I decided if I wanted to get the best criticism and help I should probably show more than just one work, so I plan on posting all the sigs I make from now on here and hopefully people can tell me what needs work!

I am very amateur and only know what I've taught myself/learned in 1-2 tutorials.

Heres a sig that I sort of looked at a tutorial but also sort of just randomly did stuff (earliest sig to date that I have saved)



Here's my first sig i actually took seriously (current sig)



Here's my second, this one took a lot longer than I've ever spent making a signature. Tried to follow a tutorial really closely. The text is temporary because i'm awful at placing text and typography kind of stuff.



Please let me know what you guys think i need to fix/change/improve on!

Also i hope i'm making progress on the last one because i spent so much time on it..

the c4d of the first sig looks kind of weird ^^

i really like the 3rd sig

Yea the first sig was a few weeks ago (maybe a month) I wasn't really paying attention to any sort of rules at all.

And thank you!

This post was edited by Woodhouse on Nov 10 2012 03:53am

yeah the 3rd sig is nice other than the typo, though I'm working on that myself. Here are two really good links:

http://fc00.deviantart.net/fs27/f/2008/185/c/f/Typography_Tutorial_by_Xpnze.jpg

http://forums.d2jsp.org/topic.php?t=57874419&f=246

Newest sig for a friend.

I got a few more of these coming for a giveaway I did.

I don't have a ton of time to spend on these so they won't be perfect but I wanted to let you all see them.

Another Quick throw together



This post was edited by Woodhouse on Nov 12 2012 09:08pm

if you want to improve, dont try to do the same style over and over again
its the same evctor brush on texture/noisy bg, c4d, and glowy spheres
there's really no point in posting the same stuff over and over again because you're not gonna improve that way,
this is due to the fact that this style of sig making is very very beginner
and you need to try other tuts and stuff
so my recommendation, instead of trying to give away bad sigs, try new tuts

Do you know of a place with more mid ranged rather than beginner tuts?

I've been linked to DB's profile but a lot of the tut links no longer exist (the pictures at least)

try DA
if it looks useful, do it
post results

I assume you mean deviant art?

Alright well I'll look up some nice tutorials and see what i can do

thanks for the input!