JL Subwoofers outclass any of the offering from the other listed brands, thought there are certainly subs that outperform them db wise.. The best door speakers ive owned from any of these brands however were the Alpine Series X components.. They were paired with PDX amps and it truly was an incredible listening experience. If you want a matching set from a single brand, JL Audio.
Otherwise, I would shop JL for their subs and even their amps, but you can certainly find a better performing door speaker for not much more from other brands.
That being said you wont hear a full jl audio setup and be disappointed, you can just do better
Also all of that feedback is entirely dependent on your budget