Quote (EA7 @ 19 Apr 2019 17:11)
Except, most modern literature on the subject shows that hormone therapy and SRS don't actually make a big difference in terms of depression or suicide rates. Whoops!
I don't think you've read the literature or you wouldn't be using outdated terms like SRS. It's GCS nowadays.
'Modern literature'? What does that even mean? The majority of it has been done in the last decade or so.
The biggest differences are made when someone transitions with the support of their family, doctors and friends. Social support is the #1 predictor of comorbid depression and suicidal ideation. Shapiro is a liar - you can check my profile for an analysis of his statement on this topic.
The literature does show a drastic improvement in feelings of discomfort and dysphoria in those who do.
Logically therefore the best thing for trans people is for people like you to stop being so fucking awful to them and for them to transition. Because the suicidal ideation is generally caused by a lack of social support and the dysphoria is effectively treated through HRT and, for some, GCS.
Quote
Becoming transgender, on the other hand, is pretty easy. You don't really have to put in much effort yourself. HRT just involves swallowing pills that you get prescribed. SRS is pretty painful and taxing, but most people don't even do it, and if they do, the surgeon does all the fixing for you. You just sit in bed and recover and dilate your wound several times a day. Who cares if you couldn't get a cute girlfriend as a man?
Not even remotely true. Learning how to do makeup, feminising exercise programs, vocal training, thinking about posture and mannerisms etc... There is a fuckton of work that goes into transitioning and most trans people engage in several of these things. You don't just swallow a few pills and get all cute and femme.
Shit hair removal... forgot about that shit. Hundreds if not thousands of hours of having your skin either fried or needles poked into it and then fried. Inbetween there's the constant all over shaving...
and thanks to the pink tax it's fucking expensive as well. Being trans as an American will literally cost you tens of thousands of dollars minimum.
And society will bash you for it. Your friends and family might just straight up reject you and society at large regards you and treats you with hostility.
Transitioning is anything but an easy road. It's fucking hard.
This post was edited by TransTankie on Apr 19 2019 11:48am