d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Diablo II > Diablo 2 Discussion > The Trophy Room > # Top Gm Zeal Paladin Carlos > D2:R
Prev1234511Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Views: 10416Replies: 104Track Topic
Member
Posts: 92,933
Joined: Dec 31 2007
Gold: 2,299.94
#21
Nov 15 2022 10:14am
Quote (ferdia @ Nov 15 2022 10:46am)
i rate the Armet 9/10. I would think there are 1-2 better ? needs higher def and higher life. how much do these things sell for 10-20K? I think alot of ppl are crafting these. 2sox and visionary is so hard to get :(
i rate the Diadems 8/10. I am not sure if this is harsh but I am comparing you against the best all time, and you can get a life roll with these mods.
i find the gloves to be similar to those here: https://forums.d2jsp.org/topic.php?t=98179148&f=103 and therefore would rate these 8.5/10 (note that several ppl in that thread see such gloves not as trophies (they probably dont play melee)).
Exile is is perfect
Verdungo is is perfect
Shaft is is perfect
BOTD is perfect
Bone Spiral Ring I rate 9.8/10
inventory is 10/10
Sacred Targe 9/10 ( I mean it could be eth repl ).

Taken as a whole I rate the character 9.7/10 being very critical.
(i took 0.1/10 off the score because you upped brimstone from MLD, what a baddy!) :)

Have you calc'd the benefits of Brimstone vs BOTD and Rare/craft vs Rends?

======

Gores & Highlord?


Exile is 65/116 :P

agree with score tho, near 10 and only drops if you're comparing to best possible rolls.
Member
Posts: 74,612
Joined: Aug 3 2013
Gold: 3,226.11
#22
Nov 15 2022 10:16am
Quote (ferdia @ Nov 15 2022 10:11am)
Fools mod being the only possible alternative to a BOTD, right?



Yep.

And his cruel is likely worse than ebotdz.
Member
Posts: 56,300
Joined: Jan 19 2007
Gold: 567,833.61
#23
Nov 15 2022 10:16am
Quote (thesnipa @ Nov 15 2022 04:14pm)
Exile is 65/116 :P

agree with score tho, near 10 and only drops if you're comparing to best possible rolls.


ups my bad.

This post was edited by ferdia on Nov 15 2022 10:27am
Member
Posts: 92,933
Joined: Dec 31 2007
Gold: 2,299.94
#24
Nov 15 2022 10:48am
Quote (ferdia @ Nov 15 2022 11:16am)
ups my bad.


isnt that also the Naga that was up'd but close to BIS for an mld?
Member
Posts: 74,612
Joined: Aug 3 2013
Gold: 3,226.11
#25
Nov 15 2022 11:00am
Quote (thesnipa @ Nov 15 2022 10:48am)
isnt that also the Naga that was up'd but close to BIS for an mld?



I’m not sure. But naga is a poor MLD weapon choice.

For MLD you would want a elite weapon base with lvl 49 or lower level req, such as small crescent, tomahawk or elegant blade

Naga base damage is like 40% lower than any of those above.
Member
Posts: 56,300
Joined: Jan 19 2007
Gold: 567,833.61
#26
Nov 15 2022 11:01am
Quote (thesnipa @ Nov 15 2022 04:48pm)
isnt that also the Naga that was up'd but close to BIS for an mld?


look, i messed up with 65/116, sorry. stop hitting me when im down ok!



Quote (Bui6Pays40Percent4Wins @ Nov 15 2022 05:00pm)
I’m not sure. But naga is a poor MLD weapon choice.

For MLD you would want a elite weapon base with lvl 49 or lower level req, such as small crescent, tomahawk or elegant blade

Naga base damage is like 40% lower than any of those above.


Naga has range. On EU, DerPate and I think Dune666 were all over Naga's afaik (NA did not really MLD). even in D2lod there were very few good small crescents/tomahawks/elegant blades. Melee only was never a thing (or very fringe, at MLD, in d2lod).

This post was edited by ferdia on Nov 15 2022 11:04am
Member
Posts: 74,612
Joined: Aug 3 2013
Gold: 3,226.11
#27
Nov 15 2022 11:03am
Quote (ferdia @ Nov 15 2022 11:01am)
look, i messed up with 65/116, sorry. stop hitting me when im down ok!

https://i.imgur.com/GwQBKsb.png



Naga has range. DerPate and I think Dune666 were all over Naga's afaik.



I’m aware. But dealing 40% less damage for 1 range adder isn’t exactly a good trade off
Member
Posts: 92,933
Joined: Dec 31 2007
Gold: 2,299.94
#28
Nov 15 2022 11:10am
Quote (Bui6Pays40Percent4Wins @ Nov 15 2022 12:03pm)
I’m aware. But dealing 40% less damage for 1 range adder isn’t exactly a good trade off


oath SC is for sure BiS, some just want that range, honestly cant even say what matchup it's needed in tho. never used one.
Member
Posts: 74,612
Joined: Aug 3 2013
Gold: 3,226.11
#29
Nov 15 2022 11:14am
Quote (thesnipa @ Nov 15 2022 11:10am)
oath SC is for sure BiS, some just want that range, honestly cant even say what matchup it's needed in tho. never used one.



You would want range in a WW barb for mld.

But again, I’m not sure a 40ish% decrease in damage output is worth 1 range adder. Can’t imagine so.

All sin weapons are 1 range adder as opposed to 2 range adder for naga.

Sin WW isn’t dead because it’s 1 range adder as opposed to 2.

But again, there is like 5 people who MLD. And like 1 person who MLD on LOD. It’s never been a very popular bracket.

I wouldn’t go out of my way to keep a weapon MLD viable if it was viable for HLD.
Member
Posts: 6,141
Joined: Jul 11 2003
Gold: 18,364.00
#30
Nov 15 2022 11:17am
GG epic Zealer. That helm is nasty AF. Better than any LOD helm I’ve seen. Anyone using scaling their score based of Imports is :wallbash:.
Go Back To The Trophy Room Topic List
Prev1234511Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll

© 2003-2026 d2jsp  Contact