d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > Should Child Murderers Be Sent To Prison?
Prev12347Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 23,551
Joined: Jul 3 2008
Gold: 3,479.67
Mar 8 2023 03:30pm
would be a real shame if someone takes matters into their own hands, and gave those 2 the proper punishment...

This post was edited by Warlock316 on Mar 8 2023 03:31pm
Member
Posts: 92,959
Joined: Dec 31 2007
Gold: 2,299.94
Mar 8 2023 03:31pm
Quote (excellence @ Mar 8 2023 03:27pm)
Saying no to haggis is high treason


thats a crime i can get on board with, that shit is delicious.
Member
Posts: 33,357
Joined: Dec 20 2007
Gold: 13,000.00
Mar 8 2023 03:31pm
Rage enducing.
Member
Posts: 53,368
Joined: Sep 2 2004
Gold: 57.00
Mar 8 2023 03:32pm
Quote (thesnipa @ 8 Mar 2023 16:31)
thats a crime i can get on board with, that shit is delicious.


yeah ive had it with that curry sauce or whatever. long as you dont mind ofal it’s quite good.
Member
Posts: 49,893
Joined: Jun 19 2006
Gold: 3.88
Mar 8 2023 06:16pm
Tough to say without the full context, were they in a gang?
Was this an og call?
How much influence did the adult have over the children?
Do they have real remorse?

I just can't see shit in the black and white everyone always tries to push, there are all kinds of shades.
Member
Posts: 66,666
Joined: May 17 2005
Gold: 17,384.69
Mar 8 2023 06:26pm
Quote (Plaguefear @ 9 Mar 2023 01:16)
Tough to say without the full context, were they in a gang?
Was this an og call?
How much influence did the adult have over the children?
Do they have real remorse?

I just can't see shit in the black and white everyone always tries to push, there are all kinds of shades.


heh but nuances are always colored
Member
Posts: 28,875
Joined: Aug 11 2013
Gold: 10,712.00
Mar 8 2023 07:13pm
I mean I can kind of understand the disparity because Haynes is 22 and that was his ex, so we can probably deduce that at least on some level he was the mastermind/primary planner for this crime. Then mix that in with the age of the other two and you get this.

The two younger ones (assuming not one of them pulled the trigger) are still accomplices and should probably get a harsher sentence IMO. Idk what sentencing guidelines are but slap on a wrist with minimal juvie seems lenient. Realistically the 17yr old serves 1year of juvie+ a few years of prison and 15yr old juvie until 18. If one of the younger ones pulled the trigger I think that's certainly an aggravator and to get juvie for that is injustice.
Member
Posts: 50,772
Joined: Jan 20 2010
Gold: 5,846.00
Mar 8 2023 07:29pm
Quote (ofthevoid @ Mar 8 2023 07:13pm)
I mean I can kind of understand the disparity because Haynes is 22 and that was his ex, so we can probably deduce that at least on some level he was the mastermind/primary planner for this crime. Then mix that in with the age of the other two and you get this.

The two younger ones (assuming not one of them pulled the trigger) are still accomplices and should probably get a harsher sentence IMO. Idk what sentencing guidelines are but slap on a wrist with minimal juvie seems lenient. Realistically the 17yr old serves 1year of juvie+ a few years of prison and 15yr old juvie until 18. If one of the younger ones pulled the trigger I think that's certainly an aggravator and to get juvie for that is injustice.


One of the younger ones pulled the trigger, they both broke into the house and killed her together. The 22 year old drove them to the scene, he did not enter the house.
It was a preplanned murder in cold blood of a stranger.

Zaria McKeever was the ex-girlfriend of Hayne, and had a one-year old daughter with him. She wanted a better life for her daughter and broke up with him, and Haynes stalked her and repeatedly threatened her and her new boyfriend. She already had the restraining order on him, lot of good that did. Haynes and the two Kamara brothers conspired to murder her- Haynes gave them the gun and drove them to the boyfriends apartment, planning to kill both Zaria and the boyfriend. Haynes stayed outside, the Kamara brothers kicked in the door and found Zaria, who they shot and killed. The video evidence also shows the teens staking out the apartment and stalking her prior to the murders, all the evidence of malice aforethought (and conviction without their testimony) you could ever need.

Quote (Plaguefear @ Mar 8 2023 06:16pm)
Tough to say without the full context, were they in a gang?
Was this an og call?
How much influence did the adult have over the children?
Do they have real remorse?

I just can't see shit in the black and white everyone always tries to push, there are all kinds of shades.


Based on the facts what can we say?
I can say this: Mary Moriarty campaigned not just on criminal justice reform, but specifically on lowering the prosecutions of juveniles and keeping them out of adult court. This was her explicit campaign platform, so here she is delivering on it exactly like promised. This is what the people of Brooklyn Park voted for, and hey, the Daunte Wrights of the city can get all the free passes they want now.

Particularly incoherent is that her stated rationale is that people don't have developed brains until 25 years old, but she's charging a 22 year old with an aggravated crime and seeking life in prison.
Member
Posts: 49,893
Joined: Jun 19 2006
Gold: 3.88
Mar 8 2023 08:25pm
Quote (Goomshill @ Mar 9 2023 12:29pm)
One of the younger ones pulled the trigger, they both broke into the house and killed her together. The 22 year old drove them to the scene, he did not enter the house.
It was a preplanned murder in cold blood of a stranger.

Zaria McKeever was the ex-girlfriend of Hayne, and had a one-year old daughter with him. She wanted a better life for her daughter and broke up with him, and Haynes stalked her and repeatedly threatened her and her new boyfriend. She already had the restraining order on him, lot of good that did. Haynes and the two Kamara brothers conspired to murder her- Haynes gave them the gun and drove them to the boyfriends apartment, planning to kill both Zaria and the boyfriend. Haynes stayed outside, the Kamara brothers kicked in the door and found Zaria, who they shot and killed. The video evidence also shows the teens staking out the apartment and stalking her prior to the murders, all the evidence of malice aforethought (and conviction without their testimony) you could ever need.



Based on the facts what can we say?
I can say this: Mary Moriarty campaigned not just on criminal justice reform, but specifically on lowering the prosecutions of juveniles and keeping them out of adult court. This was her explicit campaign platform, so here she is delivering on it exactly like promised. This is what the people of Brooklyn Park voted for, and hey, the Daunte Wrights of the city can get all the free passes they want now.

Particularly incoherent is that her stated rationale is that people don't have developed brains until 25 years old, but she's charging a 22 year old with an aggravated crime and seeking life in prison.


A 22 year old has a much more developed brain than a 15 year old, think of it as a sliding scale.
Member
Posts: 50,772
Joined: Jan 20 2010
Gold: 5,846.00
Mar 8 2023 08:28pm
Quote (Plaguefear @ Mar 8 2023 08:25pm)
A 22 year old has a much more developed brain than a 15 year old, think of it as a sliding scale.


And yet the metric explicitly cited by the county attorney puts the magic arbitrary number at 25. She didn't make any argument about sliding scales or degrees of responsibility, she did not make any attempt to say it cuts off at 18.
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev12347Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll