d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Sports Coliseum > Baseball > Early Baseball Keeper League
Prev12346Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 43,836
Joined: Aug 2 2015
Gold: 44.20
Mar 16 2020 05:38pm
Quote (GSY @ Mar 15 2020 07:32pm)
I was playing golf and forgot i had a draft

Holy hell its bad


prob better than you would have done tbh

need some help on ranking these pitchers


My initial rankings are these

Castillo
Morton
Grienke
Paddack
Berrios
Beaur


these are my overall picks after 72 keepers

Bad Intentions

Round Pick Overall Pick
1 3 3
1 6 6
3 6 30
3 10 34
4 7 43
5 6 54
6 3 63
7 2 74
7 11 83
8 12 96
9 11 107
11 9 129
12 9 141
13 8 152
14 9 165
15 8 176
16 9 189
17 8 200
18 8 212
19 7 223

This post was edited by ianarky on Mar 16 2020 05:38pm
Member
Posts: 3,466
Joined: Oct 6 2015
Gold: 0.00
Mar 17 2020 01:00pm
Quote (ianarky @ Mar 16 2020 06:38pm)
prob better than you would have done tbh

need some help on ranking these pitchers


My initial rankings are these

Castillo
Morton
Grienke
Paddack
Berrios
Beaur


these are my overall picks after 72 keepers

Bad Intentions

Round Pick Overall Pick
1 3 3
1 6 6
3 6 30
3 10 34
4 7 43
5 6 54
6 3 63
7 2 74
7 11 83
8 12 96
9 11 107
11 9 129
12 9 141
13 8 152
14 9 165
15 8 176
16 9 189
17 8 200
18 8 212
19 7 223


I like Luzardo the most out of your list. He's got the highest upside and he's plain filthy. He also pitches in the friendliest ballpark in Baseball for pitchers. Only downside to him is he will be limited on IP this year.

Outside of that; I'd probably go Paddock/Morton (especially if you're in win now mode and just plan to dump him next year and retain a 1st)

Then I'd put Castillo/Berrios/Greinke//Bauer in the next tier. I probably actually like Berrios the most of this group; he actually knows how to throw strikes and I think he's only getting better.

Anyone who pitches in the great American small park is a risk.

This post was edited by Schwarber on Mar 17 2020 01:03pm
Member
Posts: 43,836
Joined: Aug 2 2015
Gold: 44.20
Apr 1 2020 04:08pm
Soto costs me my 3rd
Bellinger my 4th
Vladito my 5th
Flaherty my 6th
Yordano (of elig) my 7th
Tatis jr my 16th


SP Luis Castillo - CIN 1
SP Charlie Morton - TB 1
OF Luis Robert (R) - CHW 3
2B/3B Mike Moustakas - CIN 3
RP Julio Urias - LAD 4
C Yasmani Grandal - CHW 5
RP Taylor Rogers - MIN 6
SP German Marquez - COL 7
SP Matthew Boyd - DET 7
UT Edwin Encarnacion - CHW 8
RP A.J. Puk (R) - OAK 9
SP Joe Musgrove - PIT 11
2B Ryan McMahon - COL 12
SP Michael Kopech - CHW 13
SP Nathan Eovaldi - BOS 14
2B Garrett Hampson - COL 15
OF Yasiel Puig - (N/A) 16
RP Mark Melancon - ATL 17
SS Wander Franco (R) - TB 18
SP MacKenzie Gore - SD 19





This post was edited by ianarky on Apr 1 2020 04:17pm
Member
Posts: 3,466
Joined: Oct 6 2015
Gold: 0.00
Apr 20 2020 05:41pm
Quote (ianarky @ Apr 1 2020 05:08pm)
Soto costs me my 3rd
Bellinger my 4th
Vladito my 5th
Flaherty my 6th
Yordano (of elig) my 7th
Tatis jr my 16th


SP Luis Castillo - CIN 1
SP Charlie Morton - TB 1
OF Luis Robert (R) - CHW 3
2B/3B Mike Moustakas - CIN 3
RP Julio Urias - LAD 4
C Yasmani Grandal - CHW 5
RP Taylor Rogers - MIN 6
SP German Marquez - COL 7
SP Matthew Boyd - DET 7
UT Edwin Encarnacion - CHW 8
RP A.J. Puk (R) - OAK 9
SP Joe Musgrove - PIT 11
2B Ryan McMahon - COL 12
SP Michael Kopech - CHW 13
SP Nathan Eovaldi - BOS 14
2B Garrett Hampson - COL 15
OF Yasiel Puig - (N/A) 16
RP Mark Melancon - ATL 17
SS Wander Franco (R) - TB 18
SP MacKenzie Gore - SD 19

https://i.imgur.com/kwTVcOs.png

https://i.imgur.com/Zttj4EU.png



You didn’t draft Jesus; team sucks ;)

This post was edited by Schwarber on Apr 20 2020 05:42pm
Member
Posts: 43,836
Joined: Aug 2 2015
Gold: 44.20
Apr 20 2020 05:45pm
Quote (Schwarber @ Apr 20 2020 07:41pm)
You didn’t draft Jesus; team sucks ;)


yeah, i should have in the first round with the season delay. was kinda hoping he would fall to 3rd then keeper worthy
Member
Posts: 3,466
Joined: Oct 6 2015
Gold: 0.00
Apr 20 2020 05:56pm
Quote (ianarky @ Apr 20 2020 06:45pm)
yeah, i should have in the first round with the season delay. was kinda hoping he would fall to 3rd then keeper worthy


You set yourself up nicely for the future taking Franco/Gore in the 18/19th.

Also, I'd dump Hampson. He's basically useless. Idk what's out there but anything is better than a garbage utility player.

McMahon will be the starter til Brendan Rodgers is recovered and he'll take over (I think McMahon goes to 1st since Murphy will be a FA)

This post was edited by Schwarber on Apr 20 2020 05:56pm
Member
Posts: 43,836
Joined: Aug 2 2015
Gold: 44.20
Apr 20 2020 05:59pm
Quote (Schwarber @ Apr 20 2020 07:56pm)
You set yourself up nicely for the future taking Franco/Gore in the 18/19th.

Also, I'd dump Hampson. He's basically useless. Idk what's out there but anything is better than a garbage utility player.

McMahon will be the starter til Brendan Rodgers is recovered and he'll take over (I think McMahon goes to 1st since Murphy will be a FA)


ty. always appreciate you fbb thoughts. yeah hampson was a mistake and will be my first drop.

the only thing about the franco pick is will they actually bring him up now? wish we kept more than 6. I have high hopes for gore
Member
Posts: 3,466
Joined: Oct 6 2015
Gold: 0.00
Apr 20 2020 06:02pm
Quote (ianarky @ Apr 20 2020 06:59pm)
ty. always appreciate you fbb thoughts. yeah hampson was a mistake and will be my first drop.

the only thing about the franco pick is will they actually bring him up now? wish we kept more than 6. I have high hopes for gore


He won't be up this year (if there's even a season) but he's a steal for next year and the future for a 19th rd pick. He probably won't start the year next either with missing out on reps this year and the Rays will do everything they can to keep that extra year of control.

But I suppose you already have a pretty set 6 keepers with Flaherty, Bellinger, Vladdy, Soto, Tatis, and either Alvarez/Robert.

This post was edited by Schwarber on Apr 20 2020 06:05pm
Member
Posts: 43,836
Joined: Aug 2 2015
Gold: 44.20
Apr 20 2020 06:05pm
Quote (Schwarber @ Apr 20 2020 08:02pm)
He won't be up this year (if there's even a season) but he's a steal for next year and the future for a 19th rd pick. He probably won't start the year next either with missing out on reps this year and the Rays will do everything they can to keep that extra year of control.


yeah, but i have tatis at 16th and hard to keep someone who hasn;t tasted the big leagues. Franco does have a higher ceiling though. The season will make the choices ez, hopefully. and hopefully there is one
Member
Posts: 3,466
Joined: Oct 6 2015
Gold: 0.00
Apr 20 2020 06:06pm
Quote (ianarky @ Apr 20 2020 07:05pm)
yeah, but i have tatis at 16th and hard to keep someone who hasn;t tasted the big leagues. Franco does have a higher ceiling though. The season will make the choices ez, hopefully. and hopefully there is one


Yeah edited my post but forgot you have a pretty set 6 keepers with Flaherty, Bellinger, Vladdy, Soto, Tatis, and either Alvarez/Robert/Gore.
Go Back To Baseball Topic List
Prev12346Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll