d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Sports Coliseum > Hockey > Official Detroit Red Wings Fan Thread
Prev1240241242243244332Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 30,755
Joined: Jul 9 2007
Gold: 15,354.00
Oct 20 2018 08:05pm
Quote (Stealth @ Oct 20 2018 10:02pm)
Wings had too many men in OT. Should be a shootout at best. That is, if they got through a minute of 4 on 3 OT penalty kill.


This is during the last fast break that Florida had that lead to the wings goal

http://i.imgur.com/SUj9Cn7.jpg


Until that fresh player or the player getting off touches the puck it's legal i think
Member
Posts: 27,518
Joined: May 10 2009
Gold: 13,891.00
Oct 20 2018 08:10pm
Quote (SicKid @ Oct 20 2018 10:05pm)
Until that fresh player or the player getting off touches the puck it's legal i think


Touching the puck has nothing to do with it. Here's why

That allowed Nyquist to have a chance at getting back in the play.
I could record it as a video instead. It gave Nyquist five strides that he wouldn't have gotten.

If the change is happening at the bench, then sure, don't touch the puck and you're good. But a competitive advantage was gained as a result of this early change. I am certain the ref supervisor will be in contact with them tonight.
Member
Posts: 47,299
Joined: Aug 27 2008
Gold: 30,500.00
Oct 20 2018 08:14pm
Quote (Stealth @ Oct 20 2018 10:10pm)
Touching the puck has nothing to do with it. Here's why

That allowed Nyquist to have a chance at getting back in the play.
I could record it as a video instead. It gave Nyquist five strides that he wouldn't have gotten.

If the change is happening at the bench, then sure, don't touch the puck and you're good. But a competitive advantage was gained as a result of this early change. I am certain the ref supervisor will be in contact with them tonight.


I agree that it helps Nyquist get back in the play but every team do it and it never get called.

Maybe it wad more obvious here because it was 3 on 3 though.
Member
Posts: 27,518
Joined: May 10 2009
Gold: 13,891.00
Oct 20 2018 08:15pm
Every team does it. But if you watch that play in real time, it's not even a close change
It's like the "neighborhood" play at second base in MLB. I mean you gotta be close.
Vanek was at the top of the circle when Nyquist jumped lol.
Member
Posts: 47,299
Joined: Aug 27 2008
Gold: 30,500.00
Oct 20 2018 08:18pm
Quote (Stealth @ Oct 20 2018 10:15pm)
Every team does it. But if you watch that play in real time, it's not even a close change
It's like the "neighborhood" play at second base in MLB. I mean you gotta be close.
Vanek was at the top of the circle when Nyquist jumped lol.


Yeah players are starting to abuse it but like I said I've never seen it called. Maybe they could paint a zone in front of the benches where the player needs to get in before the other players jump out ?
Member
Posts: 42,678
Joined: Jul 8 2008
Gold: 8,000.00
Oct 20 2018 08:22pm
Quote (Stealth @ Oct 20 2018 09:02pm)
Wings had too many men in OT. Should be a shootout at best. That is, if they got through a minute of 4 on 3 OT penalty kill.


This is during the last fast break that Florida had that lead to the wings goal

http://i.imgur.com/SUj9Cn7.jpg


Wow.

Florida must be pissed at that missed call
Member
Posts: 30,755
Joined: Jul 9 2007
Gold: 15,354.00
Oct 20 2018 08:55pm
Quote (Stealth @ Oct 20 2018 10:10pm)
Touching the puck has nothing to do with it. Here's why

That allowed Nyquist to have a chance at getting back in the play.
I could record it as a video instead. It gave Nyquist five strides that he wouldn't have gotten.

If the change is happening at the bench, then sure, don't touch the puck and you're good. But a competitive advantage was gained as a result of this early change. I am certain the ref supervisor will be in contact with them tonight.


Touching the puck determines if it's a penalty or not

If either the player entering, or the player exiting, plays the puck while the other is on the ice, the penalty is called. If the incoming or outgoing player is accidentally struck by the puck, it is not an infraction. In the NHL, substitution is allowed when the outgoing player is within 5 feet (1.5 m) of their bench.
Member
Posts: 42,678
Joined: Jul 8 2008
Gold: 8,000.00
Oct 20 2018 09:38pm
Quote (SicKid @ Oct 20 2018 09:55pm)
Touching the puck determines if it's a penalty or not

If either the player entering, or the player exiting, plays the puck while the other is on the ice, the penalty is called. If the incoming or outgoing player is accidentally struck by the puck, it is not an infraction. In the NHL, substitution is allowed when the outgoing player is within 5 feet (1.5 m) of their bench.


he was explaining why they need to change the rule
Member
Posts: 30,755
Joined: Jul 9 2007
Gold: 15,354.00
Oct 20 2018 09:48pm
Quote (KrWWW @ Oct 20 2018 11:38pm)
he was explaining why they need to change the rule


To be fair Flordia's bench is still on the defensive side with all their players behind Nyquist really wasn't as bad as you make it seem

Nyquist still starts at 0 speed hopping off the bench just gains a few feet from where the player getting off is at
Member
Posts: 42,678
Joined: Jul 8 2008
Gold: 8,000.00
Oct 20 2018 09:54pm
Quote (SicKid @ Oct 20 2018 10:48pm)
To be fair Flordia's bench is still on the defensive side with all their players behind Nyquist really wasn't as bad as you make it seem

Nyquist still starts at 0 speed hopping off the bench just gains a few feet from where the player getting off is at


did you look at the image that Stealth posted?

He's full stride
Go Back To Hockey Topic List
Prev1240241242243244332Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll