d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > Forced Gender Transitions In California
Prev1101112131415Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 64,763
Joined: Oct 25 2006
Gold: 0.00
Jul 17 2020 11:30am
Quote (thesnipa @ Jul 17 2020 12:27pm)
i wont even entertain that idea. suicide by trans people comes from family stress, an inability to express the gender they want to, and peer mockery. removing one of 3 factors, while also removing a child from the home and introducing a new stress factor, reducing suicide rate by 90%? we'd have to make a complete societal change in 10 years so children dont mock trans people, we know that's not happening.

but i can see LGBTQAdvocates.com releasing a "study" that says that.


Like I said, we would need to wait and see the the results. Depending on the results that's not a bad thing.

We could also make that change in 10 years. Gay acceptance went from virtually non-existent in 2000 to the majority opinion in 2010 and now the default position in 2020.
Member
Posts: 93,001
Joined: Dec 31 2007
Gold: 2,299.94
Jul 17 2020 11:34am
Quote (Thor123422 @ Jul 17 2020 12:30pm)
Like I said, we would need to wait and see the the results. Depending on the results that's not a bad thing.

We could also make that change in 10 years. Gay acceptance went from virtually non-existent in 2000 to the majority opinion in 2010 and now the default position in 2020.


let's wait and see isn't an argument, its delaying an argument lol. we can wait and see if studies come out that black people are predisposed to violence, or wait to see studies on white people being worse at swimming, or w/e. nor does it address silencing around studies perceived as anti trans. nor does it address parent's rights being superseded by something that doesnt reduce harm, simply reduces risk, according to studies with an agenda.

but lol at the last part, kids are still gonna make fun of gay kids and trans kids 50 years from now. come on, we both know that. we're talking puberty blockers here, not something for college age kids, which also get mocked for being gay/trans now despite it being the "default".
Member
Posts: 61,688
Joined: Mar 14 2006
Gold: 28.77
Jul 17 2020 11:49am
Quote (Goomshill @ Jul 17 2020 12:22am)
No not really, HRT usually only involves estrodial as a female hormone, combined with spironolactone as an antiandrogen. Everything past that is superfluous, like the dubious use of progesterone. Or the use of analogs like GnRH, same thing.
Go look up any recommended HRT dosages and prescriptions, its not some cocktail of hormones.



He isn’t being given spiro.


Also, he isn’t an innocent child if he’s in prison for raping someone.
Member
Posts: 57,901
Joined: Dec 3 2008
Gold: 286.00
Jul 17 2020 11:49am
Quote (thesnipa @ Jul 17 2020 01:27pm)
i wont even entertain that idea. suicide by trans people comes from family stress, an inability to express the gender they want to, and peer mockery. removing one of 3 factors, while also removing a child from the home and introducing a new stress factor, reducing suicide rate by 90%? we'd have to make a complete societal change in 10 years so children dont mock trans people, we know that's not happening.

but i can see LGBTQAdvocates.com releasing a "study" that says that.


The trans kids at my daughters school didn't seem to be treated poorly.
Member
Posts: 93,001
Joined: Dec 31 2007
Gold: 2,299.94
Jul 17 2020 11:51am
Quote (Skinned @ Jul 17 2020 12:49pm)
The trans kids at my daughters school didn't seem to be treated poorly.


if i went to school with 100 other kids and 90 of them were perfectly accepting and nice the 10 who mocked me would still give me issues. i think we've just moved the 90 and the 10, and i dont see a way to crack 10%. 10% of any population are complete assholes, bullies, etc.

This post was edited by thesnipa on Jul 17 2020 11:51am
Member
Posts: 28,884
Joined: Aug 11 2013
Gold: 10,712.00
Jul 17 2020 11:51am
Quote (Skinned @ Jul 17 2020 12:36pm)
No, just calling out fake tears and concern thats all.

This is an informed consent issue. I ask who is guardian because its important. You are ignorant and don't understand that patents lose rights to kids if they don't do well and often incarcerated children have legal guardians that are lawyers or social workers and not families.

So if a court appointed guardian consented to non-evidenced based treatment of a behavioral disorder then it is way beyond even an informed consent issue and it becomes a systemic problem at that point, but there is no reason to discuss systemic problems in one area to someone who i know doesn't understand systemic problems in another area because that's the same level of abstraction.


The fact that the parents are bringing this suit should tell you that they are legal guardians no? Scary fucking world we're coming to when bureaucrats could be in charge of deciding whether a kid is okay to be a boy or if we don't like his behavior lets make him more female like.

And @bolded, naw dawg. That's only part of the issue, the other that you keep pivoting away from is the fact that they administered a experimental 'treatment' one that's not supported by science for ODD. There is no 'well it depends' here. Doctors, social workers, lawyers don't get to just make shit up as they go contrary to science or established treatment procedures just because they have the winds of leftists sjw politics at their back.
Member
Posts: 22,442
Joined: Mar 3 2007
Gold: 76.11
Jul 17 2020 11:52am
Quote (ofthevoid @ Jul 17 2020 06:24am)
Just funny how the posse of leftist that condone and actively push forward such regressive policies are attacking Goom for daring to speak about it.


:rofl:
Member
Posts: 35,291
Joined: Aug 17 2004
Gold: 12,730.67
Jul 17 2020 11:58am
Quote (ofthevoid @ Jul 17 2020 10:51am)
The fact that the parents are bringing this suit should tell you that they are legal guardians no? Scary fucking world we're coming to when bureaucrats could be in charge of deciding whether a kid is okay to be a boy or if we don't like his behavior lets make him more female like.

And @bolded, naw dawg. That's only part of the issue, the other that you keep pivoting away from is the fact that they administered a experimental 'treatment' one that's not supported by science for ODD. There is no 'well it depends' here. Doctors, social workers, lawyers don't get to just make shit up as they go contrary to science or established treatment procedures just because they have the winds of leftists sjw politics at their back.


No one has said otherwise lol. These people deserve to lose whatever license they have, their job, and maybe face criminal charges depending on what the law is. We're just piling on Goom because he clearly jumped the gun on this.
Member
Posts: 78,723
Joined: Nov 30 2008
Gold: 493.00
Jul 17 2020 11:58am
Quote (Thor123422 @ Jul 17 2020 12:37pm)
hot take: depending on the medical literature at the time that won't necessarily be the incorrect thing to do


Its gonna be an interesting time to be alive when the sjws silencing dissenting thought in the medical community and academia mobilize child protection sevices to pull kids away from parents to bolster the army of the trans.

This could be a michael bay movie.
Member
Posts: 50,915
Joined: Jan 20 2010
Gold: 5,335.99
Jul 17 2020 12:07pm
Quote (ofthevoid @ Jul 17 2020 12:51pm)
The fact that the parents are bringing this suit should tell you that they are legal guardians no? Scary fucking world we're coming to when bureaucrats could be in charge of deciding whether a kid is okay to be a boy or if we don't like his behavior lets make him more female like.

And @bolded, naw dawg. That's only part of the issue, the other that you keep pivoting away from is the fact that they administered a experimental 'treatment' one that's not supported by science for ODD. There is no 'well it depends' here. Doctors, social workers, lawyers don't get to just make shit up as they go contrary to science or established treatment procedures just because they have the winds of leftists sjw politics at their back.


They want to make it an 'informed consent' issue to avoid talking about how inherently wrong it is to torture children based off some wild social/political theory dressed up under the pretenses of medical science. As if they're the first generation of social crusaders to ever have this hubris and they'll get it right this time. Hedging posts to avoid saying that using gender transition as a treatment for ODD is wrong even if the DMS-V and leading experts say it has no basis- because in a few years, it very well might be the new "accepted" standard, at least in Californian groupthink. All it takes is a few intrepid scientists willing to push boundaries and conduct social experiments and they can pave the way, even if they're paving over a few mutilated children.

We long since left behind the concepts of bodily integrity and natural development being sacrosanct and have no qualms about selectively editing the hippocratic oath. Now "consent" is just a minor bump in the road to be trod over by saying the will of a child and parents don't matter, its up to government authorities to make determinations what is best for your body. And Thor wants to see the results from the Mengele experiments to determine whether forcibly feminizing a pubescent boy with gender transition drugs is an effective way to turn rebelliousness and defiance into meekness and compliance.
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev1101112131415Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll