d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > Communism Vs Fascism
Prev12348Next
Closed New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 53,552
Joined: Mar 6 2008
Gold: 1,908.33
Jan 7 2021 01:37am
Quote (CiroC @ Jan 7 2021 02:21am)
We dont know for sure whether or not Socialism has caused more deaths. What we do know are the outcomes of WWI, WWII and Civil War.


You are literally a genocide denier. wow.

This makes me think about what the proper responses are to people like this.

Not good dude.

Quote
no i am asking this question to people like you specifically. Why so focused on the far left being bad? Trump's fascism, brain washing has done wonders to you it looks like.


Because the far left and democrat authoritarianism are clearly on the rise and not getting enough push back.
That is clearly a far more important problem to me than any mean words Trump might have said to swamp creatures on his way out.

Trump's actual policies are not that far out of line with recent presidents, with some significant good differences. The idea that its some terrible and uniquely fascist presidency is not tied to reality.
Member
Posts: 32,450
Joined: Jul 9 2007
Gold: 15.00
Jan 7 2021 01:40am
Quote (InsaneBobb @ Jan 6 2021 11:30pm)
Communism and Socialism are both on the left. Nazis were leftists, they were not on the right. The right, simply put, is self-ownership and personal responsibility. The left is state ownership, and responsibility to the state. It was the ultra conservative pro-liberty (by today's standards) far right Americans who defeated the Nazis, the Soviets, and combatted the excesses of the Chinese.

Communism and Socialism are both anti-liberty. They both hand the government all the power to destroy the freedom and liberty of the individual. It's no shock that the Democratic Party of the United States of America, the party of the KKK, is now turning to socialism and communism as a way to reinstate ownership of other people.

Now before you start spewing garbage about China and the Soviet Union and other such not being "real communism" let's face the reality of human nature here: Communism always devolves down to might makes right. No utopian vision can exist without enforcement. He/She who commands the enforcers takes control and dictates the lives of all. Communism is not viable on a large stage.


They might;ve started out Socialism but once Hitler took over, it was no longer Socialism, Same thing with Mussolini.
Member
Posts: 66,666
Joined: May 17 2005
Gold: 17,384.69
Jan 7 2021 01:42am
Quote (InsaneBobb @ 7 Jan 2021 08:30)
Communism and Socialism are both on the left. Nazis were leftists, they were not on the right. The right, simply put, is self-ownership and personal responsibility. The left is state ownership, and responsibility to the state. It was the ultra conservative pro-liberty (by today's standards) far right Americans who defeated the Nazis, the Soviets, and combatted the excesses of the Chinese.

Communism and Socialism are both anti-liberty. They both hand the government all the power to destroy the freedom and liberty of the individual. It's no shock that the Democratic Party of the United States of America, the party of the KKK, is now turning to socialism and communism as a way to reinstate ownership of other people.

Now before you start spewing garbage about China and the Soviet Union and other such not being "real communism" let's face the reality of human nature here: Communism always devolves down to might makes right. No utopian vision can exist without enforcement. He/She who commands the enforcers takes control and dictates the lives of all. Communism is not viable on a large stage.


Yes, and "personal reponsibilty" will be: take the power & wealth at any cost, even lying, saying you are a communist to attract more votes.
I understand that if you cannot even understand the essence of far right & fascism, our discussions have no way out.

I means; Hitler and moderated american independents conservatives are boths on the right oh lol ok.
Member
Posts: 32,450
Joined: Jul 9 2007
Gold: 15.00
Jan 7 2021 01:43am
Quote (cambovenzi @ Jan 6 2021 11:37pm)
You are literally a genocide denier. wow.

This makes me think about what the proper responses are to people like this.

Not good dude.



Because the far left and democrat authoritarianism are clearly on the rise and not getting enough push back.
That is clearly a far more important problem to me than any mean words Trump might have said to swamp creatures on his way out.

Trump's actual policies are not that far out of line with recent presidents, with some significant good differences. The idea that its some terrible and uniquely fascist presidency is not tied to reality.


No one said Far left is good...im just trying to see why aren't we worried about far right??
Member
Posts: 21,486
Joined: Jul 21 2005
Gold: 438.40
Jan 7 2021 01:45am
Quote (Plaguefear @ 6 Jan 2021 23:33)
Nazi's were leftists? LOL
Ill ignore the part about america defeating the nazi's.


Left: Government has rights, people do not, beyond what the government grants them. Government has ownership over all.

Right: Individuals have rights, governments exist to serve the individual, and only has those rights the individuals give to them, individuals have ownerships over themselves and their private property.

The Nazis and Soviets were equally far left. The attempt to pronounce "populism" as a "far right" ideal in order to portray the Nazis as far right is simply a lie. Populists exist on the entire spectrum, as do globalists. All populism is is the belief that the actions of a state's government should all be directed towards the well-being of the people of that state. Globalism is the belief that the state's government should take actions that are seen as beneficial to the entire planet. The Nazis may have called themselves populists, but they weren't, were they? They didn't focus on improving their own state, instead, they attempted to expand their state to encompass the entire globe. Rather than using relatively peaceful political and capital means to accomplish a takeover of the world into their ideals, they sought to use violence. But their end goal was to turn the entire planet into one state. AKA globalization. And in the end, all power and ownership in the Nazi state rested in the hands of the government. While personal property did exist, it was so highly regulated and dictated by the government, that individuals could not be said to truly "own" anything at all.

Your argument lacks consistency.

This post was edited by InsaneBobb on Jan 7 2021 01:48am
Member
Posts: 30,165
Joined: Sep 10 2004
Gold: 0.00
Warn: 30%
Jan 7 2021 01:47am
Quote (InsaneBobb @ 7 Jan 2021 08:30)
Communism and Socialism are both on the left. Nazis were leftists, they were not on the right. The right, simply put, is self-ownership and personal responsibility. The left is state ownership, and responsibility to the state. It was the ultra conservative pro-liberty (by today's standards) far right Americans who defeated the Nazis, the Soviets, and combatted the excesses of the Chinese.

Communism and Socialism are both anti-liberty. They both hand the government all the power to destroy the freedom and liberty of the individual. It's no shock that the Democratic Party of the United States of America, the party of the KKK, is now turning to socialism and communism as a way to reinstate ownership of other people.

Now before you start spewing garbage about China and the Soviet Union and other such not being "real communism" let's face the reality of human nature here: Communism always devolves down to might makes right. No utopian vision can exist without enforcement. He/She who commands the enforcers takes control and dictates the lives of all. Communism is not viable on a large stage.


holy fuck. how gullible can one person be? do you ever question ANYTHING you're told? because that idiotic talking point has debunked into oblivion (by historians, political scientists, and people with a working brain) about a million times.



Member
Posts: 53,552
Joined: Mar 6 2008
Gold: 1,908.33
Jan 7 2021 01:48am
Quote (IroningTheMaiden @ Jan 7 2021 02:37am)
no nazis were far right.

yikes


Thats what we were told to believe, sure.

The left/right paradigm is an inadequate oversimplification of issues.

Nazism is a variant of socialism.
An authoritarian collectivist ideology involving high government control of person and property. Fascism has an incredible amount of overlap with progressivism and other socialist regimes.
Its not a right wing opposite of communism, contrary to how its often portrayed.

The modern right are not the ones interested in strict regimentation and government control of business and property. That is what the leftists/democrats are advocating.
Member
Posts: 32,450
Joined: Jul 9 2007
Gold: 15.00
Jan 7 2021 01:50am
Quote (InsaneBobb @ Jan 6 2021 11:45pm)
Left: Government has rights, people do not, beyond what the government grants them. Government has ownership over all.

Right: Individuals have rights, governments exist to serve the individual, and only has those rights the individuals give to them, individuals have ownerships over themselves and their private property.

The Nazis and Soviets were equally far left. The attempt to pronounce "populism" as a "far right" ideal in order to portray the Nazis as far right is simply a lie. Populists exist on the entire spectrum, as do globalists. All populism is is the belief that the actions of a state's government should all be directed towards the well-being of the people of that state. Globalism is the belief that the state's government should take actions that are seen as beneficial to the entire planet. The Nazis may have called themselves populists, but they weren't, were they? They didn't focus on improving their own state, instead, they attempted to expand their state to encompass the entire globe. Rather than using relatively peaceful political and capital means to accomplish a takeover of the world into their ideals, they sought to use violence. But their end goal was to turn the entire planet into one state. AKA globalization.

Your argument lacks consistency.


i think you need a better understanding of each terms..
u do know that far right...Fascism is also dictatorship right? Both Far left and Far right are dictators...
Member
Posts: 30,165
Joined: Sep 10 2004
Gold: 0.00
Warn: 30%
Jan 7 2021 01:57am
Quote (cambovenzi @ 7 Jan 2021 08:48)
Thats what we were told to believe


i've only ever read reliably researched, well educated, and completely sane stuff after such an introduction.

*tips tin foil fedora
Member
Posts: 21,486
Joined: Jul 21 2005
Gold: 438.40
Jan 7 2021 01:59am
Quote (CiroC @ 6 Jan 2021 23:50)
i think you need a better understanding of each terms..
u do know that far right...Fascism is also dictatorship right? Both Far left and Far right are dictators...


Left: Government has rights, people do not, beyond what the government grants them. Government has ownership over all.

Right: Individuals have rights, governments exist to serve the individual, and only has those rights the individuals give to them, individuals have ownerships over themselves and their private property.

How many times do I need to repeat this? Fascism is not possible under far right ideals, as the ideals of the far right is that you own your shit (including your own self) and nobody can tell you anything what to do with it. You have beachfront property and want to dump toxic waste in the water? Go ahead! Nobody can stop you. The "far right" at it's most extreme not only denies any form of fascism or communism, they promote active anarchy in favor of absolute personal liberty. The "moderate right", classed as conservatives, believe that while you should have personal rights and personal property rights, they need to be tempered to a point where you cannot actively harm the personal rights of others. They do not believe in an overwhelming government that can dictate anything to them. They believe the government should exist only as a means to ensure mutual defense, insure uninterrupted commerce, and deal with disasters such as fire, and insure that one person doesn't violate the personal and property rights of another person (police).

The moment you say "Far right dictator" you've just shown that you're a horseshoe theorist. Or you simply don't have a clearly defined scale of what right and left really are. In which case your words AND your topic are pointless, and you have such a lack of credibility that you should be laughed out of any conversation you attempt to join. :)
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev12348Next
Closed New Topic New Poll