d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > Israel Attacks Iran
Prev12
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 9,121
Joined: May 11 2009
Gold: 5.01
Apr 23 2024 08:45am
Quote (BaHgerAUT @ Apr 23 2024 04:08am)
a consulate in syria*


"DAMASCUS, April 1 (Reuters) - Suspected Israeli warplanes bombed Iran's embassy in Syria on Monday in a strike that Iran said killed seven of its military advisers, including three senior commanders, marking a major escalation in Israel's war with its regional adversaries."
Member
Posts: 20,044
Joined: Apr 13 2016
Gold: 32,397.50
Apr 23 2024 09:32am
Quote (RedFromWinter @ Apr 23 2024 03:45pm)
"DAMASCUS, April 1 (Reuters) - Suspected Israeli warplanes bombed Iran's embassy in Syria on Monday in a strike that Iran said killed seven of its military advisers, including three senior commanders, marking a major escalation in Israel's war with its regional adversaries."


Consulate in nothing but word. That was an IRGC command centre.
Member
Posts: 9,121
Joined: May 11 2009
Gold: 5.01
Apr 23 2024 11:10am
Quote (Prox1m1ty @ Apr 23 2024 10:32am)
Consulate in nothing but word. That was an IRGC command centre.


That's beside the point. Embassy land is internationally viewed as sovereign soil of the foreign country within the host country. Dropping a bomb on it is akin to bombing an IRGC command center in Iran national boundaries. This is the precedence majority of world has followed even during WWII era.
Member
Posts: 9,234
Joined: Jul 28 2007
Gold: 11,301.28
Apr 23 2024 11:12am
Quote (RedFromWinter @ 23 Apr 2024 19:10)
That's beside the point. Embassy land is internationally viewed as sovereign soil of the foreign country within the host country..


Wrong, that's just a myth. The attack was still on syrian soil.
Member
Posts: 9,121
Joined: May 11 2009
Gold: 5.01
Apr 23 2024 11:17am
Quote (BaHgerAUT @ Apr 23 2024 12:12pm)
Wrong, that's just a myth. The attack was still on syrian soil.


:bonk:
Member
Posts: 9,234
Joined: Jul 28 2007
Gold: 11,301.28
Apr 23 2024 11:19am
Quote (RedFromWinter @ 23 Apr 2024 19:17)
:bonk:


feel free to link the paragraph in international law you're referring to.
Member
Posts: 9,121
Joined: May 11 2009
Gold: 5.01
Apr 23 2024 11:23am
Quote (BaHgerAUT @ Apr 23 2024 12:19pm)
feel free to link the paragraph in international law you're referring to.


:bonk:
Member
Posts: 20,044
Joined: Apr 13 2016
Gold: 32,397.50
Apr 23 2024 12:08pm
Quote (RedFromWinter @ Apr 23 2024 06:10pm)
That's beside the point. Embassy land is internationally viewed as sovereign soil of the foreign country within the host country. Dropping a bomb on it is akin to bombing an IRGC command center in Iran national boundaries. This is the precedence majority of world has followed even during WWII era.


I agree. But its right to point out that if you take a school and kick out all the children then start firing rockets from the building, its no longer a school in anything but word.
Member
Posts: 9,121
Joined: May 11 2009
Gold: 5.01
Apr 23 2024 12:34pm
Quote (Prox1m1ty @ Apr 23 2024 01:08pm)
I agree. But its right to point out that if you take a school and kick out all the children then start firing rockets from the building, its no longer a school in anything but word.


Sure, that may be the case from Israel/US intelligence perspective but the site still recognized as a diplomatic location internationally. The concern is where the change in precedence will lead. Iran responded aggressively but ineffective. That does not change the precedence that diplomatic sites may be on the table for military targeting now. Well, theyve been hit by mobs and proxy groups, not so much by state govs.

If schools, hospitals, diplomatic sites are fair game we pretty far up the ladder.

This post was edited by RedFromWinter on Apr 23 2024 12:34pm
Member
Posts: 20,044
Joined: Apr 13 2016
Gold: 32,397.50
Apr 23 2024 12:48pm
Quote (RedFromWinter @ Apr 23 2024 07:34pm)
Sure, that may be the case from Israel/US intelligence perspective but the site still recognized as a diplomatic location internationally. The concern is where the change in precedence will lead. Iran responded aggressively but ineffective. That does not change the precedence that diplomatic sites may be on the table for military targeting now. Well, theyve been hit by mobs and proxy groups, not so much by state govs.

If schools, hospitals, diplomatic sites are fair game we pretty far up the ladder.


I honestly don't think its a change in precedence from Israel's perspective. Firstly because essentially Israel and Iran are at war, by proxy and by forms of espionage and now even kinetically. And secondly because Israel would argue they didn't flatten the entire embassy/consulate for the sake of it. They targeted the IRGC commanders who were using the "consulate" to organise efforts against Israel.

Not saying that I agree with Israels actions but I can see their perspective. I can also see that the internationally norm is not to do that type of thing.
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev12
Add Reply New Topic New Poll