d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > Taiwan
12313Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 34,649
Joined: Jul 2 2007
Gold: 273.37
Jul 19 2020 09:54am
https://www.taiwannews.com.tw/en/news/3969642

In the wake of China's annexation (for lack of a better word) of Hong Kong, Taiwanese diplomats in the city have been ordered to sign a document affirming "One China" in order to renew their visas. They have thus far refused, and the Head of the office in the city has left Hong Kong for Taiwan.

The Taiwanese Minister of the Interior is now rejecting the principle of "One China" in its entirety, something that has de facto been true for all to see, but against the official recognition of which the CCP has long threatened war. Xi Jinping has made it clear that unification between the two China's should not be passed to the "next generation", and the CCP dropped the word "peaceful" from official language on the need to reunify with Taiwan.

Question for Pard : What stance should the United States and Europe take towards a potential invasion of Taiwan by China?
Member
Posts: 78,723
Joined: Nov 30 2008
Gold: 493.00
Jul 19 2020 09:59am
well they certainly should defend a democratic nation against the invasion of commies

will it happen? unlikely
Member
Posts: 33,928
Joined: Oct 9 2008
Gold: 2,528.52
Jul 19 2020 10:00am
Member
Posts: 54,184
Joined: May 26 2005
Gold: 4,945.67
Jul 19 2020 10:39am
Quote (bogie160 @ 19 Jul 2020 17:54)
https://www.taiwannews.com.tw/en/news/3969642

In the wake of China's annexation (for lack of a better word) of Hong Kong, Taiwanese diplomats in the city have been ordered to sign a document affirming "One China" in order to renew their visas. They have thus far refused, and the Head of the office in the city has left Hong Kong for Taiwan.

The Taiwanese Minister of the Interior is now rejecting the principle of "One China" in its entirety, something that has de facto been true for all to see, but against the official recognition of which the CCP has long threatened war. Xi Jinping has made it clear that unification between the two China's should not be passed to the "next generation", and the CCP dropped the word "peaceful" from official language on the need to reunify with Taiwan.

Question for Pard : What stance should the United States and Europe take towards a potential invasion of Taiwan by China?


Militarily, there is nothing the West could do realistically to stop China if they really invaded Taiwan. But it would trigger huge economic and diplomatic sanctions. And it might well push India and even Russia toward the US/EU camp. China has been eyeing resource-rich and underpopulated Siberia for a long time, and in terms of economic might and manpower, Russia wouldnt be able to put up much of a fight if the Chinese came for them. So in the end, I think that an armed annexation of Taiwan would close the ranks against China in most of the rest of the world and turn them into a bit of a pariah.
Member
Posts: 35,291
Joined: Aug 17 2004
Gold: 12,730.67
Jul 19 2020 12:36pm
Quote (Black XistenZ @ Jul 19 2020 09:39am)
Militarily, there is nothing the West could do realistically to stop China if they really invaded Taiwan. But it would trigger huge economic and diplomatic sanctions. And it might well push India and even Russia toward the US/EU camp. China has been eyeing resource-rich and underpopulated Siberia for a long time, and in terms of economic might and manpower, Russia wouldnt be able to put up much of a fight if the Chinese came for them. So in the end, I think that an armed annexation of Taiwan would close the ranks against China in most of the rest of the world and turn them into a bit of a pariah.

There absolutely is. Between the US and British navies, China doesn't even have a chance to send troops to occupy the region. It's vitally important for the US to have STRONG diplomatic relationships with Japan, India, South Korea, Vietnam, and the EU. That should deter a Chinese invasion but if for some reason it DOES happen, we need to respond militarily. Diplomatic sanctions won't do anything once a military invasion commences.

In order to achieve victory, the US coalition would need to sink the Chinese fleet and render their artificial islands useless. That can be done in a matter of days. From there, you impose HEAVY sanctions on China in order to send them into a depression. That's really the only way.

This post was edited by thundercock on Jul 19 2020 12:40pm
Member
Posts: 33,928
Joined: Oct 9 2008
Gold: 2,528.52
Jul 19 2020 01:03pm
Quote (thundercock @ Jul 19 2020 02:36pm)
There absolutely is. Between the US and British navies, China doesn't even have a chance to send troops to occupy the region. It's vitally important for the US to have STRONG diplomatic relationships with Japan, India, South Korea, Vietnam, and the EU. That should deter a Chinese invasion but if for some reason it DOES happen, we need to respond militarily. Diplomatic sanctions won't do anything once a military invasion commences.

In order to achieve victory, the US coalition would need to sink the Chinese fleet and render their artificial islands useless. That can be done in a matter of days. From there, you impose HEAVY sanctions on China in order to send them into a depression. That's really the only way.


Member
Posts: 52,226
Joined: Jan 3 2009
Gold: 8,902.00
Jul 19 2020 01:16pm
The United States should sell Los Angeles class attack submarines and Arleigh Burke class guided missile destroyers to Taiwan.

Quote (Black XistenZ @ Jul 19 2020 11:39am)
Militarily, there is nothing the West could do realistically to stop China if they really invaded Taiwan. But it would trigger huge economic and diplomatic sanctions. And it might well push India and even Russia toward the US/EU camp. China has been eyeing resource-rich and underpopulated Siberia for a long time, and in terms of economic might and manpower, Russia wouldnt be able to put up much of a fight if the Chinese came for them. So in the end, I think that an armed annexation of Taiwan would close the ranks against China in most of the rest of the world and turn them into a bit of a pariah.


American submarines can decimate any invasion fleet China could muster and are virtually immune from Chinese counterattack.
Member
Posts: 54,184
Joined: May 26 2005
Gold: 4,945.67
Jul 19 2020 01:21pm
Hmm, is China really this far behind in terms of maritime warfare? I have a hard time believing that they still couldn't do shit against American submarines operating a couple of miles off of their own shores.
Member
Posts: 28,884
Joined: Aug 11 2013
Gold: 10,712.00
Jul 19 2020 02:14pm
The pivot to Asia under Obama was the right thing to do. The next logical step in this more aggressive stance towards a growingly hostile power is to confront them economically. Trump was absolutely right to start the trade war, and the subsequent tensions between China and many of their neighbors are absolutely necessary.

We need the world to start divorcing their production from China. For example what Japan is starting to do is the right thing.

Quote
Japan’s government will start paying its companies to move factories out of China and back home or to Southeast Asia, part of a new program to secure supply chains and reduce dependence on manufacturing in China.


Fifty-seven companies including privately-held facemask-maker Iris Ohyama Inc. and Sharp Corp. will receive a total of 57.4 billion yen ($536 million) in subsidies from the government, the Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry said Friday. Another 30 firms will receive money to move manufacturing to Vietnam, Myanmar, Thailand and other Southeast Asian nations, according to a separate announcement, which didn’t provide details on the amount of compensation.

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-07-18/japan-to-pay-at-least-536-million-for-companies-to-leave-china

I also mentioned India, them banning a bunch of Chinese apps is a good start. I really think we're entering cold war 2.0.

If we can drive a wedge between Russia and China that would be monumental. They rely heavily on Russian energy exports, if we can get Russia on our side, proverbially speaking that would be a huge win.

This post was edited by ofthevoid on Jul 19 2020 02:18pm
Member
Posts: 52,226
Joined: Jan 3 2009
Gold: 8,902.00
Jul 19 2020 02:18pm
Quote (Black XistenZ @ Jul 19 2020 02:21pm)
Hmm, is China really this far behind in terms of maritime warfare? I have a hard time believing that they still couldn't do shit against American submarines operating a couple of miles off of their own shores.


https://thediplomat.com/2018/09/the-chinese-surface-fleets-growing-anti-submarine-warfare-capabilities/

They're coming around after decades. Literally decades.

They've been expanding their anti-ship capabilities for years now, as well as anti-satellite (US military targeting is highly dependent on GPS), but the US Navy is in a class all by itself, and carries potent anti-missile defenses, not to mention the only operating fleet of super carriers in the world. The US Navy is also a true blue water navy, unlike the ChiComs brown water navy. But the creme de la creme of the USN is the silent service. The old Los Angeles class submarine carry 3 dozen torpedos, the new Virginia class mix in a couple dozen missiles for increased range. The submarines can take targeting data from drones and stealth aircraft and take down the ASW platforms from great distance, leaving the rest of an opposing fleet helpless from medium range torpedos.
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
12313Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll