Quote (PhiRip @ Dec 3 2018 08:06am)
I think that honestly needs a revamp, but I like the values given for plate and chain. Actually, I believe that the values for leather and scale need tweaking, and of course padded should be added. There is really no way that vit is more useful on a scale and int is more useful on a leather. I'm sure those ratios were defined to allow players to gain as much total numerical defense as possible, but that isn't actually what's important. Also, I think it falls short because it rounds to the nearest 0.25, which isn't the same for daggers and clubs, so I don't see why they have to be rounded this way for armors either. Thanks for the foundation to build on!
Quote (Meridius @ Dec 3 2018 08:02am)
Hi community,
let us discuss this for the SC's best item list rating here.
my suggestion:
Robe:
1 Vitality = 0.10 EE, 1 Intelligence = 0.90 EE
Padded Robe:
1 Vitality = 0.25 EE, 1 Intelligence = 0.75 EE
Leather:
1 Vitality = 0.5 EE, 1 Intelligence = 0.5 EE
Scale:
1 Vitality = 0.5 EE, 1 Intelligence = 0.5 EE
Chain mail:
1 Vitality = 0.75 EE, 1 Intelligence = 0.25 EE
Plate mail:
1 Vitality = 0.90 EE, 1 Intelligence = 0.10 EE
Meridius, IMO this is a very logical way to do it and I think it's close for most of them. I understand why you want it to be = 1 every time, and now that I'm thinking about it... it should of course be = to 1 in each case!
This is my opinion below. (I think the numbers would have to be cleaned up, even if people agreed on my ratings, but if I rounded beforehand you couldn't really see what I'm trying to change I guess...)
I'm sure some people will disagree, so let's talk about it
BWConformity's general idea of vit/int value for ee armors...Robe:
Doesn't really matter, no amount of anything will be making this a Best Item in the tanking category
Padded Robe:
1 Vitality = 0.8 EE, 1 Intelligence = 0.2 EE
Leather:
1 Vitality = 0.75 EE, 1 Intelligence = 0.25 EE
Scale:
1 Vitality = 0.7 EE, 1 Intelligence = 0.3 EE
Chain mail:
1 Vitality = 0.8 EE, 1 Intelligence = 0.2 EE
Plate mail:
1 Vitality = 0.9 EE, 1 Intelligence = 0.1 EE