one for the record books.

LLD how does he withstand vs eth'd / %DR / chargdin

For average damage they do need to be perfect

Scarlet 1-4 Min
of Joyfulness 1-4 Min
Carbuncle 1-5 Max
of Wrath 6-9 Max

with perfect rolls that's 8-14 damage with an average of 11
with minimum rolls that's 2-7 damage with an average of 4.5


No

20 max is perfect so average of 0min to 20max is 10
7-14 isnt perfect and has better avg then 20max (10.5)
8-13 isnt perfect and has better avg then 20max (10.5)

10.5 > 10

If i were you I would refrain from trying to correct other people because you simply lack the necessary logic to do so.

No/10

This post was edited by Fateful on Apr 13 2016 08:13pm

That's a fallacy because 10.5 can truncate to 10 which is why I said it, I'm not trying to skew it like you

don't get mad when someone corrects a post of yours, you always do it


No I didn't say that, it's not how the game calculates final damage, you're just going into retard mode because you were wrong with your post.


At no point did I say that


Correct. So we surmise that a 8-14 beats 20 for average damage in a Sigon's shield, other than that you cannot guarantee anything. But saying 'you don't need 4 perfect rolls to beat the average damage of a 20 maxer' is wrong because you cannot guarantee it. If you had said 'potentially' then it could have worked because of addition with other items and 2 of the aforementioned jewels if talking about other eq, but from what you said the same can be argued against which I have proven.


Goodbye, no retort because you know I am correct. Have a nice day.

This post was edited by Marieusz on Apr 13 2016 08:42pm

LOLLL, so in your mind the game always calculates your average damage every time you hit and truncates accordingly rather then generating a random number between and including your min and max AND THEN truncating just as the game was fucking designed?

Yes in d2 numbers are always rounded down and truncation does happen obv but certainly not in the same way as in your pea sized brain

even if that was true, the second I would equip a second such 10.5 avg jewel, your logic would then be flawed

This post was edited by Fateful on Apr 13 2016 08:18pm

You are a clown, you were basically saying the 1 extra min or max damage which ends up to a decimal average damage on the jewel will end up being irrelevant because of truncation, which is wrong in so many ways

Ok

Lol, you are the first limitless person I have seen, yes there is simply no limits to your stupidity.. On the other hand your limits are that you can't argue worth shit and you have the logic of a 5 year old at best.

I'm done wasting my time with you

Keep on editing bro, at this point I think your best bet is to edit everything out and claim that I've made up those quotes.

This post was edited by Fateful on Apr 13 2016 08:41pm

that discussion is kinda useless anway. just compare prices and availability of 20max and 10.5 average dmg jewels
this being said, I would take 20max over 8-13 or 7-14 any day

ironmonger is still a 10 imo and nothing else