d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Diablo II > Diablo 2 Discussion > The Trophy Room > Top Cruels Mallet D2r > D2:R
Prev191011121314Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 92,944
Joined: Dec 31 2007
Gold: 2,299.94
Feb 10 2023 10:37am
Quote (Tapir @ Feb 9 2023 01:40pm)
I think its a narrow perspective. With this mindset your 200K fg chars in LOD wouldn't be consider trophy. Since my 200 fg mf hammerdin can 1vs 7 all of you. So hammerdin must be the mantinel in pala vs pala duels?
I do agree with you that D2R trophys are hard to rate.

On the mallet, I rate 6/10. missing a nice mod/ 2 sox.


Only for people who dont understand supply.

rating d2r which is a new based on the accumulated and massively exploited drop pool of d2c is idiotic.

jsp's fault a bit, there should be a d2r trophy room and d2c trophy room, but i dont think they foresaw or cared about people being dense.
Member
Posts: 74,612
Joined: Aug 3 2013
Gold: 3,226.11
Feb 10 2023 10:44am
Quote (thesnipa @ Feb 10 2023 10:37am)
Only for people who dont understand supply.

rating d2r which is a new based on the accumulated and massively exploited drop pool of d2c is idiotic.

jsp's fault a bit, there should be a d2r trophy room and d2c trophy room, but i dont think they foresaw or cared about people being dense.



Supply isn’t the issue.

The issue is people think a hard roll rare is good, simply because it’s a low drop rate. But if the item is worse than a common unique or Runeword etc, it doesn’t matter
Member
Posts: 92,944
Joined: Dec 31 2007
Gold: 2,299.94
Feb 10 2023 11:06am
Quote (Bui6Pays40Percent4Wins @ Feb 10 2023 10:44am)
Supply isn’t the issue.

The issue is people think a hard roll rare is good, simply because it’s a low drop rate. But if the item is worse than a common unique or Runeword etc, it doesn’t matter


That's not entirely accurate, niche case builds are also discarded. but supply does 100% play a role, circs are the most common case for that where people compare them to d2c c-food diadems.

"only usable on GF barb, so can't be trophy"

"only usable in all rare leagues so that means its bad"

"my 99 hdin will kill ur LLD in 2 seconds"

"its BIS for your build but your build is worse than CC build so not trophy"

the list goes on. and at the same time yes people do post 6/6 roll items that aren't good and should be informed their item can't beat a basic item.
Member
Posts: 75,862
Joined: Oct 30 2007
Gold: 26,290.00
Feb 10 2023 11:17am
Quote (Bui6Pays40Percent4Wins @ 10 Feb 2023 17:44)
Supply isn’t the issue.

The issue is people think a hard roll rare is good, simply because it’s a low drop rate. But if the item is worse than a common unique or Runeword etc, it doesn’t matter


No, your issue (amongst many others) is that you only consider items to be trophies around your version of a ‘BiS’ build around one specific player-made ruleset.. i mean you don’t even play d2r do you? You’re still stuck at the point where you lost your assa, and all you’re around for now is ‘dissing’ people in spite
Member
Posts: 74,612
Joined: Aug 3 2013
Gold: 3,226.11
Feb 10 2023 11:47am
Quote (J33 @ Feb 10 2023 11:17am)
No, your issue (amongst many others) is that you only consider items to be trophies around your version of a ‘BiS’ build around one specific player-made ruleset.. i mean you don’t even play d2r do you? You’re still stuck at the point where you lost your assa, and all you’re around for now is ‘dissing’ people in spite



0 spite
100% facts.
0 dissing

Yes I consider items to be trophies when they are better than a common unique or Runeword. Of which this is worse than edc.

Of which the shit you post is never a trophy, and you get upset. Even when I try to help you understand why.
Quote (thesnipa @ Feb 10 2023 11:06am)
That's not entirely accurate, niche case builds are also discarded. but supply does 100% play a role, circs are the most common case for that where people compare them to d2c c-food diadems.

"only usable on GF barb, so can't be trophy"

"only usable in all rare leagues so that means its bad"

"my 99 hdin will kill ur LLD in 2 seconds"

"its BIS for your build but your build is worse than CC build so not trophy"

the list goes on. and at the same time yes people do post 6/6 roll items that aren't good and should be informed their item can't beat a basic item.



There is a difference between trolling, which there is a lot of in trophy room, such as the “99 din will kill your lld” or grief > this, etc. but what I type is all facts. No troll. Simply trying to help people understand what’s good and bad, and why.


But 100% a trophy must beat a common Runeword or unique.
Member
Posts: 92,944
Joined: Dec 31 2007
Gold: 2,299.94
Feb 10 2023 11:54am
Quote (Bui6Pays40Percent4Wins @ Feb 10 2023 11:47am)
0 spite
100% facts.
0 dissing

Yes I consider items to be trophies when they are better than a common unique or Runeword. Of which this is worse than edc.

Of which the shit you post is never a trophy, and you get upset. Even when I try to help you understand why.


There is a difference between trolling, which there is a lot of in trophy room, such as the “99 din will kill your lld” or grief > this, etc. but what I type is all facts. No troll. Simply trying to help people understand what’s good and bad, and why.


But 100% a trophy must beat a common Runeword or unique.


i have no problem with a rare wep that nearly beats ebotdz/edc, at like 95% as good you'd have to duel 100 times to notice a difference. and style > boring items. especially due to all rare leagues, which is what ALL melee should be anyways. its already an overpriced league of items not usable on other chars, might as well go full bore.
Member
Posts: 134,560
Joined: Apr 4 2009
Gold: 1,230.92
Feb 10 2023 11:56am
Quote (thesnipa @ Feb 10 2023 11:54am)
i have no problem with a rare wep that nearly beats ebotdz/edc, at like 95% as good you'd have to duel 100 times to notice a difference. and style > boring items. especially due to all rare leagues, which is what ALL melee should be anyways. its already an overpriced league of items not usable on other chars, might as well go full bore.


grief>melee

casters>uninstalling d2>melee
Member
Posts: 74,612
Joined: Aug 3 2013
Gold: 3,226.11
Feb 10 2023 12:02pm
Quote (thesnipa @ Feb 10 2023 11:54am)
i have no problem with a rare wep that nearly beats ebotdz/edc, at like 95% as good you'd have to duel 100 times to notice a difference. and style > boring items. especially due to all rare leagues, which is what ALL melee should be anyways. its already an overpriced league of items not usable on other chars, might as well go full bore.



It’s not a trophy. Which is the whole point.

People want participation trophies because they overpaid for some item that’s worse than edc.
Member
Posts: 92,944
Joined: Dec 31 2007
Gold: 2,299.94
Feb 10 2023 12:09pm
Quote (Bui6Pays40Percent4Wins @ Feb 10 2023 12:02pm)
It’s not a trophy. Which is the whole point.

People want participation trophies because they overpaid for some item that’s worse than edc.


its like u didnt read my post but ok

Quote (Haseo @ Feb 10 2023 11:56am)
grief>melee

casters>uninstalling d2>melee


ear'd u
Member
Posts: 134,560
Joined: Apr 4 2009
Gold: 1,230.92
Feb 10 2023 12:11pm
Quote (thesnipa @ Feb 10 2023 12:09pm)
its like u didnt read my post but ok



ear'd u


nope, u fled to dookie game m8 not us
Go Back To The Trophy Room Topic List
Prev191011121314Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll