Quote (Taurean @ 30 Jun 2022 18:51)
I guess it is a very complex and difficult question.
Analyzing the internal philosophy and mass psychology: It is important for human beings to feel that we get revenge. And it is absurd when sometimes the person murdered gets a worse funeral or send-off than the murderer, depending on the circumstances. Even still, after everything is said and done, looking back to how we do things as a society, even in the most difficult matters as these, not lowering ourselves to the level of the murderer i think does something to us as a community. We send a signal to others that if we manage to stand above the actions of those that are in the darkest parts of life, everything we live for and stand for becomes more wortwhile. We don't give them a funeral to honor the murderer, but those that are murdered. They can't utter their wishes, and if they had been alive, maybe some of them would want it that way. And that is what we should consider.
It is very difficult and complex. Our first instinct is to mutilate and hang the body for mockery and dishonor. But our first instincts are often the most short-sighted. Our last instinct is forgiveness, and i personally do not expect anyone to forgive a murderer or any criminal. But for a society to continue on and grow, forgiveness is the last and most long-sighted emotion. And if we manage to stay true to that, we stay true to the best emotions that we have as a humanity. And there is no mistake; A murderer's life is obviously black and very problematic. If just to have 0.01% of light can make a difference for our society, giving them a funeral is a way to do that.
Providing tens or hundreds of thousands of taxpayers dollars for the funeral of a murderous psychopath who was a danger to society is not "making a difference for society" but rather causing yet another drain on society.
As already stated, charge Gascon, personally. As in, he has no choice. Garnish his pay, 100% of his pay, until the funeral is 100% paid for. He chose not to prosecute, he chose to let people out. He went against the will of the voters and their representatives. He chose to become a law into himself, so he is welcome to pay the consequences.
You don't need to lower yourself to the level of the murderer. Justice is based on the theory of "Do unto others as they have done unto you" with morality-based limitations. So if a serial killer murders and eats 27 people, you don't murder the serial killer and eat them. But you do tend to sentence them to swift and merciful death, for the sake of society.
A murderer is never not a murderer. Murder once, and you're a murderer for life. Same as a Cannibal, same as many other terrible things. Robbing from the average citizen at gunpoint (taxing them) to pay for lavish funerals for murderers, when the taxpayers already agreed to and supported laws that would have prevented the most recent murders perpetrated by said murderer?
Politicians lie to get in office, everywhere, all the time, and always have. Being taken in by a lie shouldn't put you on the hook for supporting a murderer. Prove they did it, remove their head from their body, cremate their remains, throw the ash into the nearest stand of pine or fir trees, and continue about your day.