d2jsp
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Entertainment Room > Movies & TV Shows > Official Game Of Thrones Discussion > Season 8
Prev1101102103104105109Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Blah58
#1021 May 22 2019 08:56pm
Group: Member
Posts: 38,874
Joined: Jun 17 2006
Gold: 10,358.00
Quote (fuzzy159 @ May 21 2019 11:49am)
What?

How do you know Sansa wouldn't have done the same if Jon was crowned instead of Bran?

She was about the North being separate since S6 no matter who was the King.


If Jon, the king of the North, became the King of the seven kingdoms, it makes literally no sense for the North to suddenly hate him...
Booyaka
#1022 May 22 2019 09:09pm
Group: Member
Posts: 8,060
Joined: May 10 2008
Gold: 750.00
Quote (Blah58 @ 22 May 2019 21:56)
If Jon, the king of the North, became the King of the seven kingdoms, it makes literally no sense for the North to suddenly hate him...


anyone other then bran would've made more sense


fk bran
fuzzy159
#1023 May 22 2019 10:55pm
Group: Member
Posts: 39,634
Joined: Jan 9 2007
Gold: 1,153.01
Quote (Blah58 @ May 22 2019 10:56pm)
If Jon, the king of the North, became the King of the seven kingdoms, it makes literally no sense for the North to suddenly hate him...


No one would hate him.... What are you even talking about....

Booyaka
#1024 May 22 2019 10:59pm
Group: Member
Posts: 8,060
Joined: May 10 2008
Gold: 750.00
Quote (fuzzy159 @ 22 May 2019 23:55)
No one would hate him.... What are you even talking about....


the only 1s who would hate him is the unsullied and the dothrakis


the whole north/wildlings and everyone else would support him 100%


7 kingdoms vs leftover unsullied and dothrakis


+ when they left basicly nothing they can do about jon being king beside hearing about it and coming back and get rekt by superior force
Kayeto
#1025 May 22 2019 11:09pm
Group: Member
Posts: 42,267
Joined: Aug 27 2009
Gold: 37,588.89
Warn: 10%
Quote (fuzzy159 @ May 21 2019 02:49pm)
What?

How do you know Sansa wouldn't have done the same if Jon was crowned instead of Bran?

She was about the North being separate since S6 no matter who was the King.


Quote (Blah58 @ May 22 2019 10:56pm)
If Jon, the king of the North, became the King of the seven kingdoms, it makes literally no sense for the North to suddenly hate him...


Seems like this line of responses are getting muddled a bit. The responses don't seem to line up directly with the previous comment. Tracing it back to the beginning:

Quote (Blah58 @ May 20 2019 11:24pm)
So is anyone else confused as to why Sansa said the North will never bend the knee again when the king of the realms would be a fucking Stark, and when they were pretty freaking ready to bend the knee to Jon?


Sansa bending the knee a Stark King of the 7 kingdoms would be inconsistent with the Northern philosophy for 2 reasons.

1- The North always wanted to be independent. Not connected to the other 6 kingdoms (not above, below or beside).

2- Even if a Stark was elected king at this council, his successor wouldn't have been a Stark (as the council state).
Blah58
#1026 May 23 2019 02:57am
Group: Member
Posts: 38,874
Joined: Jun 17 2006
Gold: 10,358.00
Quote (fuzzy159 @ May 22 2019 09:55pm)
No one would hate him.... What are you even talking about....


The fact that you think Sansa wanting the North to secede while their is a northern King on the throne makes any amount of sense.

Quote (Kayeto @ May 22 2019 10:09pm)
Sansa bending the knee a Stark King of the 7 kingdoms would be inconsistent with the Northern philosophy for 2 reasons.

1- The North always wanted to be independent. Not connected to the other 6 kingdoms (not above, below or beside).

2- Even if a Stark was elected king at this council, his successor wouldn't have been a Stark (as the council state).


1) No... It's never been "we want to be independent of the rest of the world" it's been "we want a king in the North" or "we don't want to bend the knee to a southern King"

This means that seceding from the 7 kingdoms while a northern King sits on the throne doesn't make any sense

2) moot point as we have no idea what will happen. Bran could live and rule for 1000 years. The Starks could set up a succession line. Or, of they do end up keeping the "Council choice" thing, it is probably not hard to keep the king a stark tbh. But really can't say so not worth really talking about.

This post was edited by Blah58 on May 23 2019 03:03am
-=vasya=-
#1027 May 23 2019 03:05am
Group: Member
Posts: 57,134
Joined: Mar 7 2006
Gold: 5,000.00
still cant get over how amazing was final, its been on my mind every night lol got a massive urge to rewatch last ep again but should probably wait and rewatch whole season later

This post was edited by -=vasya=- on May 23 2019 03:05am
Blah58
#1028 May 23 2019 03:17am
Group: Member
Posts: 38,874
Joined: Jun 17 2006
Gold: 10,358.00
Quote (-=vasya=- @ May 23 2019 02:05am)
still cant get over how amazing was final, its been on my mind every night lol got a massive urge to rewatch last ep again but should probably wait and rewatch whole season later


If you're being honest and not trolling, I'm glad someone could enjoy it.
-=vasya=-
#1029 May 23 2019 03:31am
Group: Member
Posts: 57,134
Joined: Mar 7 2006
Gold: 5,000.00
Quote (Blah58 @ May 23 2019 09:17am)
If you're being honest and not trolling, I'm glad someone could enjoy it.


100% honest, i thought it was beautiful, so well filmed. Rushed? yes but it was expected so i am not too upset about that at all, it needed to end and they did amazing job imo

Was very emotional ep for me, felt very sorry for Jon, while Sansa left a bitter taste in my mouth and everything else was just perfect

me and my buddy in the same boat, both of us enjoyed it while my other friends not so much

This post was edited by -=vasya=- on May 23 2019 03:36am
fuzzy159
#1030 May 23 2019 05:55am
Group: Member
Posts: 39,634
Joined: Jan 9 2007
Gold: 1,153.01
Quote (Blah58 @ May 23 2019 04:57am)
The fact that you think Sansa wanting the North to secede while their is a northern King on the throne makes any amount of sense.



1) No... It's never been "we want to be independent of the rest of the world" it's been "we want a king in the North" or "we don't want to bend the knee to a southern King"

This means that seceding from the 7 kingdoms while a northern King sits on the throne doesn't make any sense

2) moot point as we have no idea what will happen. Bran could live and rule for 1000 years. The Starks could set up a succession line. Or, of they do end up keeping the "Council choice" thing, it is probably not hard to keep the king a stark tbh. But really can't say so not worth really talking about.


Are you joking....

Sansa wanted to be Queen of the North. Whether it was Jon or Bran on the throne she would have asked. Jon being King doesn't mean the next king will be a Northerner....
Go Back To Movies & TV Shows Topic List
Prev1101102103104105109Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll