Extremely easy yes.

You touched on most of the main reasons. And whoever said nfc west super tough division.... Idk if that's the case anymore.

And the usual 'not enough games from Jimmy G'. Well I'll counter that and say wait till he has a full off-season under Kyle the offensive God Shanahan. Mix that with a draft where I can see Shanahan picking even more players for fit his scheme and a healthy Garcon.... Yikes. We're talking about a guy where his best options down the stretch were Goodwin and rookie George Kittle.

In the end you just have to look at what you see on film. Pocket presence, release mechanics, accuracy......
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=IYPKw6hTWMw

The drop off in Atlanta's offense shows that Shannahan at least knows what he's doing on offense.

monica

I like what I see and I love what I hear from the coaches and other players about his intangibles. Still, lets be fair. Give him a full off season learning the offense and building chemistry with teammates and a full off season for dcoordinators to watch film and scheme for him. We'll get a much better picture of what this is going to be.

Not enough info. 4 games is hardly enough data to make any kind of serious decision.

5 games actually, but I understand your point. Out of curiosity, do you think that 46 games would be enough data?

Let's say that after his 46th game with San Francisco, Garoppolo has won 24% of his starts, a 1.3:1 td/int ratio and 250 passing yards per game. Do you think that would be enough data to conclude that the 49ers should move on from him?

Idk if it's "extremely easy" to say yes

But I'm leaning toward this franchise being wildly successful with these 2 core pieces

I guess we'll just have to wait and see. The drop off will have to be massive if he's to match your numbers lol.
Let's say it's not a smoke cloud and Brady isn't close to 100% against the jags tmrw, better believe I'll be right back in this thread.

You missed a golden opportunity to dub it a "49asty"

damn you're right

i fucked up big