Try 2.585, and calculate both the low and the high. It's closer to the mark. Then go read my last edit, made prior to your post.

This post was edited by InsaneBobb on Jun 2 2008 01:20am

im stating yours is = to a 157 EE... so the margin of error is ~ 0.08%

compared to your theory on your charm = 175 EE lvl 55

i did put a disclaimer on it, read the first thing on the guide....

my point being your wrong your charm doesnt do more dmg than a 170 EE lvl 55




This post was edited by A_U_T_I_S_M on Jun 2 2008 01:24am

I'll make this easy for you, save you some heartache, since you didn't read my edit:

heres ill make it simple on you, since you didnt read post 1



so an error of 2EE which is ~ 1.2% of value its sapose to Guestamate is worth making a big fuss blowing up your charm to something that does a whole 25+ ee dif ~ 20%
and get 1000 +1's about nothing more than proving my original point

i was 1.2% off you were 20%

t4t



instead of simply putting nice guide!

This post was edited by A_U_T_I_S_M on Jun 2 2008 01:28am

Dude, that disclaimer has nothing to do with a mention that your kill calculations (which are pretty good averages, for feeder) are based on FEEDER. You put the information out. Is it so hard to put in there a simple (Kill calculations are based on feeder classes, and increase the higher tier you get)?

Dude, don't beat that horse man, because your "top of the post" disclaimer didn't address WHICH kill numbers you were playing with. I wasn't critisizing it, I was making a suggestion on an improvement.



Tell INTEL it's only taking his alch 3500 kills to get to MQ. Oh wait, you probably can't, right? It is a nice guide. Is a suggestion for an improvement so difficult for you to deal with?

And man, the EE bit, did I not say your dmg calc was very close, and props on it? Erm, yes. So, with you refusing a suggestion that is 100% correct, and trying to focus on something I already stated you were closer on, why did you even bother to post? In fact, my very first post was a simple question on where your numbers came from, your thought line on how you would bother with calculating based on tier number, rather than base damages at all. Man.

In fact, since we're up about your skills here, which you obviously believe are so incredibly solid that questions aren't worth answering, only worth saying "don't mess up my work", here's a reminder how you answer a simple "Why" question:





This post was edited by InsaneBobb on Jun 2 2008 01:34am

said nothing of the sort its for feeder, everyone knows there is a exp cut as char climbs/class's, anything else obvious you would like to point out?

tier number = base number... idk what your trying to prove, besides you being wrong again

base dmg on tier 1 = exactly 1/2 of tier 2 and so forth, its just simplifying it, keeping the respected proportions

there is a reason why its tier 1 and 2 and not tier 1 and 2.0001

This post was edited by A_U_T_I_S_M on Jun 2 2008 01:36am

Tell me... When you first started playing LS, did you know that you'd be getting less exp at Ninja than at Mage or Rogue, or whatever you started with?

Next question: Did you read the guides available at the time?

Myself, I read all the guides. As a new player. I'm glad that other guides pointed out the simple things. It helped. So are you ONLY writing for pros, who you believe know these things (even if they've never been past Feeder/Sam), or are you writing for everyone?

BTW: I don't recall any guide having mentioned the feeder>unlockable exp changes in any of their guides. I may have missed one somewhere, but doing a very quick scan through several of the guides in the guides sticky, I didn't see them. Seeing as your kill calc directly utilizes that information, it'd actually be a VERY good thing to put in there. Further, even an "averages" chart would be nice for the number of kills required to get to MQ on the succession of classes would be super (only speaking of possible additions to your guide here).

This post was edited by InsaneBobb on Jun 2 2008 01:43am

it is what it is bob, and you are what you are, and nothing here is changing

This post was edited by A_U_T_I_S_M on Jun 2 2008 02:03am

No idea what you're trying to say, but Gn8.



Nice guide I guess?

ty sir