d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate >
Poll > Trump 2016 > Trump Vs Clinton
Prev1117911801181118211833169Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
  Guests cannot view or vote in polls. Please register or login.
Member
Posts: 57,901
Joined: Dec 3 2008
Gold: 286.00
Feb 10 2017 03:47pm
Quote (tman65ky @ Feb 10 2017 04:36pm)
Most of the homeless population is homeless due to substance abuse and or mental illness. I agree with you though that we need to do more to help them and we could if we changed welfare laws.


How do you know this again? I feel like a lot of people just assume this. Where did you learn this?

The biggest reason for homelessness is lack of affordable housing according to the vast majority of studies I've been exposed to. The number one reason families lose their home is medical bankruptcy, usually for a physical injury and not mental health reasons.

A lot of homeless people aren't addicts or crazy. It is easy to write them off as such because it is easier to believe that people end up that way due to a moral failing or poor decision making, but sometimes they just got hurt at work or their wife got sick and they couldn't afford their mortgage.
Member
Posts: 1,486
Joined: Feb 8 2017
Gold: 0.00
Warn: 20%
Feb 10 2017 03:48pm
Quote (Skinned @ Feb 10 2017 10:47pm)
How do you know this again? I feel like a lot of people just assume this. Where did you learn this?

The biggest reason for homelessness is lack of affordable housing according to the vast majority of studies I've been exposed to. The number one reason families lose their home is medical bankruptcy, usually for a physical injury and not mental health reasons.

A lot of homeless people aren't addicts or crazy. It is easy to write them off as such because it is easier to believe that people end up that way due to a moral failing or poor decision making, but sometimes they just got hurt at work or their wife got sick and they couldn't afford their mortgage.


bad commie
Member
Posts: 49,289
Joined: Jun 18 2006
Gold: 11.77
Feb 10 2017 03:53pm
Quote (Skinned @ Feb 10 2017 04:47pm)
How do you know this again? I feel like a lot of people just assume this. Where did you learn this?

The biggest reason for homelessness is lack of affordable housing according to the vast majority of studies I've been exposed to. The number one reason families lose their home is medical bankruptcy, usually for a physical injury and not mental health reasons.

A lot of homeless people aren't addicts or crazy. It is easy to write them off as such because it is easier to believe that people end up that way due to a moral failing or poor decision making, but sometimes they just got hurt at work or their wife got sick and they couldn't afford their mortgage.


Enlightened right-wingers such as myself don't view mental problems(including addiction) as moral failings.

Actually, most people don't view mental illness as a moral failing, but addiction is another story.

This post was edited by IceMage on Feb 10 2017 03:54pm
Member
Posts: 66,666
Joined: May 17 2005
Gold: 17,384.69
Feb 10 2017 03:55pm
Quote (BiGBraD @ 10 Feb 2017 22:48)
bad commie


he's right about medical bankruptcy....

Thats pretty weird because it's something that just doesnt exist here in france.

they show it at tv-circus like this:





This post was edited by Saucisson6000 on Feb 10 2017 03:56pm
Member
Posts: 93,031
Joined: Dec 31 2007
Gold: 2,214.94
Feb 10 2017 04:02pm
Quote (IceMage @ Feb 10 2017 03:53pm)
Enlightened right-wingers such as myself don't view mental problems(including addiction) as moral failings.

Actually, most people don't view mental illness as a moral failing, but addiction is another story.


what if its addiction brought on by a mental illness tho
Member
Posts: 50,946
Joined: Jan 20 2010
Gold: 5,335.99
Feb 10 2017 04:15pm
Quote (IceMage @ Feb 10 2017 03:53pm)
Enlightened right-wingers such as myself don't view mental problems(including addiction) as moral failings.

Actually, most people don't view mental illness as a moral failing, but addiction is another story.


Meanwhile I reject the dichotomy of mental illness and free will entirely. People are bags of flesh and fluid and our decision making is a product of our chemical 'imbalances' and neurons firing off, we are all machines however complex. A physical addiction may provide a strong influence towards shaping behaviors that won't be overcome by personality. If its within our power to fix the addiction, we can remove it as an influence in that persons judgement and return them to being a functional member of society. Fixing influences of violent disposition due to more complex character flaws might be outside our current technological powers. Maybe in the future being a sociopath will be curable instead of merely medicated into submission., maybe we'll perform reconstructive surgery on the brains of infants with autism using nanobots. If we want to separate what "mental illnesses can be effectively treated" versus "decisions arising from complex and irreducible personality flaws", thats fine. Addiction has pretty discrete pathology.
Member
Posts: 32,103
Joined: Dec 29 2009
Gold: 0.00
Feb 10 2017 04:16pm
Quote (thesnipa @ Feb 10 2017 04:02pm)
what if its addiction brought on by a mental illness tho


Addiction is it's own mental illness. It's a separate diagnosis. It frequently goes hand in hand with other mental health issues, like depression/bi-polar/etc, but it is separate.

Unless you're simply referring the physical manifestation of addiction brought on by another mental health issue, in which case carry on. :)
Member
Posts: 93,031
Joined: Dec 31 2007
Gold: 2,214.94
Feb 10 2017 04:19pm
Quote (Surfpunk @ Feb 10 2017 04:16pm)
Addiction is it's own mental illness. It's a separate diagnosis. It frequently goes hand in hand with other mental health issues, like depression/bi-polar/etc, but it is separate.

Unless you're simply referring the physical manifestation of addiction brought on by another mental health issue, in which case carry on. :)


i was actually just being a smart ass :rofl:

i've personally seen a lot of abuse tied to depression/bipolar from people i know....
Member
Posts: 63,058
Joined: Jul 15 2005
Gold: 152.00
Feb 10 2017 04:52pm
Quote (Goomshill @ Feb 10 2017 05:15pm)
Meanwhile I reject the dichotomy of mental illness and free will entirely. People are bags of flesh and fluid and our decision making is a product of our chemical 'imbalances' and neurons firing off, we are all machines however complex. A physical addiction may provide a strong influence towards shaping behaviors that won't be overcome by personality. If its within our power to fix the addiction, we can remove it as an influence in that persons judgement and return them to being a functional member of society. Fixing influences of violent disposition due to more complex character flaws might be outside our current technological powers. Maybe in the future being a sociopath will be curable instead of merely medicated into submission., maybe we'll perform reconstructive surgery on the brains of infants with autism using nanobots. If we want to separate what "mental illnesses can be effectively treated" versus "decisions arising from complex and irreducible personality flaws", thats fine. Addiction has pretty discrete pathology.


The most likely and most profound medical interventions in the future will IMO be genetic technologies, esp. CRISPR.
Member
Posts: 57,901
Joined: Dec 3 2008
Gold: 286.00
Feb 10 2017 07:14pm
I'll be back to discuss this topic, especially what Mr. Shill has to say. It is a topic I love ☺ and am quite invested in. I'm a couple cocktails into the night and seeing some stand-up comedy soon so it will be tomorrow.

Quote (thesnipa @ Feb 10 2017 05:19pm)
i was actually just being a smart ass :rofl:

i've personally seen a lot of abuse tied to depression/bipolar from people i know....


Self-medication is real. When social systems fail the masses need an opiate.

This post was edited by Skinned on Feb 10 2017 07:16pm
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev1117911801181118211833169Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll