Quote (Improv @ 9 Dec 2012 18:41)
I don't do signature requests anymore unfortunately, but it offends me to see people who have never followed a single sig tutorial and do attempts like this as if they are naturally good at making sigs or something and they think they dont need the practice. but then again they are probably just in it for the fg and probably dont care for gfx art at all

Regardless of the quality of the work and the fact that you can do better or not, i still think it's better to actually give some constructive cristicism instead of saying it's shit and leave it at that.
We've all got to start somewhere, so be a little supportive and lend a helping hand by letting him know what he could do to improve on it