d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Graphic Design > Lwe12345's Progression Thread > Looking For Constructive Criticism
Prev18910111223Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 47,052
Joined: Jul 1 2008
Gold: 13,845.00
Oct 29 2012 12:29am
I dont like the composition and effects, seem really random
and please dont use blur/smudge to create depth, try using shading instead and sharpen
and dont abuse filters
Member
Posts: 55,482
Joined: Mar 18 2007
Gold: 820.71
Oct 29 2012 01:37am
Quote (killkillkillkil @ Oct 29 2012 02:29am)
I dont like the composition and effects, seem really random
and please dont use blur/smudge to create depth, try using shading instead and sharpen
and dont abuse filters


What is wrong with the blur tool? :unsure:
Member
Posts: 48,531
Joined: Oct 15 2007
Gold: 100.00
Oct 29 2012 01:41am
Quote (Avid @ 29 Oct 2012 10:37)
[FONT="Arial"]What is wrong with the blur tool?  :unsure:[/FONT]


Don't know. Sometimes it can be used in a very good way - as you create depth with it as long with other aspects, it looks more natural. By nature, your eye focuses the same way on close objects, nothing wrong with it.

Point is to not rely your depth on it, highlights-shadows is just as important and gives a sense of dimensions.
Member
Posts: 12,605
Joined: Feb 5 2011
Gold: 0.00
Oct 29 2012 04:40am
-_____-
Member
Posts: 7,815
Joined: Feb 20 2011
Gold: 5,625.00
Oct 29 2012 04:57am
lefunnyhehehaha
Member
Posts: 48,531
Joined: Oct 15 2007
Gold: 100.00
Oct 29 2012 08:12am
I understand that many people have something against this thread but why post? This is nonsense. It not like your posts are going to change anything or make the world better place. This is why thread with least point get closed why completely pointless ones stay open. Let people progress.
Member
Posts: 8,783
Joined: Oct 3 2006
Gold: 14,555.15
Oct 29 2012 12:06pm
Quote (LindeRKV @ Oct 29 2012 10:12am)
I understand that many people have something against this thread but why post? This is nonsense. It not like your posts are going to change anything or make the world better place. This is why thread with least point get closed why completely pointless ones stay open. Let people progress.


:)




I decided to go back and re-evaluate what I did with this sig. Retouched it and I think it's a lot better! Let me know what you think..

Old version:



Looks like the lighting on the old version is better, Working away at it.

edit :


This post was edited by Lwe12345 on Oct 29 2012 12:32pm
Member
Posts: 47,052
Joined: Jul 1 2008
Gold: 13,845.00
Oct 29 2012 03:26pm
seems like too much contrast some parts are really dark some parts too bright
some parts of it are really sharp, like bottom left and then those light spheres on top right (yellow) are like.... uh...
idk, LQ?
idk lol, so bad at this
Member
Posts: 48,531
Joined: Oct 15 2007
Gold: 100.00
Oct 29 2012 03:44pm
Quote (Lwe12345 @ 29 Oct 2012 21:06)
:)



http://i.imgur.com/xR60C.jpg
I decided to go back and re-evaluate what I did with this sig. Retouched it and I think it's a lot better! Let me know what you think..

Old version:
http://i.imgur.com/YmITY.jpg


Looks like the lighting on the old version is better, Working away at it.

edit :
http://i.imgur.com/qeIjV.jpg


I liked 1st one better. Better depth. As i mentioned it, eye by nature focuses on what you look at and blurs out rest.
Member
Posts: 8,783
Joined: Oct 3 2006
Gold: 14,555.15
Oct 29 2012 04:08pm
Quote (killkillkillkil @ Oct 29 2012 05:26pm)
seems like too much contrast some parts are really dark some parts too bright
some parts of it are really sharp, like bottom left and then those light spheres on top right (yellow) are like.... uh...
idk, LQ?
idk lol, so bad at this


Np. Thanks for the advice

super jealous of your smudge skills by the way.

Go Back To Graphic Design Topic List
Prev18910111223Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll