d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Graphic Design > Rate My Current Piece > Plox
Prev12345Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Views: 841Replies: 47Track Topic
Member
Posts: 7,815
Joined: Feb 20 2011
Gold: 5,625.00
#11
May 16 2012 07:40pm
Quote (killkillkillkil @ May 17 2012 01:37am)
does a sports player practice the same skill?


Uh yes? lol clearly you are not the biggest sports fan :mellow:

Quote (AngeloMisery @ May 17 2012 01:37am)
Yes but you are just practicing the wrong things over and over again.


What is so wrong about this? I happen to like this smudge style and so do alot of other people lol.

This post was edited by Golden_star on May 16 2012 07:41pm
Member
Posts: 17,750
Joined: Jul 8 2007
Gold: 0.00
#12
May 16 2012 07:46pm
Quote (Golden_star @ May 16 2012 08:40pm)
Uh yes? lol clearly you are not the biggest sports fan  :mellow:



What is so wrong about this? I happen to like this smudge style and so do alot of other people lol.


Well first off it isn't what most people will classify as smudge. Secondly it is the same sig over and over with a different render/background colour. It has no depth, the flow is weak, text is awful etc.

Liking a style is fine but continuing to make the same sig over and over is not going to improve things.

This post was edited by AngeloMisery on May 16 2012 07:47pm
Member
Posts: 7,815
Joined: Feb 20 2011
Gold: 5,625.00
#13
May 16 2012 07:52pm
Quote (AngeloMisery @ May 17 2012 01:46am)
Well first off it isn't what most people will classify as smudge. Secondly it is the same sig over and over with a different render/background colour. It has no depth, the flow is weak, text is awful etc.

Liking a style is fine but continuing to make the same sig over and over is not going to improve things.


- This yours imo, i find the colour change disturbing for my eyes and i find the text pretty bad plus left side feels empty and i dont see alot of flow in it either? and how is using the smudge tool for your render not a smudge? and you shouldnt just quit on a style as soon as you can manage 50% of it correctly.

This post was edited by Golden_star on May 16 2012 07:53pm
Member
Posts: 17,750
Joined: Jul 8 2007
Gold: 0.00
#14
May 16 2012 07:57pm
Quote (Golden_star @ May 16 2012 08:52pm)
http://i1223.photobucket.com/albums/dd504/Hinrik96/Donotrip2.jpg - This yours imo, i find the colour change disturbing for my eyes and i find the text pretty bad plus left side feels empty and i dont see alot of flow in it either? and how is using the smudge tool for your render not a smudge? and you shouldnt just quit on a style as soon as you can manage 50% of it correctly.


I didn't even make mine, and I didn't ask for Cnc on mine. Honestly if you ask for Cnc and then can't take it don't bother even asking.

Also I said it wasn't what most people would classify as smudge not that it isn't smudge.

This post was edited by AngeloMisery on May 16 2012 07:58pm
Member
Posts: 7,815
Joined: Feb 20 2011
Gold: 5,625.00
#15
May 16 2012 08:02pm
Quote (AngeloMisery @ May 17 2012 01:57am)
I didn't even make mine, and I didn't ask for Cnc on mine. Honestly if you ask for Cnc and then can't take it don't bother even asking.

Also I said it wasn't what most people would classify as smudge not that it isn't smudge.


I just thought since you were pointing mine out i was kinda expecting you could do it yourself :) I'l take critisism from anyone who can atelast show me they have some experiance lol.

This post was edited by Golden_star on May 16 2012 08:03pm
Member
Posts: 17,750
Joined: Jul 8 2007
Gold: 0.00
#16
May 16 2012 08:03pm
Quote (Golden_star @ May 16 2012 09:02pm)
I just thought since you were pointing mine out i was kinda expecting you could do it yourself :)


No that isn't how it works what so ever, you asked for it I did not, nor did I make my sig it was made as a gift from someone else.
Member
Posts: 7,815
Joined: Feb 20 2011
Gold: 5,625.00
#17
May 16 2012 08:07pm
Quote (AngeloMisery @ May 17 2012 02:03am)
No that isn't how it works what so ever, you asked for it I did not, nor did I make my sig it was made as a gift from someone else.


lol thats not how it works? i wont go to someone for advice without him being able to prove he is atleast better than me :wacko:
Member
Posts: 17,750
Joined: Jul 8 2007
Gold: 0.00
#18
May 16 2012 08:09pm
Quote (Golden_star @ May 16 2012 09:07pm)
lol thats not how it works? i wont go to someone for advice without him being able to prove he is atleast better than me  :wacko:


Being better has nothing to do with being technically correct. I could not be open to open photoshop but still know the fundamentals to tell you that the style you are practicing isn't considered smudge, the text is bad, has no depth, and that you are doing the same thing over and over again.

Looks fine for a beginner but needs tutorials if you want to get better.

This post was edited by AngeloMisery on May 16 2012 08:11pm
Member
Posts: 8,244
Joined: Jul 20 2005
Gold: 2.00
#19
May 16 2012 08:09pm
you should at least learn how to provide psd to people first
the rest is just all bull shit

http://forums.d2jsp.org/topic.php?t=50504432&f=111&o=1490
Member
Posts: 17,075
Joined: Oct 1 2005
Gold: 140.00
#20
May 16 2012 08:10pm
Quote (Golden_star @ May 16 2012 10:07pm)
lol thats not how it works? i wont go to someone for advice without him being able to prove he is atleast better than me  :wacko:


guy, if you don't settle down few are going to give you the time of day.

I could care less how bad your tags are, the first always are... I do like however that you keep making new tags, and practice.


So, I would recommend you keep practicing and shut up about others tags. no hate, but serious.
Go Back To Graphic Design Topic List
Prev12345Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll

© 2003-2026 d2jsp  Contact