Also, I made it very clear to her before sex was ever even an option, that I did not under any circumstances want a baby. On top of that I'm a very shy guy, and didn't want to have sex with her in the first place, however It had been a long time, and she was very persistent despite my repeated refusals, but a guy's brain can only stay in control for so long.

i think this is a trololol

Using the same condom, nutting 3 times?
Overflowing?
....
future harvard student and still being a complete idiot?
You deserve it. You're desperate, fucking a drugged out whore who's fucking a few of your friends in the same week.

Desperate probably isn't far from the truth. She's very attractive, it had been a very long time, and I didn't know any of these things about her until recently, and I haven't had sex with her since I've found out.

But seriously
Condoms arent meant to be used more than once.
Not only that do you not jack off? or do you cum buckets everytime to overflow a condom....

Talk to her about it maybe? If shes fucking your friends then just plane innocent and you wore a rubber everytime. Most likely she was high on pills with your peter inside her.

This is the beginning of a wonderful topic:

The link between academic education and intelligence

I never used a condom more than once. I've talked with her about it extensively, but she's a woman, and therefor the conversation gets nowhere. Honestly I'm most worried about her refusing to get that thing aborted.

probably likely shes not pregnant in the first place
if she is, it prolly isnt yours anyway

but the story does sound silly...

That's got to be the best advice yet...

I jerk it multiple times daily and still cum buckets.

thanks, and I'm sure the story does sound silly, however that does not negate the truth of it.