d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > Should Trans Women Be Able To
Prev1111213141520Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 6,793
Joined: Sep 25 2004
Gold: 2.51
Apr 3 2022 11:03am
Quote (NetflixAdaptationWidow @ Apr 3 2022 09:57am)
And by "lead to tweaked performance" you mean "massive improvements". The records for both men and women are still trending downward. We will have to see how the future shakes out, but it's very much a possibility that women overtake men's records in the future as procedures get optimized.

There's another issue still dominating, and that's that men still have much easier access to individualized training than women because of the lack of overall scientific progress on women's sports. Women still aren't up to parity in support systems and still have a ways to go before we can say the playing field is truly level.



You don’t understand biology or bone or muscle structure. Lemme try this. You have a Ferrari and a Honda. You can paint the Honda. You can put better fuel into it. You can put a Ferrari body on it. The true Ferrari will always be faster. Now a Honda is safer. It’s better on fuel efficiency. It’s cleaner. It has all its own goodness. Make sense? Men are bigger, faster, stronger, period. Always will be. Welcome to planet earth. It’s the case a lot. There’s also a lot where the female is bigger, faster, stronger. People are not one. That doesn’t make men bad or women bad it’s how reality works.

This post was edited by justhackitup on Apr 3 2022 11:04am
Member
Posts: 45,719
Joined: Aug 25 2008
Gold: 40,130.00
Apr 3 2022 11:18am
Quote (NetflixAdaptationWidow @ 4 Apr 2022 00:54)
Sorry you live in such a shitty place.


Look , it wouldnt be fair to say that he live in a shitty place.
Different culture, different political system and way of life should be considered.
I do not question your humanity, as a matter of fact humanity is an extremely important facet of life.

That being said, there must be at certain point that a line have to be drawn.
I can see that you are quite liberal in your thinking but please correct me if I am wrong.
You might be living in a place where there is a decent amount of diversity .

It is extremely hard to balance, but perhaps you should look into different culture and different race have a different mindset. There are certain things that is a taboo and no no for certain people and culture.

I am not sure if I am giving a good analogy but please bear with me.

Its like a group of Muslim going to Texas and they take up a whole town and declare Sharia law.
It will raise more than just eyebrows.

This post was edited by Hamsterbaby on Apr 3 2022 11:19am
Member
Posts: 64,763
Joined: Oct 25 2006
Gold: 0.00
Apr 3 2022 11:23am
Quote (Hamsterbaby @ Apr 3 2022 12:18pm)
Look , it wouldnt be fair to say that he live in a shitty place.
Different culture, different political system and way of life should be considered.
I do not question your humanity, as a matter of fact humanity is an extremely important facet of life.

That being said, there must be at certain point that a line have to be drawn.
I can see that you are quite liberal in your thinking but please correct me if I am wrong.
You might be living in a place where there is a decent amount of diversity .

It is extremely hard to balance, but perhaps you should look into different culture and different race have a different mindset. There are certain things that is a taboo and no no for certain people and culture.

I am not sure if I am giving a good analogy but please bear with me.

Its like a group of Muslim going to Texas and they take up a whole town and declare Sharia law.
It will raise more than just eyebrows.


Except it wouldn't be like Muslims going to declare Sharia law. That would be restrictive. I am advocating for less restrictions, and more personal decision making, and less violence.

I think you live in a much worse place because people attack trans people. I think violence like that is pretty undefendable, and should be condemned.

Quote (justhackitup @ Apr 3 2022 12:03pm)
You don’t understand biology or bone or muscle structure. Lemme try this. You have a Ferrari and a Honda. You can paint the Honda. You can put better fuel into it. You can put a Ferrari body on it. The true Ferrari will always be faster. Now a Honda is safer. It’s better on fuel efficiency. It’s cleaner. It has all its own goodness. Make sense? Men are bigger, faster, stronger, period. Always will be. Welcome to planet earth. It’s the case a lot. There’s also a lot where the female is bigger, faster, stronger. People are not one. That doesn’t make men bad or women bad it’s how reality works.


I guarantee I understand more biology than you do :)

The fact that you think you can compare human bodies to cars is a pretty good testament to that.

The world and biology is much more complicated than "men stronger". Sports aren't really a test of pure strength.

This post was edited by NetflixAdaptationWidow on Apr 3 2022 11:25am
Member
Posts: 6,793
Joined: Sep 25 2004
Gold: 2.51
Apr 3 2022 11:27am
Quote (NetflixAdaptationWidow @ Apr 3 2022 10:23am)
Except it wouldn't be like Muslims going to declare Sharia law. That would be restrictive. I am advocating for less restrictions, and more personal decision making, and less violence.

I think you live in a much worse place because people attack trans people. I think violence like that is pretty undefendable, and should be condemned.



I guarantee I understand more biology than you do :)

The fact that you think you can compare human bodies to cars is a pretty good testament to that.



NBA average height - 6’6”
WNBA average height - 6’

If you think the men in the nba wouldn’t absolutely destroy any wnba team its a joke and a bad one.

This post was edited by justhackitup on Apr 3 2022 11:27am
Member
Posts: 64,763
Joined: Oct 25 2006
Gold: 0.00
Apr 3 2022 11:30am
Quote (justhackitup @ Apr 3 2022 12:27pm)
NBA average height - 6’6”
WNBA average height - 6’

If you think the men in the nba wouldn’t absolutely destroy any wnba team its a joke and a bad one.


You're doing that thing that a lot of transphobes do. I say the world is more complicated than that, and you insist that I don't believe that average differences between sexes exist.

Maybe, instead of assuming I don't know basic biology, you actually engage in an honest dialogue and read what I said. Like how this conversation started out with my suggestion that we create tiered sports around important factors. Like height in basketball.
Member
Posts: 23,970
Joined: Feb 28 2007
Gold: 35,554.14
Warn: 10%
Apr 3 2022 11:30am
Quote (NetflixAdaptationWidow @ Apr 3 2022 12:23pm)
Except it wouldn't be like Muslims going to declare Sharia law. That would be restrictive. I am advocating for less restrictions, and more personal decision making, and less violence.

I think you live in a much worse place because people attack trans people. I think violence like that is pretty undefendable, and should be condemned.



I guarantee I understand more biology than you do :)

The fact that you think you can compare human bodies to cars is a pretty good testament to that.

The world and biology is much more complicated than "men stronger". Sports aren't really a test of pure strength.


Now tell us about how great fat pride is.
Member
Posts: 45,719
Joined: Aug 25 2008
Gold: 40,130.00
Apr 3 2022 11:32am
Quote (NetflixAdaptationWidow @ 4 Apr 2022 01:23)
Except it wouldn't be like Muslims going to declare Sharia law. That would be restrictive. I am advocating for less restrictions, and more personal decision making, and less violence.

I think you live in a much worse place because people attack trans people. I think violence like that is pretty undefendable, and should be condemned.



Personally i dont live in a place where we attack Trans people.
We just don't bother to make an issue out if we know they are Trans.
I believe the current Trans movement have blown everything out of proportion and is in fact detrimental to them.

For the past perhaps 24 years, that i have live in my country no one actually talk about them.
The older generation will probably say something but it is more or less when they are having a private conversation.
Member
Posts: 64,763
Joined: Oct 25 2006
Gold: 0.00
Apr 3 2022 11:41am
Quote (Hamsterbaby @ Apr 3 2022 12:32pm)
Personally i dont live in a place where we attack Trans people.
We just don't bother to make an issue out if we know they are Trans.
I believe the current Trans movement have blown everything out of proportion and is in fact detrimental to them.

For the past perhaps 24 years, that i have live in my country no one actually talk about them.
The older generation will probably say something but it is more or less when they are having a private conversation.


Here's the thing. Trans people aren't blowing it out of proportion. It's conservatives using trans issues as a way to motivate their base.

Here in the U.S. trans people weren't even on the radar until Republicans decided to make trans bathrom bills a national issue.

This is what conservatives in the U.S. do. They take a pretty obvious issue, lie about it, and then make it a national issue so they can distract the populace. Trans people were doing sports and using bathrooms for a long time, and nobody really gave a shit until Republicans decided to make it an issue.

The issue of trans people in sports is so massively overblown that even female cisgender people who perform well are getting called men and being forced to do testosterone tests and have their genitals examined.


This is also what happened with CRT. CRT is a pretty obvious thing. Racist laws were made a long time ago. We got rid of explicitly racist laws, but the effects still remain to a great degree, and some laws were made with racial motivations that never got removed. Oh look, that means we still have racially motivated laws and outcomes.

Pretty obvious right? Yeah, you'd think. Then Republicans explicitly decided to lie about CRT and claim it is a system to make whites hate themselves for being white and indoctrinate your kids into hating themselves.


This happens pretty often in the U.S.

This post was edited by NetflixAdaptationWidow on Apr 3 2022 11:43am
Member
Posts: 45,719
Joined: Aug 25 2008
Gold: 40,130.00
Apr 3 2022 11:49am
Quote (NetflixAdaptationWidow @ 4 Apr 2022 01:41)
Here's the thing. Trans people aren't blowing it out of proportion. It's conservatives using trans issues as a way to motivate their base.

Here in the U.S. trans people weren't even on the radar until Republicans decided to make trans bathrom bills a national issue.

This is what conservatives in the U.S. do. They take a pretty obvious issue, lie about it, and then make it a national issue so they can distract the populace. Trans people were doing sports and using bathrooms for a long time, and nobody really gave a shit until Republicans decided to make it an issue.

The issue of trans people in sports is so massively overblown that even female cisgender people who perform well are getting called men and being forced to do testosterone tests and have their genitals examined.


This is also what happened with CRT. CRT is a pretty obvious thing. Racist laws were made a long time ago. We got rid of explicitly racist laws, but the effects still remain to a great degree, and some laws were made with racial motivations that never got removed. Oh look, that means we still have racially motivated laws and outcomes.

Pretty obvious right? Yeah, you'd think. Then Republicans explicitly decided to lie about CRT and claim it is a system to make whites hate themselves for being white and indoctrinate your kids into hating themselves.


This happens pretty often in the U.S.


I think the issue with USA politics are too divided in the current climate. But from what I have seen or at least what I know, please pardon me because I do not live in the USA.
They are promoting that if you dont date a trans you are naturally a Transphobe, but correct me if I am wrong.
Even some actress and actors are trying to convince their kids that they dont belong to what they are biologically born with and try to change their nature.

If such situation is true and I do hope I am wrong, then it will be a huge challenge to the conservatives.
Member
Posts: 45,719
Joined: Aug 25 2008
Gold: 40,130.00
Apr 3 2022 11:55am

As a matter of fact, I know a few friends who dated transgenders before. They are extremely private about it, but their "girlfriend" have told them beforehand and they accepted it.
But then again the transgender in my country or in my region are very very feminine.

They look like that , as a matter of fact the pictures i posted below are all transgender.

Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev1111213141520Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll