d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > d2jsp > General Help > Site Suggestions >
Poll > Topic Bumping System Idea > In Topic & Notification Section
Prev12345Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
  Guests cannot view or vote in polls. Please register or login.
Retired Moderator
Posts: 25,259
Joined: Apr 3 2014
Gold: 100.00
Trader: Trusted
Nov 8 2018 06:06am
The Ls argument is pretty much invalid for me, for one reason.
You can have only 3 topics active in the top 50 and until they fall down from Top, quite a few hours/days need to pass, so you technically can have only 3 active topics at all.

While the Diablo II Trading Section is way way more active. IF it would be implemented then it would be more useful for other sections and not for the Ls one.

I like how it is and vote against this suggestion, i pretty much agree with FreeUsername, it would be easier for people to get their +1 and just bump random topics without any trading intention.
The flood control is there but you still have to go to your topic and press the Bump button, your suggestion would make it one step easier.

This post was edited by Herolinda on Nov 8 2018 06:07am
Member
Posts: 14,445
Joined: Aug 5 2009
Gold: 312,018.35
Nov 14 2018 11:39pm
to the top
Member
Posts: 14,445
Joined: Aug 5 2009
Gold: 312,018.35
Nov 20 2018 12:53am
Bump

Please provide your individual input ^_^
I'd love to hear what everyone has to say
Good or bad :hug:
Trade Moderator
Posts: 26,718
Joined: Dec 20 2005
Gold: 82,000.00
Trader: Trusted
Nov 20 2018 03:10am
I voted No.
It will only allow user to violate the top 50 rule.
With your suggestion if for example I had 10 topics in USEAST and I can bump them all, I can just press the button easily ( lets ignore the flood control for a second ) and spam my topics in the top 50.
If everyone will do it, it will create chaos.


So like I said, No for me.
Member
Posts: 14,445
Joined: Aug 5 2009
Gold: 312,018.35
Nov 20 2018 03:15am
Quote (Yakir @ Nov 20 2018 03:10am)
I voted No.
It will only allow user to violate the top 50 rule.
With your suggestion if for example I had 10 topics in USEAST and I can bump them all, I can just press the button easily ( lets ignore the flood control for a second ) and spam my topics in the top 50.
If everyone will do it, it will create chaos.


So like I said, No for me.


Thanks for the input :D

You would still be subject to the 30 second post restriction.

But anyone can easily break the rules even now.
Because if you have 10 topics, nothing is currently preventing you
From bumping them all...
Just like now, you would have to be smart and continue following the rules
If it was implemented, it would be useful for people like myself with topics in LS trading, and in the d2 forums.

This post was edited by Terp on Nov 20 2018 03:15am
Member
Posts: 6,141
Joined: Mar 22 2016
Gold: 1,000.00
Trader: Trusted
Nov 20 2018 06:00am
How about, as long as you have 4 or 3 topics in the top 50, the other buttons are grayed out??

Voted yes - with modification :)
Member
Posts: 9,388
Joined: Jul 3 2015
Gold: 74.92
Nov 21 2018 02:50pm
Voted no


enough people spamming trades that they just permanently bump for post count without ever trading
Member
Posts: 11,852
Joined: Sep 21 2016
Gold: 108.00
Nov 21 2018 03:20pm
I say ya.. and move bumps to 2 hours.. ;)
Member
Posts: 14,445
Joined: Aug 5 2009
Gold: 312,018.35
Nov 21 2018 03:22pm
Quote (ium @ Nov 20 2018 06:00am)
How about, as long as you have 4 or 3 topics in the top 50, the other buttons are grayed out??

Voted yes - with modification :)


Great idea,
I'm not sure how much work it would take,
but to completely stop the problem of having too many topics in the top 50
It could be made where users are prevented from creating or bumping topics in any forum where they have the max number of topics in the top 50

Quote (Sakata @ Nov 21 2018 02:50pm)
Voted no


enough people spamming trades that they just permanently bump for post count without ever trading


Not everyone is diablo_clone

Quote (TkThakilla @ Nov 21 2018 03:20pm)
I say ya.. and move bumps to 2 hours.. ;)


I think the 4 hour bump restriction is just fine and should probably not change.

This post was edited by Terp on Nov 21 2018 03:25pm
Member
Posts: 13,136
Joined: Dec 26 2006
Gold: 44.69
Nov 22 2018 02:17pm
The bump button is good enough for me,D2 section is only place I could see use but even then just make a larger ft list instead of multiple topics interest in one item will bump your whole list and give more exposure
Go Back To Site Suggestions Topic List
Prev12345Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll