d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Sports Coliseum > Hockey > Battle Of Alberta Gdt
Prev1444546474849Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Views: 3294Replies: 485Track Topic
Member
Posts: 32,264
Joined: Mar 11 2008
Gold: 1,157.00
#451
May 27 2022 01:02pm
Quote (VAS3CT0MY @ May 27 2022 12:39pm)
Without a doubt, they scored 4 goals and like a minute in the second period, the game couldve easily been won by either team. As well the series too. The Kings, Leafs, and Pens were all up 3-2 on their first round series and ended up losing.
I think most of the issue (for me any way, and probably most others who didnt have an emotional stake in the game) isnt the call itself but rather the ambiguity in which the rule is written. It was the perfect example of a true 50/50 call and because of the vagueness of the rules it was judged in a way that a large portion of hockey fans just will not be able to see. To you its a good goal, to me its also good, and to SP as well, but then Subzero, Drago, Manajunkie, etc. all see it it the other way around.
In reality its on the league, not the refs. The league needs to step up and rewrite the vague ambiguous rules so that they have concrete terms and criteria. The game will be better for the players and the fans if we all know what can or can't happen and what is or is not allowed.


I mean. Sutter could have challenged. Couldn't he of?


And oilers win 4 straight but "series can go anyway too" come on man.

This post was edited by Subzer0isGG on May 27 2022 01:14pm
Member
Posts: 27,905
Joined: Jul 24 2009
Gold: 726.69
#452
May 27 2022 01:17pm
"I felt it wasn't a kicking motion" he says to the press... of course he'd say that post game... lmao what a silly fucker.
Member
Posts: 32,264
Joined: Mar 11 2008
Gold: 1,157.00
#453
May 27 2022 01:19pm
Quote (ManaJunkie @ May 27 2022 01:17pm)
"I felt it wasn't a kicking motion" he says to the press... of course he'd say that post game... lmao what a silly fucker.


The dude admits to assisting it in with his foot. And people here still saying there was no kick. I can't even
Member
Posts: 27,905
Joined: Jul 24 2009
Gold: 726.69
#454
May 27 2022 01:20pm
Quote (Subzer0isGG @ May 27 2022 03:19pm)
The dude admits to assisting it in with his foot. And people here still saying there was no kick. I can't even


Meh, everyone is entitled to their wrong opinion, right lol
Member
Posts: 46,225
Joined: May 26 2009
Gold: 8,587.00
#455
May 27 2022 02:45pm
Not an Oilers fan by any means but in my opinion it was the right call. Obviously the rule is terribly written and something of this magnitude was bound to happen

Deliberate kicking motion to me doesn’t mean a full blown soccer kick. If you “assist” the puck into the net and your foot is not stationary, that’s a kick imo.

At the end of the day, that’s not what cost the flames the series.

This post was edited by SharpNips on May 27 2022 02:45pm
Member
Posts: 42,857
Joined: Oct 9 2010
Gold: 10.55
#456
May 27 2022 03:01pm
Quote (Subzer0isGG @ May 27 2022 12:02pm)
I mean. Sutter could have challenged. Couldn't he of?


And oilers win 4 straight but "series can go anyway too" come on man.


Im pretty certain you cannot challenge that.
IF the goal had stood and IF the Flames won, it would be a 3-2 series which is anybodies game. So yes, it could have gone either way. Its funny, when the oilers were down 2-3 to the kings (the worst playoff team) and everybody was laughing, you came back to win two in a row. Fuck outta here if you think the flames couldnt have done the same.

If these are good goals, and the one bruins posted last night where the jets kick that shit in from damn near the faceoff circle then colemans shouldve counted too, either that or they all shouldnt count. But not a mixture, and thats the fuckin problem.
https://twitter.com/scottcwheeler/status/1530040346184454161
https://twitter.com/TheAthleticNHL/status/1448146408146571264


This post was edited by VAS3CT0MY on May 27 2022 03:15pm
Member
Posts: 39,795
Joined: May 8 2017
Gold: 5.10
Warn: 20%
#457
May 27 2022 03:24pm
Goal shud have counted. Edm got lucky LOL
Member
Posts: 32,264
Joined: Mar 11 2008
Gold: 1,157.00
#458
May 27 2022 03:27pm
Quote (VAS3CT0MY @ May 27 2022 03:01pm)
Im pretty certain you cannot challenge that.
IF the goal had stood and IF the Flames won, it would be a 3-2 series which is anybodies game. So yes, it could have gone either way. Its funny, when the oilers were down 2-3 to the kings (the worst playoff team) and everybody was laughing, you came back to win two in a row. Fuck outta here if you think the flames couldnt have done the same.

If these are good goals, and the one bruins posted last night where the jets kick that shit in from damn near the faceoff circle then colemans shouldve counted too, either that or they all shouldnt count. But not a mixture, and thats the fuckin problem.
https://twitter.com/scottcwheeler/status/1530040346184454161
https://twitter.com/TheAthleticNHL/status/1448146408146571264


You honestly think they way flames performed over 5 games they'd be able to win three straight? Fuck outa here you are so delusional
Member
Posts: 27,447
Joined: Dec 19 2011
Gold: 8,732.50
#459
May 27 2022 04:06pm
Im more surprised by the fact that the ref on ice called it a good goal, and the puck was going into the net anyway and they've allowed far more balantant kicking motion goals that wouldn't have gone in otherwise. It's rare the see the league negate and reverse the ref on ice's call.

Like we've seen refs make poor calls live time, and upon review, everybody be like zomg noob he blind?! And they've stuck with the refs decision etc.
Member
Posts: 29,868
Joined: Mar 11 2010
Gold: 6,000.00
#460
May 27 2022 04:16pm
Quote (Subzer0isGG @ May 27 2022 03:27pm)
You honestly think they way flames performed over 5 games they'd be able to win three straight? Fuck outa here you are so delusional



Game 2 and 5 were easily coin tosses. Series could be 3-2 flames right now. It isn’t, we lost, but yes the league helped you along at the end.
Go Back To Hockey Topic List
Prev1444546474849Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll

© 2003-2024 d2jsp  Contact