Quote (Voyaging @ May 13 2012 09:51pm)
Ah I guess I was thinking more of "counting fully" a set. Such as answering the question "how many natural numbers are in an infinite set?" Infinite, of course.
i made reference to the infinity hotel earlier, aka hilbert's paradox.
a hotel has an infinite number of rooms numbered 1, 2, ...
This hotel is completely full right now. that is, no room is empty and it holds an infinite number of people.
A new guest comes in and wants a room. the manager says sure, we have room for you. he moves person in room 1 to room 2, person in room 2 to room 3, person in room r to room r+1. now room 1 is empty, and this new guest has a room. this hotel is still fully occupied with an infinite number of people + 1.
now a bus comes along with infinite people. they are seated in seats 0, 1, 2, 3, ... and they all want a room. the manage says sure, we have room for you. so he puts the person in room 1 to room 2, room 2 to room 4, room r to room 2r. for each person on the bus in seat s, he puts them in room 2s+1. every room is occupied. the hotel holds an infinite + infinite number of people
now an infinite number of buses come along with people in seats 1, 2, 3, .... the manager says sure, we have room for you. he puts all the existing people in room 2^r. for each bus b and each corresponding person in seat s, he puts them in room = bth prime (eg 3, 5, 7, 11, ...) raised to the power s. now the hotel has an infinite number of unoccupied rooms (eg room 1, room 6, ..) and it holds an infinite * infinite number of people.
now a bus of people in seats labbeled after every irrational number comes along to his desk and the manager says "sorry, we don't have room" even though he has an infinite number of unoccupied rooms