Its not enforceable, which is why the debate is if it should be allowed.

It is, and should be.

It’s not a debate, it’s you shaking your fist and shouting “I dislike this”

Again, if there’s a range, you can simply say “bin 25, if you have, if not no need”

you can also at any given time back out of the trade if the item doesnt suit you. lets say a trader offers a range item and the buyer rejects it in the trade window everything is fine as well.

also: from my point of view as a guy who has a lot of rando uniques and runewords for sale too; i typically sell the highest range items first and once i hit a low on the top "range" i edit it accordingly. that way customer happiness is preserved in always getting the highest bang for your buck.

also: listign each and every stat on each and every generic item would just utterly clutter threads, cause a lot of work and has no return value for any given party. so no.

Giving the range is basically the same as selling a "random". So it doesn't matter. If you don't want low then don't buy a random or a low-range item. Easy.

The way I look at this its basically the same way as them saying.

I have 20x of an item to sell...
Im selling them all for the same price if their specific stats are within this range x% to y%
Oh look at that..
10x of them are within that range.
Im too lazy to write down all 10 individually..
So im just going to write it down once and say I got 10x in stock
Since im selling them for the same price anyways.

Basically leaving it up to the buyer to assume he may very likely get the lowest % in that range.
And understand it doesnt matter because thats what he is selling it for.

I dont personally find any issue with this.
Its within my capacity as a buyer to not buy it if I dont want one that low for that price.

When I see those type of sales
i always assume bro is going to give me the lowest dog shit % in that range for that price.
I assume I will not get the higher ranges
And thats how I decide if its worth buying or not.
If its not worth it to me.
Then his loss as a seller for not being more specific.

This post was edited by spiltpuddin on Apr 3 2026 02:18pm

Using your own words, if it's not worth it you ignore it and move on. So just do that. No rule needs to be set in place. You either buy what you want or you don't, just like everyone else. Just ignore and move on.

Using my own words.
Thats basically what I said but in different words