d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Sports Coliseum > Football & Rugby > Most Overrated & Underrated Player On Your Team?
Prev12345Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 29,219
Joined: Jan 23 2014
Gold: 0.00
Oct 20 2020 09:53am
Quote (4killer7 @ Oct 20 2020 10:51am)
Overrated: Kirk the obvious choice, I'll go Anthony Barr for the not as obvious. Good player not great should definitely not be making the probowl every year like he does

Underrated: Brian O'Neil might be one of the best RTs in the league, Still incredibly young going to have a bright future if he stays healthy.


As a packer fan, barr gives me nightmares
Member
Posts: 55,176
Joined: Jul 21 2010
Gold: 15.80
Oct 20 2020 09:56am
Overrated : Troy hill. Somehow pff always has this dude ranked high even though he makes 5 absolutely boneheaded plays every game. He is a good tackler though.

Underrated : Goff. Give him a clean pocket and he has one of the prettiest throws in the league.
Member
Posts: 39,484
Joined: May 8 2017
Gold: 0.10
Warn: 30%
Oct 20 2020 09:58am
Most overrated- hrmm but I'd have to taysom hill. Hes an overpaid special teams player. The packages where hes at at qb absolutely make me cringe.


Underrated- has to be demario davis , never see him get any love and hes a top ILB over the last few seasons. Incredible in pass coverage and tackler. Heart and soul of that defence.
Member
Posts: 72,078
Joined: May 31 2008
Gold: 3,500.80
Oct 20 2020 10:00am
Quote (Vtrix @ Oct 20 2020 10:58am)
Most overrated- hrmm but I'd have to taysom hill. Hes an overpaid special teams player. The packages where hes at at qb absolutely make me cringe.


Underrated- has to be demario davis , never see him get any love and hes a top ILB over the last few seasons. Incredible in pass coverage and tackler. Heart and soul of that defence.


Hill is more overrated than Bree's? Or do you guys understand what a soggy wet noodle is now after the first few weeks?

This post was edited by Cheesehead on Oct 20 2020 10:01am
Member
Posts: 12,782
Joined: Sep 27 2013
Gold: 1,995.00
Oct 20 2020 10:35am
Quote (Cheesehead @ Oct 20 2020 11:00am)
Hill is more overrated than Bree's? Or do you guys understand what a soggy wet noodle is now after the first few weeks?


I don't think the thread is referring to overrated/underrated over the last 6 games, but lifetime results compared to how much they are paid/talked about.

That being said, yes Hill is way overrated and overpaid for what he actually does.

Most underrated would probably be Jameis Winston, because hes a backup being paid 1 mil only.

This post was edited by Zero501 on Oct 20 2020 10:36am
Member
Posts: 42,854
Joined: Oct 9 2010
Gold: 11,010.55
Oct 20 2020 10:37am
Overrated: honestly dont know, stafford hasnt been great this year but i hestitate to call him overrated, other than that we dont really have alot of players that are often considered good lol

Underrated: Golladay, even though hes gotten more recognition lately, i think he still doesnt get as much credit as he deserves.
Member
Posts: 72,078
Joined: May 31 2008
Gold: 3,500.80
Oct 20 2020 10:38am
Quote (Zero501 @ Oct 20 2020 11:35am)
I don't think the thread is referring to overrated/underrated over the last 6 games, but lifetime results compared to how much they are paid/talked about.

That being said, yes Hill is way overrated and overpaid for what he actually does.

Most underrated would probably be Jameis Winston, because hes a backup being paid 1 mil only.


Well considering the OP brings up a player that has only been with the team the last 6 games, I figured we were trying to be objective on the season. I agree that Hill is probably talked about more than any backup in my recent memory aside from Tebow and just hasn't done anything notable aside from fumble a game away. The fact that people were legitimately calling for him to start over Brees this last off-season is all you need to know about how overrated he is
Member
Posts: 12,782
Joined: Sep 27 2013
Gold: 1,995.00
Oct 20 2020 10:43am
Quote (Cheesehead @ Oct 20 2020 11:38am)
Well considering the OP brings up a player that has only been with the team the last 6 games, I figured we were trying to be objective on the season. I agree that Hill is probably talked about more than any backup in my recent memory aside from Tebow and just hasn't done anything notable aside from fumble a game away. The fact that people were legitimately calling for him to start over Brees this last off-season is all you need to know about how overrated he is


You may be correct about it being this season. I still don't think Brees is overrated. Pretty much everyone I talk to and listen to talks about how Brees cannot throw anymore, I think for the first time in a while he's actually being rated correctly, perhaps slightly overpaid but not when compared to his resume.



Member
Posts: 76,951
Joined: Jun 12 2008
Gold: 59,215.34
Oct 20 2020 01:58pm
Quote (bob(Cs2) @ Oct 20 2020 11:18am)
Gronk overrated
Lavonte David underrated for the last 10 years

Average fans have never heard of him because he was on shit teams, but his stats and impact is up there with Kuechley and Wagner.


Im not sure anybody who watches football thinks lavonte david is underrated
Member
Posts: 29,219
Joined: Jan 23 2014
Gold: 0.00
Oct 20 2020 02:00pm
Quote (Flopps @ Oct 20 2020 02:58pm)
Im not sure anybody who watches football thinks lavonte david is underrated


This lol
Go Back To Football & Rugby Topic List
Prev12345Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll