d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > Walker's Promise
Prev14567Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 77,542
Joined: Nov 30 2008
Gold: 500.00
Oct 21 2014 04:49pm
Quote (Santara @ Oct 21 2014 05:37pm)
I do, and justly. Unlike in the public sector, a private sector relationship between a union and the employer operates under the bounds of economic realities like the employer's interest in maintaining uninterrupted production and limits on revenues to fund the union's demands. If the unions command too much in the way of wages and benefits, the company suffers competitively. Just look at the inexorable rise of Toyota over General Motors for a prime example. Toyota generally builds a better car, and they do it while selling it for less. The difference in labor costs to the respective corporations is roughly $1500 per car.

But what happens when the "company" is government funded by the taxpayers? Does the company go out of business if they pay the workers more than can be afforded? No. They raise taxes on the public and continue to operate under a flawed and uneconomic model.



This election? Not terribly likely. Would be even better to foster an environment that didn't compel companies to seek that route.


while we're complaing about labor costs, let's keep in mind that the ceo of gm also made about 6 times that of toyota's
Member
Posts: 51,928
Joined: Jan 3 2009
Gold: 8,933.00
Oct 21 2014 05:08pm
Quote (duffman316 @ Oct 21 2014 05:49pm)
while we're complaing about labor costs, let's keep in mind that the ceo of gm also made about 6 times that of toyota's


...and in a perfect world where GM would have been allowed to bankrupt, like they SHOULD have, barring illegal government intervention, the CEO of GM should have been working for the CEO of Toyota.
Member
Posts: 69,886
Joined: Jan 22 2009
Gold: 133,165.00
Oct 21 2014 06:48pm
Quote (Santara @ Oct 21 2014 04:08pm)
...and in a perfect world where GM would have been allowed to bankrupt, like they SHOULD have, barring illegal government intervention, the CEO of GM should have been working for the CEO of Toyota.


^^^
Member
Posts: 38,317
Joined: Jul 12 2006
Gold: 20.31
Oct 21 2014 07:27pm
Quote (RUSSiABANK @ Oct 20 2014 10:38pm)
yes, even the "fiscally conservative" are horribly corrupt and just the opposite. There is no political right remaining when it comes to finances in America.


I don't like tying the two things together because that's unnecessary. Walker isn't (hilariously) corrupt just because of what he believes or because he's a "fiscal conservative." There are plenty of incumbents, even governors, who have the exact same governing philosophy that Walker does but they didn't illegally coordinate with outside groups, construct the WEDC, and whatever else.

There's still a sizable chunk of people in office and the electorate who support those policies. True they can't reliably win national elections anymore, but they're still there.
Member
Posts: 69,886
Joined: Jan 22 2009
Gold: 133,165.00
Oct 21 2014 08:21pm
Quote (Pollster @ Oct 21 2014 06:27pm)
I don't like tying the two things together because that's unnecessary. Walker isn't (hilariously) corrupt just because of what he believes or because he's a "fiscal conservative." There are plenty of incumbents, even governors, who have the exact same governing philosophy that Walker does but they didn't illegally coordinate with outside groups, construct the WEDC, and whatever else.

There's still a sizable chunk of people in office and the electorate who support those policies. True they can't reliably win national elections anymore, but they're still there.


I know he's not corrupt because of what he believes. He's corrupt because he's a politician lmao.
Member
Posts: 33,863
Joined: Jul 2 2007
Gold: 633.87
Oct 21 2014 09:49pm
Is corruption such a bad thing? The public interest is the only good that should matter in governance.
Member
Posts: 77,542
Joined: Nov 30 2008
Gold: 500.00
Oct 21 2014 09:56pm
Quote (bogie160 @ Oct 21 2014 10:49pm)
Is corruption such a bad thing? The public interest is the only good that should matter in governance.


should use that as the republican slogan for 2016
Member
Posts: 40,833
Joined: Sep 17 2011
Gold: 0.00
Oct 21 2014 10:08pm
Quote (bogie160 @ 22 Oct 2014 03:49)
Is corruption such a bad thing? The public interest is the only good that should matter in governance.


The public good cannot be first in the mind of a corrupt politician. First for them is their own wealth and power.
Member
Posts: 77,542
Joined: Nov 30 2008
Gold: 500.00
Oct 21 2014 10:26pm
Quote (RUSSiABANK @ Oct 21 2014 09:21pm)
I know he's not corrupt because of what he believes. He's corrupt because he's a politician lmao.


ron paul was a different matter, they're not all bad ~ that way
Member
Posts: 10,566
Joined: May 31 2013
Gold: 0.76
Oct 22 2014 08:35am
Quote (Santara @ 21 Oct 2014 17:37)
I do, and justly. Unlike in the public sector, a private sector relationship between a union and the employer operates under the bounds of economic realities like the employer's interest in maintaining uninterrupted production and limits on revenues to fund the union's demands. If the unions command too much in the way of wages and benefits, the company suffers competitively. Just look at the inexorable rise of Toyota over General Motors for a prime example. Toyota generally builds a better car, and they do it while selling it for less. The difference in labor costs to the respective corporations is roughly $1500 per car.

But what happens when the "company" is government funded by the taxpayers? Does the company go out of business if they pay the workers more than can be afforded? No. They raise taxes on the public and continue to operate under a flawed and uneconomic model.



This election? Not terribly likely. Would be even better to foster an environment that didn't compel companies to seek that route.



using Overseas labor vs unionized U.S. labor makes a horrible example to compare fora state using union labor or non union labor for one the state is not manufacturing or selling anything. And the state is not a money making endeavour it is a service endeavour. The wages that Mr. walker would be paying his union workers would be going back into his state's economy which would revitalize a dying economy boosting sales tax, and increasing state revenues.
If the State budget runs low then trim the damn budget but don't bust the backs of the labor force.
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev14567Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll