Quote (Gensokyo @ Apr 10 2012 01:44am)
yeah, i realize.
idk why you'd say gmaps're bad in the context of contrast though. the purple/orange on softlight adds contrast, even if it's considered overused. (i dont use this particular one myself, but for the sake of argument)
it's not like you then can't turn around and adjust opacity or lay a graident ontop of the gmap to control how much of the map actually applies to the piece.
whereas photo filters & color filters directly act to either monotone-ize or filter out specific colors.
like a purple lighten one (as the current example) seems to give the direct opposite effect - a washed out look, where the blacks turn faded purple, and the light colors dont look as pronounced.
i guess the point im trying to make is that, isn't it just another tool? i mean, everything can look shit if you apply it the wrong way.
like idk how many years ago, 08, 09 maybe, what initially put me off of lighting was all these "pro" people insisting on 120px white softbrush splodges on the front of their sigs because it "enhanced" quality, despite looking like utter shit & out of place.
I understand your argument but its kinda missing the point of what I was talking about. I never said gmaps were bad for contrast
a black and white gmap on soft light adds contrast just as a purple/orange gmap would, but without putting a yellow film over everything...and it doesn't change the colors, but rather changes the shades.
Then again, you can always just use a brightness/contrast layer.
I use purple or sometimes blue, to wash out pure black spots. Its for balance in the colors. i don't see black as a color I see it as a shade. Any kind of light will alter black, and change is hue or darkness in a real life setting. Pure black is simply to strong, and makes the colors unbalanced in most cases. The only time you see pure black, is when there is no light at all. Meaning, in order for you to see true black, you would not be able to see anything else. If that makes sense.
although, my argument had nothing to do with contrast, it was about color. I don't claim to know everything, but I would like to believe I have a good understanding of colors.
I stand by my statement, gmaps are a horrible way to create colors.
as far as the white brushes, thats something that I did when I first started using photoshop. Like black, there is no such thing as pure white lighting. Something to remember
This post was edited by DB_odin on Apr 10 2012 02:44am