Who are the top 10 QBs?
More specifically, 8-10? I feel like the top 7 are somewhat indisputable (maybe not in a specific order though)

Mahomes
Burrow
Hurts
Allen
Jackson
Herbert
Rodgers

Then who?

Tua, Lawrence, Dak, Cousins, Watson, Wilson, Murray??

Based on just last year, Geno Smith.

Based on history, Wilson CAN still be top 10.

Based on a combination of both I say neither are top 10.

I guess if you're talking strictly on "name brand" of qb, then Geno wouldn't cut it. (I mean, it's Geno Smith, I get it).

But if we are talking about stats from last year, he would be up there in top 10. But once again, based on LAST year alone. If you dip into the way past, then obviously no.

For Russ, I think he'll have a bounce back year. I don't care if he has a bounce back year or not but that's just my gut feeling.

Burrow
Hurts
Allen
Jackson
Herbert

how many rings do they have?

pm me

If you had your choice of any QB for the upcoming 2023 season only, would Russ or Geno be in your top 10? Cost not a factor.

I guess that’s the best way I would evaluate my top 10 QBs right now.

Lamar Jackson
Josh Allen
Joe Burrow
Deshaun Watson
Russell Wilson
C.J. Stroud
Anthony Richardson
Trevor Lawrence
Patrick Mahomes
Jimmy Garoppolo
Justin Herbert
Tua Tagovailoa
Mac Jones
Aaron Rodgers
Kenny Pickett
Ryan Tannehill/Will Levis
Desmond Ridder
Kyler Murray
Bryce Young
Justin Fields
Dak Prescott
Jared Goff/Hendon Hooker
Jordan Love
Matthew Stafford
Kirk Cousins
Derek Carr
Daniel Jones
Jalen Hurts
Brock Purdy/Trey Lance
Geno Smith
Kyle Trask/Baker Mayfield
Sam Howell/Jacoby Brissett

So this is the list of the starting QB potentially for 2023.

----------------------------------------------------------------

Lamar Jackson
Josh Allen
Joe Burrow
Patrick Mahomes
Justin Herbert
Aaron Rodgers
Jalen Hurts

Pretty safe list above.

Now, to pick out 3 from this list below, it's all subjective. I think Wilson would still make the top 10. And it's a little bit homer (duh) but Geno would be in the conversation to be honest.

Deshaun Watson
Russell Wilson
Trevor Lawrence
Tua Tagovailoa
Dak Prescott
Matthew Stafford
Kirk Cousins
Derek Carr
Daniel Jones
Geno Smith

This post was edited by Slowtoanger on May 24 2023 11:05am

My exact reason for creating this thread. The bottom portion of top 10 QB’s is probably very subjective.

My bottom 10 would be:
Lawrence
Cousins
Tua

Lawrence, Cousins, Stafford/Tua for me. Tough to say