d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > This Kid Grew Up, Maybe There's Hope For Others
Prev14567810Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 1,711
Joined: Jul 17 2008
Gold: 581.00
Jul 3 2012 09:56am
You could think that atleast some republicans likes to think that higher education are left leaning and that's why they are taking a stance against it :rolleyes: .

(not sure if posted already)
Member
Posts: 26,027
Joined: Jan 14 2006
Gold: 110.00
Jul 3 2012 02:41pm
Quote (WidowMaKer_MK @ Jul 3 2012 09:44am)
...no , it does not follow even if it's correct . You can't paint all phd's with the same brush as professors with phd's .

As a anecdotal note the overwhelming majority of medical doctors I have met in America are far from liberal .


I'm not, but if most phds are professors, and if most professors are left leaning, then most phds are left leaning.

Aaaaannd if we look at the link I posted, the split between democrat/republican masters/phd holders is nearly 60/40 respectively.

So yeah, most phds are left leaning.
Member
Posts: 34,649
Joined: Jul 2 2007
Gold: 273.37
Jul 3 2012 09:24pm
Quote (Wakeskater77 @ Jul 3 2012 08:23am)
There's a reason why I said phds...I'm talking about the highly educated, not just people with BAs/BSs.

That being said, I think college graduates tend to be more left than right.


Are lawyers not highly educated? How about those who obtain an MBA? Why are Economists less relevant (or why aren't they more relevant) than many low paying academic positions in the humanities? Does obtaining a Phd in the Humanities (or many social sciences) qualify you to speak on the Economy or many of the political issues of the day?

Relatively low-paying academic positions (PhDs aren't normally obtained for the money) will always be hotbeds of leftist ideology, just as the business and economic professions are heavily skewed towards the right.

If you go back to Kerry vs Bush (I'd posit that Obama v McCain was an anomaly due to the political climate), 52% of college graduates voted Republican, at the very least I wouldn't say that they lean left, and Republicans often edge out Democrats in both the graduate and professional degree categories, just like they edge out the Democrats among the middle and upper-middle classes.

The Academic community is left-leaning in large part because the academic life appeals to values held by left-leaning individuals. I don't think you can divorce that from the equation.
Member
Posts: 26,027
Joined: Jan 14 2006
Gold: 110.00
Jul 3 2012 10:12pm
Quote (bogie160 @ Jul 3 2012 09:24pm)
Are lawyers not highly educated? How about those who obtain an MBA? Why are Economists less relevant (or why aren't they more relevant) than many low paying academic positions in the humanities? Does obtaining a Phd in the Humanities (or many social sciences) qualify you to speak on the Economy or many of the political issues of the day?

Relatively low-paying academic positions (PhDs aren't normally obtained for the money) will always be hotbeds of leftist ideology, just as the business and economic professions are heavily skewed towards the right.

If you go back to Kerry vs Bush (I'd posit that Obama v McCain was an anomaly due to the political climate), 52% of college graduates voted Republican, at the very least I wouldn't say that they lean left, and Republicans often edge out Democrats in both the graduate and professional degree categories, just like they edge out the Democrats among the middle and upper-middle classes.

The Academic community is left-leaning in large part because the academic life appeals to values held by left-leaning individuals. I don't think you can divorce that from the equation.


I've never bought the argument that being a professor is removing oneself from the job market and placing oneself in an ivory tower. Ivory tower, sure...but absent from the job market? Please...

And I never said I placed any more value between different disciplines...simply that those who hold phds are the most educated.

Member
Posts: 799
Joined: Jul 19 2007
Gold: 0.00
Jul 3 2012 10:58pm
Member
Posts: 4,287
Joined: Aug 19 2011
Gold: 1.00
Jul 4 2012 12:46am
Quote (CLiXKoNNeKT @ Jul 3 2012 09:58pm)
http://i.imgur.com/9VUU3.jpg



few people in the world would know find that funny :lol:
Member
Posts: 11,277
Joined: Jan 24 2007
Gold: 11.00
Jul 4 2012 01:08am
Quote (Wakeskater77 @ Jul 3 2012 01:24am)
I think most highly educated people are liberal...most professors and people with phd's, in my experience, are liberal. I'm sure someone can google this. The only prominent exception I can think of would be economics phds who are generally conservative. I can't think of another discipline that is notoriously conservative. 

And then you have Billy Bob and Jethro who love their guns and think the goverment should stay out of their lives so they can drive their atvs down the highway and canoodle with their cousins.

Stereotypes maybe, but I think there's a partial truth to liberals being at least more educated then conservatives.



that is all
Member
Posts: 799
Joined: Jul 19 2007
Gold: 0.00
Jul 4 2012 01:13am
Quote (dothe @ Jul 4 2012 03:08pm)
that is all


Member
Posts: 62,215
Joined: Jun 3 2007
Gold: 9,039.20
Jul 4 2012 01:20am
Nom chomsky biggest fake piece of shit I've ever seen. Guy thinks he's some messiah to anarchism and goes around campuses across the country charging them absurd fees to hear him speak about nonsense he doesn't even follow.
Member
Posts: 63,058
Joined: Jul 15 2005
Gold: 152.00
Jul 4 2012 01:52am
Chomsky hipster
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev14567810Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll