d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Diablo II > Diablo 2 Discussion > The Trophy Room > #1 Necro Diadem? > Escl | Pic Inside
Prev1345679Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 46,594
Joined: May 26 2009
Gold: 3,926.00
Jul 10 2020 08:31am
Quote (EcHsE1337 @ Jul 10 2020 11:28am)
well if you post an item that is in your opinion supposed to be good but it reality it isnt
and you keep telling that it´s good beacuse you cant accept the fact that it isnt
it means it´s a pretentious behavior


It's not my item lol
I never claimed the item was good
The guy who owns the item also never argued anyone's claim it's a bad item
It is an average item for NL, there are obviously plenty of them that are better
It is a great item for ladder

This post was edited by SharpNips on Jul 10 2020 08:32am
Member
Posts: 43,254
Joined: Jan 24 2009
Gold: 8,212.98
Jul 10 2020 08:35am
Quote (SharpNips @ Jul 10 2020 04:31pm)
It's not my item lol
I never claimed the item was good
The guy who owns the item also never argued anyone's claim it's a bad item
It is an average item for NL, there are obviously plenty of them that are better
It is a great item for ladder


he´s asking if it´s top1 so he assumes it´s top tier atleast
than he´s rating it himself 7/10 even tho it´s not trophy room worthy
and why would you need to own it to show pretentious behavior ?
if you´re saying that one team is better than the other one without accepting that in reality it isnt
and you keep telling others it´s the best it can be considered as a arrogant/pretentious behavior
maybe not the best example but w/e

This post was edited by EcHsE1337 on Jul 10 2020 08:38am
Member
Posts: 46,594
Joined: May 26 2009
Gold: 3,926.00
Jul 10 2020 08:41am
Quote (EcHsE1337 @ Jul 10 2020 11:35am)
he´s asking if it´s top1 so he assumes it´s top tier atleast
than he´s rating it himself 7/10 even tho it´s not trophy room worthy
and why would you need to own it to show pretentious behavior ?
if you´re saying that one team is better than the other one without accepting that in reality it isnt
and you keep telling others it´s the best it can be considered as a arrogant/pretentious behavior
maybe not the best example but w/e


You should note he rated it himself as 7/10 with a "?" Showing he clearly doesn't know, as he did in the topic title.
I dont think he refuted anyone's claim at any point
Nor have I

Let's just all be friends

This post was edited by SharpNips on Jul 10 2020 08:44am
Member
Posts: 43,254
Joined: Jan 24 2009
Gold: 8,212.98
Jul 10 2020 08:44am
Quote (SharpNips @ Jul 10 2020 04:41pm)
You should note he rated it himself as 7/10 with a "?" Showing he clearly doesn't know, as he did in the topic title.
I dont think he refuted anyone's claim at any point

Let's just all be friends


well for me it seems like begging for good ratings while in reality it´s closer to a 0/10 than to a 7/10
but w/e he sold an useful 5/6 mods diadem that can only be considered useful in NvN and NvH
it´s kind like a 5x lifer considering 55 fhr from spirit and 30 fhr from shadowdancers give you a total of 85 fhr already
Member
Posts: 1,532
Joined: Jul 4 2020
Gold: 1.05
Aug 3 2020 07:56pm
Six out of 10
Member
Posts: 13,915
Joined: Nov 15 2012
Gold: 200.00
Aug 4 2020 02:01am
9/10

missing 9 life [ and 2 def ] to be 10


ANYWAYS

rates below 8 are just unfair , this is not a RateHowMyItemIsUseful but Trophy Room which many people and trolls doesnt understand it seems.

A PERFECT item HAS to be rated 10/10, it aint matter if its usefull or not , it does matter if it fit in requiements [aka no rw's ,uniques]

This one has perfect stats but
31/40 life
58/60 def

Thus , 8-9/10 is the ONLY rate which shall be given on this item, all other ratings are just not rating item stats , but usefulness and all other aspects which aint a SUBJECT in TR.

This post was edited by giraffe11223344556677889900 on Aug 4 2020 02:06am
Member
Posts: 43,254
Joined: Jan 24 2009
Gold: 8,212.98
Aug 4 2020 02:36am
Quote (giraffe11223344556677889900 @ Aug 4 2020 10:01am)
9/10

missing 9 life [ and 2 def ] to be 10


ANYWAYS

rates below 8 are just unfair , this is not a RateHowMyItemIsUseful but Trophy Room which many people and trolls doesnt understand it seems.

A PERFECT item HAS to be rated 10/10, it aint matter if its usefull or not , it does matter if it fit in requiements [aka no rw's ,uniques]

This one has perfect stats but
31/40 life
58/60 def

Thus , 8-9/10 is the ONLY rate which shall be given on this item, all other ratings are just not rating item stats , but usefulness and all other aspects which aint a SUBJECT in TR.


nice that you dont know that rare diadems can get up to 60 life
Member
Posts: 13,915
Joined: Nov 15 2012
Gold: 200.00
Aug 4 2020 02:45am
Quote (EcHsE1337 @ Aug 4 2020 10:36am)
nice that you dont know that rare diadems can get up to 60 life


Haha my mistake, lol

it shall be around 6-7/10 then
Member
Posts: 21,355
Joined: May 20 2003
Gold: 6,586.00
Aug 4 2020 02:53am
Quote (giraffe11223344556677889900 @ 4 Aug 2020 10:01)
9/10

missing 9 life [ and 2 def ] to be 10


ANYWAYS

rates below 8 are just unfair , this is not a RateHowMyItemIsUseful but Trophy Room which many people and trolls doesnt understand it seems.

A PERFECT item HAS to be rated 10/10, it aint matter if its usefull or not , it does matter if it fit in requiements [aka no rw's ,uniques]

This one has perfect stats but
31/40 life
58/60 def

Thus , 8-9/10 is the ONLY rate which shall be given on this item, all other ratings are just not rating item stats , but usefulness and all other aspects which aint a SUBJECT in TR.


Beside as already stated you have huge gap in your knowledge (therefore you are not able to rate correctly an item)
most of what you'er asying is wrong.
A Trophy is not an item with perfect stats, is an item with the proper combination of proper stat.

you can have boots with

50% Heal Stamina
+2 to Light Radius
+30 to Max Stamina
Half Freeze Duration
Repair Durability
1-23 lightning damage

100% perfect.
are they trophy?

Member
Posts: 58,644
Joined: May 19 2009
Gold: 4,603.69
Aug 7 2020 06:04am
9/10
Go Back To The Trophy Room Topic List
Prev1345679Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll