d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Graphic Design > Quotax' Gallery > Back In Business ;)
Prev123458Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 497
Joined: Jun 15 2009
Gold: 4,028.50
Jun 26 2011 08:48am
ok :)
thx for all the constructive criticism, love and hate.
i just want to point out for those of you who are "to stupid to realize that" (@xXDreamAlongXx): i dont think my sigs are awesome.
it was just the appropriate answer to

Quote (Sk4t3r @ 25 Jun 2011 01:34)
read more tuts


i think its extremly inappropriate to ask me to read more tuts. especially from some1 like sk4t3r, as his profile background gives me quite an impression on how developed his artistic sense is.
its very unfortunate that all the posters afterwards didnt get that.
actually i dont think i need to explain myself but its quite fun what some of u posted :D

my sigs are definately not the best among this forum, but aint the worst either.
i like to discover the things photoshop and similiar apps have to offer by myself. in all the years im workin with ps i read like 10 tuts. and they werent about sigantures at all.
sure i could improve my skills by reading one tut after another but i just dont want to.

especially the "recent work" was completely requested, except for my own sig. they all had a specific vision and i tried to fit this as much as possible.

for example the kuma sig:
this is the render i had to work with


the colors are crap and its chopped. i think under these circumstances the outcome was pretty good.

but in the end: every1 got his own taste, some of u might like my work and some wont. i dont care, but pls dont spam my topic with: read more tuts. this is just inmature.
criticism and suggestions are always welcome but in a more specific way so one can rly have a benefit from.

and i didnt made all my fg with gfx :D most of em i made in poker :) as i said, my post wasnt serious.

and last but not least: the ones who ordered a sig were always happy with the result and i think that is important.

This post was edited by Quotax on Jun 26 2011 08:52am
Member
Posts: 6,517
Joined: Oct 12 2008
Gold: 450.00
Jun 26 2011 09:12am
If you want some actual advice. Stay away from centered focals, they generally are much harder to pull off than one that follows the rule of thirds.

Most of your sigs just feel like a bunch of random stuff all put together. They should fit better.

Your text is horribad.

of all the sigs you posted I can only stand the 5th one to be honest, the rest just remind me of most random sig makers in the gfx request forum.

Read a good signature tut or two, I know what you've stated about tuts, but they help everyone, no matter how advanced you are, just make sure it's a good tut, you can look in my profile for some.
Member
Posts: 9,834
Joined: Feb 27 2008
Gold: 157.41
Jun 26 2011 09:22am
Member
Posts: 497
Joined: Jun 15 2009
Gold: 4,028.50
Jun 26 2011 11:57am
Quote (melodude @ 26 Jun 2011 17:12)
Most of your sigs just feel like a bunch of random stuff all put together. They should fit better.


well, your sig actually is random stuff all put together so i dont get ur point at all...
Member
Posts: 48,531
Joined: Oct 15 2007
Gold: 100.00
Jun 26 2011 12:12pm
Quote (Quotax @ 26 Jun 2011 19:57)
well, your sig actually is random stuff all put together so i dont get ur point at all...


And his still look interesting at some point. Yours doesn't. if you learn to throw randomly stuff together and still make it look good, then you would earn some good words.
Member
Posts: 6,517
Joined: Oct 12 2008
Gold: 450.00
Jun 26 2011 12:18pm
Quote (Quotax @ Jun 26 2011 01:57pm)
well, your sig actually is random stuff all put together so i dont get ur point at all...


This isnt my gallery for comments and criticism,
If you want to comment on my tags please place it here: http://forums.d2jsp.org/topic.php?t=54825055&f=107

I was actually trying to help you get better.
Member
Posts: 6,065
Joined: Jul 10 2010
Gold: 12,286.58
Jun 26 2011 06:20pm
Quote (Quotax @ Jun 26 2011 08:48am)
ok :)
thx for all the constructive criticism, love and hate.
i just want to point out for those of you who are "to stupid to realize that" (@xXDreamAlongXx): i dont think my sigs are awesome.
it was just the appropriate answer to



i think its extremly inappropriate to ask me to read more tuts. especially from some1 like sk4t3r, as his profile background gives me quite an impression on how developed his artistic sense is.
its very unfortunate that all the posters afterwards didnt get that.
actually i dont think i need to explain myself but its quite fun what some of u posted :D

my sigs are definately not the best among this forum, but aint the worst either.
i like to discover the things photoshop and similiar apps have to offer by myself. in all the years im workin with ps i read like 10 tuts. and they werent about sigantures at all.
sure i could improve my skills by reading one tut after another but i just dont want to.

especially the "recent work" was completely requested, except for my own sig. they all had a specific vision and i tried to fit this as much as possible.

for example the kuma sig:
this is the render i had to work with
http://img220.imageshack.us/img220/1668/kumarender.png

the colors are crap and its chopped. i think under these circumstances the outcome was pretty good.

but in the end: every1 got his own taste, some of u might like my work and some wont. i dont care, but pls dont spam my topic with: read more tuts. this is just inmature.
criticism and suggestions are always welcome but in a more specific way so one can rly have a benefit from.

and i didnt made all my fg with gfx :D most of em i made in poker :) as i said, my post wasnt serious.

and last but not least: the ones who ordered a sig were always happy with the result and i think that is important.


Raped. Read more tuts
Member
Posts: 20,464
Joined: Dec 31 2006
Gold: 131.00
Jun 26 2011 06:27pm
you make sigs that look like 2005
cool
Member
Posts: 23,897
Joined: Mar 4 2008
Gold: 535.00
Jun 26 2011 06:29pm
toot toot toot toot.
Needs more toots.
Member
Posts: 497
Joined: Jun 15 2009
Gold: 4,028.50
Jun 26 2011 06:52pm
so many trolls in my thread... whutthefarg
Go Back To Graphic Design Topic List
Prev123458Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll