Here is my analysis for each team's picks in the 2012 NFL Draft. The draft grades are on a basic scale, you can figure it out. Feel free to ask any questions/make any comments and I'll try to address them all.
NFC WestArizona CardinalsMichael Floyd, WR – Gives Fitz a ton of help and, even though Whizy will say he has to earn the spot over Roberts, Doucet, etc, Floyd will be the #2 in week 1.
Jamell Fleming, CB – I don’t know too much about him but all the “experts” see to be in love with him so I’ll just be happy with it.
Bobby Massie, OT – Holy shit. How did this happen? There were some health concerns but that was the only thing I could find that would justify Massie falling. He was a second round pick projected to possibly go late in the first. The Cardinals creamed their pants when this pick happened.
Senio Kelemete, OT – I’m personally not too high on Kelemete but he does have plenty of experience and could step in for us early and be effective. I felt as if he took plays off occasionally though. I hope I’m wrong.
Justin Bethel, DB – I’ve seen him listed as a corner and a safety. Either way, I love it. This was a sleeper of mine. From a small school with huge talent. Could be a major steal down the road.
Ryan Lindley, QB – LOVE LOVE LOVE this pick. He’s a project for sure, but he’s got the physical tool needs for an NFL QB and can and will push Skelton for the starting job once Kolb is inevitably injured.
Nate Potter, OT – I had Potter going in the 4th, maybe slipping to the 5th. Getting him in the 7th is just ridiculous. He had a bad combine, but he is a physical freak.
Overall – Gotta give the Cardinals some props for this draft. Partially for players falling to them, but they also drafted smart, going for BPA at a position that wasn’t necessarily the highest need rather than reaching for a position of need as they oh so often did in the past.
Grade – A-
San Francisco 49ersA.J. Jenkins, WR – To not be bias because it’s the Niners, I’ll turn to Walt. “This is bizarre. Did the 49ers know that Coby Fleener, Cordy Glenn and Stephen Hill were still on the board, or were they thrown off because the first round was going by so quickly? I don't get it. This is a huge reach. Here's where A.J. Jenkins ranked on the major big boards: 67, 76, 57, 73 and 70. Yeesh.” Meh…
LaMichael James, RB – Maybe they don’t like Hunter anymore? I mean, why would they draft his double? James and Hunter are very similar and with the acquisition of Brandon Jacobs, I don’t see why they even took a RB that wasn’t named Trent Richardson falling to them lol.
Joe Looney, OG – This was probably the only sensible pick for the Niners, and it’s a great one at that. They lost Snyder to the Cardinals and Looney can step in from day 1 and replace him. He has tons of experience and will do well for the Niners.
Darius Flemming, DE/OLB – Might as well continue the trend of mediocre picks now that we got the good one out of the way. Flemming is just an average player who will add depth.
Trenton Robinson, S – Goldson is a liability in coverage big time. Robinson is a steal this late and he can be an upgrade if he has some time to develop and not be rushed into the starting line.
Jason Slowey, C – Another bonehead pick. There were better center prospects on the board and the Niners just messed up here, plain and simple.
Cam Johnson, DE/OLB – Walter… “Talk about a steal - Cam Johnson was No. 50 on Mike Mayock's big board. It's unbelievable that he fell to the middle of the seventh round. His work ethic is a concern, but still, he should have gone much earlier than this.” If Harbaugh keeps his eye on Johnson and makes sure he stays on track, he can be a very good player for the Niners for a long time and upgrade an already great defense.
Overall – How does a team with really no pressing areas of concern, no real needs in the draft, have such a bad draft? I mean, they could have just gone BPA at every pick, regardless of position and been just fine. But instead, they reach for players, take players at areas of no concern and miss out on some great picks? I don’t get it. Johnson and Robinson were steals and great picks, but come on Niners, you just got to the mountain top, stop dangling that rope for us bottom feeders in the west to grab onto.
Grade – C
Seattle SeahawksBruce Irvin, DE/OLB – OK, I’m trying to think of some reasoning for this pick. I’m really trying to justify it and I simply cannot. Irvin is a speed rusher and that’s about it. He had off the field issues, a down year at West Virginia and a decent combine. Maybe the Seahawks know something that no one else on the planet Earth knows, but I doubt it and this is just a bad pick. My positive outlook on this though…..Irvin will do well. He won’t ever amount to be worthy of this pick, but he will do well. He will start and he will get numbers for the Seahawks, but he’ll never be more than an over drafted, well enough player.
Bobby Wagner, OLB – I like this pick a lot more than most. Wagner is better than Irvin though which makes it a painful pick. Wagner can play all over the field. OLB, ILB and he can even put his hand in the dirt and play DE imo. He’ll be used as an OLB most likely and will probably out perform Irvin and make that pick even worse. I’m sorry Seahawk fans, but that pick of Irvin is going to be pushed back in your face for a while. :-/
Russel Wilson, QB – LOVE IT!! Best pick of the draft for the Seahawks. Wilson is a natural leader and a winner. I don’t give a flying fuck about his height, I think he can be successful in the NFL. Some may question this pick since the Seahawks just got Flynn, but if anyone should know about this situation, it’s me. Fuck QBs who have a few games of success on teams with high powered offenses that are winning and then get thrown into a starting job on a struggling team. No, fuck that right in the ear.
Robert Turbin, RB – I like Turbin. He’s a sleeper prospect who’s very strong and extremely fast for having the strength he does (or extremely strong for having the speed he does, however you want to look at it haha). I think he’ll be a nice starter for the Seahawks as soon as Lynch’s bum ass decides he doesn’t want to play anymore now that he’s paid.
Jaye Howard, DT – Fits the range for the pick, isn’t a stand out player, isn’t a scrub. Nice depth addition mainly who could develop into a starter.
Korey Toomer, ILB – See above for my reasoning for continuously going to Walter. “It's hardly a surprise that the Seahawks spent a second draft pick on a linebacker, but Korey Toomer is a reach in the middle of Round 5. But I don't think Bazuzu/Pete Carroll cares about reaches at this point.” More so than at this point, but all together lol.
Jeremy Lane, CB – Solid special teams player and depth for the corner position. He’s athletic and lengthy and could cause problems for receivers.
Winston Guy, S – Most have Guy as a solid depth and special teams player. I have him as a starter in this league. He had a very solid and consistent season last year and has all the tools to be a starting safety in the NFL. He’ll look nice next to Earl Thomas in a year or so (maybe even this year). At the very least, he will be the solid depth and special teams player.
J.R. Sweezy, DT – Another DT for depth. No real value here.
Greg Scruggs, DT – Fucking Christ another DT for depth with no real value here. Side note, fucking word capitalized Christ. The fuck is that shit?
Overall – Well, there are some obvious questionable picks. I feel like the Seahawks could have and should have just snagged Mike Wallace to give Flynn a real weapon, lose that first and they still could have gotten Wagner in the second, Wilson in the third, Irvin and Turbin in the 4th.
Grade – C-
St. Louis RamsMichael Brockers, DT – I turn to Walter early in this analysis. “There's nothing like picking a raw prospect and screwing over your franchise quarterback in the span of an hour. I don't quite get why the Rams wouldn't help out Sam Bradford with David DeCastro or Riley Reiff, or perhaps jumping the Cardinals to obtain Michael Floyd, but maybe they have some sort of plan with their three second-rounders. The move down is what keeps this from being a D.” The “D” at the end is in reference to his draft grade of this pick which was a ‘C’. Not a good pick. Brockers is inexperienced and very raw. Has all the makings of a bust.
Brian Quick, WR – Another very raw pick. Let’s take a look at the receivers picked in the second round after Quick. Stephen Hill, Alshon Jeffery, Ryan Broyles and Rueben Randle. All of these players (with the exception of Broyles who’s more of a complimentary receiver as I said in my Lions analysis) have the capability to be #1 receivers in this league from day one. Quick has the potential, but he has the potential to bust as well.
Janoris Jenkins, CB – Great pick. Jenkins has outstanding talent and will be able to make Fitz work a little harder when playing the Rams. The Rams will have to keep a close eye on him though, keep his ass out of trouble. Fisher shouldn’t have a problem doing that though.
Isaiah Pead, RB – Love this pick. I really liked what I saw from Pead. It may be a bit early for him but the Rams clearly liked what they saw (as I did) and wanted to make sure to get their guy, leaving Miller and James on the board to pick Pead.
Trumaine Johnson, DB – There is some value here but aside from that, the Rams get a versatile player (I don’t know if they’ll use him at safety or corner) who can develop into a very nice player for the Rams. For now, he’ll be a depth and special teamer.
Chris Givens, WR – The Rams needed receivers badly and they got them. This pick makes me like the pick of Quick a bit more. Quick is a big, physical receiver and Givens is a smaller, speedier guy. They will complement each other well.
Rokevious Watkins, OG – This is a bit of a reach for Watkins but I liked him as a player. He’s versatile, able to play inside and out and is a good run blocker which will help SJax and Pead immensely. He’s decent enough in pass blocking but I’m really shocked the Rams waited so long to get an offensive line piece. It seems like the Rams and Indy had the same plan. Get weapons for our franchise QB, fix a piece of the D, fuck oline for this year. Lol.
Greg Zuerlein, K – He’s a kicker, not much to say.
Aaron Brown, OLB – I don’t know much about either of the next two picks but Brown seems to have been a consensus UDFA. But, as Walter said, “there’s no such thing as a reach in Round 7.”
Daryl Richardson, RB – As I said above, I don’t know much here but this is just a depth pick if he even makes the team.
Overall – Rams had an OK draft. They could have gone in a few directions but as I alluded to, they kind of seemed to have the same game plan as the Colts for the most part. The pick of Brockers wasn’t a good choice imo. They should have jumped us to make sure they got Floyd once they lost out on Blackmon. I would have moved with Minny to get Kalil from them instead of even considering Blackmon though. This was a deep WR draft imo and they could have gotten the same WRs that they got, along with protection for Bradford before he turns into David Carr.
Grade – C
***Post is too damn long, rest is coming in the following posts.***