d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > Dobbs V Jackson
Prev1192021222335Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 20,274
Joined: Aug 17 2021
Gold: 1,453.85
Jun 24 2022 09:04pm
Quote (18nomaUSEast @ Jun 24 2022 07:58pm)
without outside interference? what do you call the rearing process between expulsion from the host's body through the first several years before complex thought exists?


I think his point is that being alive is a very good experience and we shouldn't deny the unborn of it due to selfish reasons.
Member
Posts: 17,972
Joined: Jun 3 2019
Gold: 261.69
Jun 24 2022 09:06pm
Quote (JessiWan @ 24 Jun 2022 23:04)
I think his point is that being alive is a very good experience and we shouldn't deny the unborn of it due to selfish reasons.


who says being alive is a good experience O_O
Member
Posts: 35,291
Joined: Aug 17 2004
Gold: 12,730.67
Jun 24 2022 09:06pm
Quote (fender @ Jun 24 2022 07:34pm)
not with authoritarians and religious bigots of course, but certainly with people who value freedom, bodily autonomy, women's rights, and the government staying out of your private business.

i think you could make a decent argument that it can reasonably become the government's business once the fetus is viable (a quick reminder that just 8% of abortions are performed week 13 and later, just about 1% week 20 or later - earliest viability is around week 23, which accounts for less than half a percent of all abortions) - at least in a modern society that can afford to and has the political will to ensure that baby doesn't suffer from hunger and poverty - so that definitely doesn't include the US.

so yeah, fundamentally none of your or the government's business - especially a government that doesn't give a flying fuck about actual children.


Why is your country's cut off at 12 weeks then? A fetus certainly isn't viable at that point. Clearly, the majority of Germans believe that a nonviable fetus has value and deserves to be protected. Are the majority of Germans religious bigots and/or authoritarians?
Member
Posts: 20,274
Joined: Aug 17 2021
Gold: 1,453.85
Jun 24 2022 09:07pm
Quote (18nomaUSEast @ Jun 24 2022 08:06pm)
who says being alive is a good experience O_O


He does. Not me.

Being born in itself is neutral. If someone alive is being tortured everyday of his life, then it's better that he not be born at all.
Member
Posts: 25,364
Joined: Aug 11 2013
Gold: 7,621.00
Jun 24 2022 09:08pm
Quote (18nomaUSEast @ Jun 24 2022 10:58pm)
without outside interference? what do you call the rearing process between expulsion from the host's body through the first several years before complex thought exists?


I call it natural and expected. It's observed in pretty much most mammal species. What's unnatural is to purposefully end an offspring's life. You look at nature around you and pretty much all organisms are trying to pass on their genes.

This post was edited by ofthevoid on Jun 24 2022 09:09pm
Member
Posts: 35,291
Joined: Aug 17 2004
Gold: 12,730.67
Jun 24 2022 09:09pm
Quote (ofthevoid @ Jun 24 2022 07:09pm)
Why aren't you happy that more black boys and girls are going to have a chance at life, to grow up to pursue their dreams and be happy, laugh, cry, live.

My thing with abortion proponents is like, do some introspection. You today are alive, you can enjoy the sun, a good meal, sex, fill in the blank. If life is that miserable for you, you can commit suicide, it's your choice. You don't though, because life is good and you have a inherent drive and want to live. But yet you want to deny that young life the same experience for convenience purposes? It's inhumane and absolutely selfish.


You're projecting here. Black people don't even smile when their photo is taken and you expect them to be filled with happiness? What sort of fantasy world are you living in? The reality is that many black people will die at the hands of a police officer or their friend will blow their head off. It's much easier to say goodbye to a fetus than your son with his brains blown out. We should respect that decision.
Member
Posts: 17,972
Joined: Jun 3 2019
Gold: 261.69
Jun 24 2022 09:10pm
Quote (ofthevoid @ 24 Jun 2022 23:08)
I call it natural and expected. It's observed in pretty much most mammal species. What's unnatural is to purposefully end an offspring's life. You look at nature around you and most organisms are trying to pass on their genes.


https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Infanticide_(zoology)#Infanticide_by_parents_and_caregivers
Member
Posts: 25,364
Joined: Aug 11 2013
Gold: 7,621.00
Jun 24 2022 09:11pm
Quote (18nomaUSEast @ Jun 24 2022 11:10pm)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Infanticide_(zoology)#Infanticide_by_parents_and_caregivers


Cool, exceptions exist. Are exceptions the norm though?
Member
Posts: 17,972
Joined: Jun 3 2019
Gold: 261.69
Jun 24 2022 09:13pm
Quote (ofthevoid @ 24 Jun 2022 23:11)
Cool, exceptions exist. Are exceptions the norm though?


call me crazy but I'd say humans are indeed exceptional
Member
Posts: 14,112
Joined: Jul 4 2007
Gold: 0.20
Jun 24 2022 09:37pm
I hate the fed, so this is great. Local governments can cater to the local people, instead of deferring to bureaucrats a thousand miles away.
In places where people abhor abortion, they can outlaw it. In places where people value a woman's choice over a baby's life, they can keep it. That's democracy!
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev1192021222335Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll