d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > So What's Up With That Trumpcare ? > Dead ?
Prev12345619Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 64,656
Joined: Oct 25 2006
Gold: 260.11
Jul 18 2017 06:09pm
Quote (EndlessSky @ Jul 18 2017 06:02pm)
What are you talking about?

You have to pay for a gun. The same should be true of healthcare.


I've yet to see any model in which healthcare isn't paid for somehow.
Member
Posts: 33,514
Joined: Oct 9 2008
Gold: 2,617.52
Jul 18 2017 06:39pm
Quote (Thor123422 @ Jul 18 2017 08:09pm)
I've yet to see any model in which healthcare isn't paid for somehow.


YOU paying for it. Not someone else paying for you.
Member
Posts: 11,343
Joined: Jan 23 2007
Gold: 752.10
Jul 18 2017 06:43pm
Quote (EndlessSky @ Jul 18 2017 06:39pm)
YOU paying for it. Not someone else paying for you.



Everyone is already paying for it with absurd hospital bills but you're just hurrr durrring as usual. He got you with his poorly elaborated comparison, you gobbled it right up.
Member
Posts: 90,657
Joined: Dec 31 2007
Gold: 2,489.69
Jul 18 2017 06:54pm
Quote (EndlessSky @ Jul 18 2017 05:40pm)
How is it a right?

Someone has to provide it after going to school for 8 years. It doesn't just exist floating in the wind.


I could make a Christian argument but I know you favor a more selfish Christianity.

I could make a more economic one as nobrow did but you're too set in your ways to really bother with on literally every issue.

Reactionary as usual though, I wasnt making the argument that it is a right at all. I was simply stating that Obamacare sets the stage in terms of health care being a right to facilitate a single payer system more easily, and said it isn't close enough in terms of specifics to act as a pivot point to a single payer system with ease. In other words Obamacare isn't a single payer system-lite.

This post was edited by thesnipa on Jul 18 2017 06:58pm
Member
Posts: 33,514
Joined: Oct 9 2008
Gold: 2,617.52
Jul 18 2017 06:56pm
Quote (nobrow @ Jul 18 2017 08:43pm)
Everyone is already paying for it with absurd hospital bills but you're just hurrr durrring as usual. He got you with his poorly elaborated comparison, you gobbled it right up.


Reported for spam.
Member
Posts: 61,380
Joined: Mar 14 2006
Gold: 10.77
Jul 18 2017 07:18pm
If they would write a bipartisan compromise they could get something passed.

How about a national system for everyone under the age of 18 (or 26 or somewhere between those ages) who isn't covered by a parent's or own employer plan, nationalized coverage for pregnant women, add some family leave in there, federal takeover of Medicaid to streamline it, then add in some goodies like being able to purchase any insurance across state lines to drive competition, bump age benefits to 67... I don't know, there are good ideas on both sides. Just take the best ideas and combine them as best as possible.

Or just commit to saving the country lots of money and do a Medicare for All bill while allowing a competing private sector to still exist with the whole state lines thing included for people who want "cadillac" plans above and beyond MFA. It's fiscally conservative. It's also socialist. Makes perfect sense to me as a bipartisan reform.
Member
Posts: 90,657
Joined: Dec 31 2007
Gold: 2,489.69
Jul 18 2017 07:25pm
Quote (inkanddagger @ Jul 18 2017 07:18pm)
If they would write a bipartisan compromise they could get something passed.

How about a national system for everyone under the age of 18 (or 26 or somewhere between those ages) who isn't covered by a parent's or own employer plan, nationalized coverage for pregnant women, add some family leave in there, federal takeover of Medicaid to streamline it, then add in some goodies like being able to purchase any insurance across state lines to drive competition, bump age benefits to 67... I don't know, there are good ideas on both sides. Just take the best ideas and combine them as best as possible.

Or just commit to saving the country lots of money and do a Medicare for All bill while allowing a competing private sector to still exist with the whole state lines thing included for people who want "cadillac" plans above and beyond MFA. It's fiscally conservative. It's also socialist. Makes perfect sense to me as a bipartisan reform.


anyone else remember the debate where trump just repeated the bold over and over while calling the problem easy?

I agree on all your bipartisan suggestions though
Member
Posts: 33,514
Joined: Oct 9 2008
Gold: 2,617.52
Jul 18 2017 08:26pm
Quote (inkanddagger @ Jul 18 2017 09:18pm)
If they would write a bipartisan compromise they could get something passed.

How about a national system for everyone under the age of 18 (or 26 or somewhere between those ages) who isn't covered by a parent's or own employer plan, nationalized coverage for pregnant women, add some family leave in there, federal takeover of Medicaid to streamline it, then add in some goodies like being able to purchase any insurance across state lines to drive competition, bump age benefits to 67... I don't know, there are good ideas on both sides. Just take the best ideas and combine them as best as possible.

Or just commit to saving the country lots of money and do a Medicare for All bill while allowing a competing private sector to still exist with the whole state lines thing included for people who want "cadillac" plans above and beyond MFA. It's fiscally conservative. It's also socialist. Makes perfect sense to me as a bipartisan reform.


Democrats won't allow the mandate to be repealed because it would collapse the socialism half of the system.
Member
Posts: 53,139
Joined: Sep 2 2004
Gold: 57.00
Jul 18 2017 08:40pm
Quote (thesnipa @ 18 Jul 2017 21:25)
anyone else remember the debate where trump just repeated the bold over and over while calling the problem easy?

I agree on all your bipartisan suggestions though

yep now he's President

this idea of "national healthcare and ppl can buy better" sounds nice but the more expensive better will become a "right" in no time flat, probably due to some wacked out "separate but equal" bastardized ruling
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev12345619Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll