Why do you assume that is a trait for dumb people?
Homogeny is a good thing, maybe even the best thing.
Because nobody said anything about racial homogeny. We were talking about being born in the US. You seem to have an ulterior motive
The "dumb" part is making assumptions without knowing what you're talking about. For example, if I said "you must be a poor redneck living in a trailer" that would make me dumb because there's no evidence that you are like that.
What would you choose if forced to pick between:
1. A US president born in the US, is a citizen, but is Chinese or Iranian
2. A US president not born in the US, not a citizen, but is white