I had seen Prone make a similar thread on the hockey sub-forum and found it very interesting!

Most overrated: David Johnson. Being paid superstar money for his position. He's been a disaster this year.
Most underrated: Darren Fells. He's 34 years old and still makes all the big plays at tight end like he's 25.

Post the most overrated and underrated player on your favorite NFL team. Don't hold back. I want honest answers.

Most overrated: not sure really.. maybe stidham solely bc of the hype around him
Most underrated: Slater, without a doubt.. lost people who pay attention now how good he is but he's a key part to our leadership and probably the best/most consistent special teams player in the nfl.

Overrated: Engram, Tate, Shepard, Barkley. All equally bad and need to be traded

Underrated: everyone else


Team is literally being held back because of these clowns. Thankfully no Barkley rest of the year, shepard is more overrated due to how he plays..guy will never be healthy(decent player though), Engram couldn’t block my grandmother and Tate turtles whenever anyone gets near him.

Barkley is the only one I think can turn it around. He better fucking turn it around or he’ll never be healthy either. Guy needs to take the yards that are there before dancing, even if there are guys in his face. It’s about protecting himself more than anything else honestly. Can’t do that when you’re constantly off balance and contorting your body. Rbs are supposed to keep you ahead of the chains. He does the opposite far too often. Not worth it just for his big play potential.


One more tidbit. Read some article from some clown giants reporter talking about cam brown being a $70 million guy and the next LT or some shit like that. Guy has played like 6 defensive snaps all year. Looks like Eli left a huge stash of pot at MetLife stadium....good god

Barkley needs to learn how to block too

Kid folds in the pass rush

He’s afraid of contact...I’ve yet to see him try to run someone over. He refuses to run between the tackles. I’ve never seen anything like it...guy is 235 lbs and plays like he’s 180

Overrated: Stafford, has a cannon arm, but can't get it done.
Underrated: Kenny Golladay he's one of the best in the game, but you rarely hear him mentioned in talks about top wr's.

This is such a bad take. Stafford isn't your issue lmfao and people def put gollday in the top talks. Maybe you should actually watch football

Try harder please.

Don't really need to try to get a reaction out of you

I think Stafford is underrated. He's normally ranked outside of top 15 even top 20 Qbs.