old topics closed due to spam
http://forums.d2jsp.org/topic.php?t=70336949&f=105

heres my last square attempt, kidna happy with the result




comments?

too much contrast and exposure
the smudging is pretty bad too, did you read a tut?

again thats not a square

also that smudge is bad

it looks like you took someone else's smudge sig and over contrasted it

This post was edited by Sena on Mar 10 2014 06:03pm

i asked for comments, not for accusations.
also im used to call these signs square. i think you understand what i meant



looked a few ones but cant find any that explain things well instead of saying something like smudge till you like it, add color, add filter, done


lowered contrast and exposure a bit, and it does look better.



other than that, flow, font, placement, what could be done better?

This post was edited by christop03 on Mar 10 2014 06:16pm

nvm

This post was edited by Arcaeus on Mar 10 2014 06:45pm

but all squares are rectangles



here are some good ones
http://www.deviantart.com/art/Tutorial-Sign-Smudge-ENG-ITA-190489439
http://www.deviantart.com/art/Smudge-Signature-Tutorial-258893648
http://www.deviantart.com/art/Smudge-Tag-Tutorial-315358451

False.

current work in progress, unfinished

render won't be centered on final product, havent finished the smudge on the right part