Im joking lol but as passer hes far better.
He's more talented in terms of raw skills, I won't disagree there. He was the #1 overall pick for a reason. Hurts was a 2nd round pick who was benched in the national championship game in college for Tua.
With that said...Hurts has that dawg pedigree and winning edge that Caleb lacks so far. Hurts is cold. Doesn't smile, doesn't get excited over little shit. Just outworks people and does what needs to be done which is why he's a champion and has been to two SBs in 5 years in the league.
Caleb has 5 INTs in two playoff games and like a 50% completion percentage and terrible passer rating. He's still young though and will likely have great years ahead but so far his performance has been nothing special.
This post was edited by Sixers on Jan 18 2026 09:07pm