I'd go for v3
The render just looks slapped on top to me. Maybe try wrapping some of the background textures around it?
Play the hue and saturation of the render a bit to try and match the colouring a bit better.
Quote (illyria @ May 4 2014 02:44am)
The second is my favourite, however, I do think that it is too dark by a minuscule amount.
Agreed. If you can get it matching a bit more, try chucking a white layer over it set on screen to brighten it up a little.