d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Graphic Design >
Poll > Who's Sig Is Best > Come Take A Look
Prev123456Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Views: 1480Replies: 51Track Topic
  Guests cannot view or vote in polls. Please register or login.
Member
Posts: 48,531
Joined: Oct 15 2007
Gold: 96.26
#21
Jan 5 2017 12:21pm
You should have made this poll in another sub-forum then - preferably where neither of you are regular posters and where there are enough active users to vote.

Creation of this topic is rather displeasing event in here.

Nulled vote.
Member
Posts: 7,749
Joined: Apr 4 2016
Gold: 0.00
#22
Jan 5 2017 12:24pm
Quote (LindeRKV @ Jan 5 2017 02:21pm)
You should have made this poll in another sub-forum then - preferably where neither of you are regular posters and where there are enough active users to vote.

Creation of this topic is rather displeasing event in here.

Nulled vote.


Doesnt make sens if ppl dont know shit about gfx tho? No?

Just my thought
Member
Posts: 48,531
Joined: Oct 15 2007
Gold: 96.26
#23
Jan 5 2017 12:35pm
Quote (Devoir @ 5 Jan 2017 20:24)
Doesnt make sens if ppl dont know shit about gfx tho? No?

Just my thought


How many of those 39 voters here have deeper knowledge of technical side of art?

This post was edited by LindeRKV on Jan 5 2017 12:40pm
Member
Posts: 7,749
Joined: Apr 4 2016
Gold: 0.00
#24
Jan 5 2017 12:39pm
Quote (LindeRKV @ Jan 5 2017 02:35pm)
How many of those 39 voters here have deeper knowledge of techincal side of art?


Probably none or close to none lol.

Pretty sure most active gfx artist didnt vote here :P
Member
Posts: 7,749
Joined: Apr 4 2016
Gold: 0.00
#25
Jan 5 2017 01:03pm
I just made my signature.

What you think?
Member
Posts: 32,538
Joined: Dec 6 2007
Gold: 1,945.00
#26
Jan 5 2017 02:19pm
I normally don't bother commenting on these but why not?

You both seem kind of douchebaggy but putting that aside, let's talk about the tags.

There is really nothing to this bread's. Boxes + space stock + drop shadow + animation = 5 minutes tops.

At least the other tag looks like someone attempted to put effort into it. There was some attempt at using rule of thirds, trying to blend the render into the tag, flow is wonky and the smudge is as basic as it gets..but still, there's effort.

This isn't saying that simple or quick tags aren't good. But you shouldn't be able to dissect a tag completely and know that it took less than five minutes.

There, someone from the forum responded, now you guys can take the pissing contest elsewhere.
Member
Posts: 17,270
Joined: Aug 21 2008
Gold: 2,375.00
#27
Jan 5 2017 02:50pm
your signature is technical but it looks like the guy didn't take the time even blending the avatar.
I do agree with you though at times words ruin the art

With the other guy is it's simple. And I was never a big fan of animations just because they are so pixelated.

I think both sigs were rushed and the person who had the other Red sig in the best one by far
Member
Posts: 11,014
Joined: May 29 2006
Gold: 1.00
#28
Jan 5 2017 04:06pm
Quote (Xandriia @ Jan 5 2017 03:19pm)
I normally don't bother commenting on these but why not?

You both seem kind of douchebaggy but putting that aside, let's talk about the tags.

There is really nothing to this bread's. Boxes + space stock + drop shadow + animation = 5 minutes tops.

At least the other tag looks like someone attempted to put effort into it. There was some attempt at using rule of thirds, trying to blend the render into the tag, flow is wonky and the smudge is as basic as it gets..but still, there's effort.

This isn't saying that simple or quick tags aren't good. But you shouldn't be able to dissect a tag completely and know that it took less than five minutes.

There, someone from the forum responded, now you guys can take the pissing contest elsewhere.


Thanks for your opinion.

Didnt really want to make that kind of topic but he was being like oh you dodge etc etc.

I'll get the topic closed.

Quote (Jeremmy @ Jan 5 2017 03:50pm)
your signature is technical but it looks like the guy didn't take the time even blending the avatar.
I do agree with you though at times words ruin the art

With the other guy is it's simple. And I was never a big fan of animations just because they are so pixelated.

I think both sigs were rushed and the person who had the other Red sig in the best one by far


Thanks for your opinion
Member
Posts: 11,570
Joined: Oct 8 2007
Gold: 1,000.00
#29
Jan 5 2017 04:40pm
Quote (Xandriia @ Jan 5 2017 02:19pm)
I normally don't bother commenting on these but why not?

You both seem kind of douchebaggy but putting that aside, let's talk about the tags.

There is really nothing to this bread's. Boxes + space stock + drop shadow + animation = 5 minutes tops.

At least the other tag looks like someone attempted to put effort into it. There was some attempt at using rule of thirds, trying to blend the render into the tag, flow is wonky and the smudge is as basic as it gets..but still, there's effort.

This isn't saying that simple or quick tags aren't good. But you shouldn't be able to dissect a tag completely and know that it took less than five minutes.

There, someone from the forum responded, now you guys can take the pissing contest elsewhere.


lol I don't mind its kinda funny.

Breads is terrible. Plain and simple. In a graphic standpoint its everything you should not do. All its missing is bleeding cowboy's and layer of topaz so thick that it looks like it were painted with a 90px hard round.
Argells needs work. its not a great signature, but there is some knowledge of graphic design put into it. Good or Bad it automatically wins.

The people voting for the other signature have signatures that are even worse. So yeah.
If its a popout and it didnt come from Phil it should be illegal on this forum.

This post was edited by DB_odin on Jan 5 2017 04:40pm
Member
Posts: 7,749
Joined: Apr 4 2016
Gold: 0.00
#30
Jan 5 2017 04:45pm
Quote (DB_odin @ Jan 5 2017 06:40pm)
lol I don't mind its kinda funny.

Breads is terrible. Plain and simple. In a graphic standpoint its everything you should not do. All its missing is bleeding cowboy's and layer of topaz so thick that it looks like it were painted with a 90px hard round.
Argells needs work. its not a great signature, but there is some knowledge of graphic design put into it. Good or Bad it automatically wins.

The people voting for the other signature have signatures that are even worse. So yeah.
If its a popout and it didnt come from Phil it should be illegal on this forum.


Yay I wear a pop-out from phil xD

Also, Beowulf has some solid pop-outs.
Go Back To Graphic Design Topic List
Prev123456Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll

© 2003-2024 d2jsp  Contact