d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Sports Coliseum > Football & Rugby > Name Your Top 10-20 Qb's In The Nfl > We Ranked Top 5 & 1-10 Already
Prev18910111214Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Views: 950Replies: 130Track Topic
Member
Posts: 2,785
Joined: Oct 15 2010
Gold: 80.00
Warn: 10%
#91
Sep 22 2012 12:43pm
Quote (xnozx. @ Sep 22 2012 01:30pm)
Actually Eli's been ahead of Ben for a few years now. That's no slight on Ben though he's still better than Rivers.


no he hasnt rofl

if this is based on qb skills, i would take rivers over both of them

also why is stafford so high? and cam?
i would take matt ryan or maybe even schaub before them

This post was edited by KWyouknow on Sep 22 2012 12:45pm
Member
Posts: 3,356
Joined: Feb 13 2009
Gold: 0.00
#92
Sep 22 2012 12:49pm
Is this list on overall performance or what we think this year?
Member
Posts: 29,499
Joined: Apr 10 2009
Gold: 1,184.50
#93
Sep 22 2012 12:52pm
Quote (xnozx. @ Sep 22 2012 02:16pm)
New York Jets 1-1|Atlanta Falcons 2-0|Baltimore Ravens 1-1| Chicago Bears 1-1

?

:huh:


Yes?
Member
Posts: 9,412
Joined: Apr 29 2009
Gold: Locked
Trader: Scammer
Warn: 30%
#94
Sep 22 2012 12:53pm
Quote (xnozx. @ Sep 22 2012 11:44am)
Lol

He has easily surpassed Rivers... that's been evident for awhile now. And Ben > Rivers so that ranking doesn't make sense.

Eli is probably the second best QB in the NFL right now behind Rodgers. Once again this season he's playing as well as anyone.



There is no better QB in clutch situations.
There is no better QB in the 4th Q.
There is no better road QB.



He's answered every single question a QB could possibly have to answer. Every check on the list is complete besides league MVP and he's making a strong case after 3 games.

Not sure what else he has to do to prove it. It's time to stop hating and give him his due.




You have Brees up there who all he does every season is pad his stats no matter the score. Never comes out of blowout games. I don't know how many times I've seen this guy get garbage time TD's and ample yardage. Eli was pulled vs the Panthers. Wasn't Matt Ryan pulled vs the Chiefs? Can't remember.


You have Vick 11th ahead of Matt Ryan. Vick sucks. I don't know why you continue to overrate him.


I can careless what a QB has accomplished. That's my judgment on QB's and my list. Post-season success is a team effort.
Member
Posts: 59,137
Joined: Jan 19 2005
Gold: 26.51
Warn: 10%
#95
Sep 22 2012 12:53pm
Quote (PhewPhew @ Sep 22 2012 02:52pm)
Yes?


Wondering why you have those teams in your sig?

Don't understand the correlation.

This post was edited by xnozx. on Sep 22 2012 12:53pm
Member
Posts: 29,499
Joined: Apr 10 2009
Gold: 1,184.50
#96
Sep 22 2012 12:55pm
Quote (xnozx. @ Sep 22 2012 02:53pm)
Wondering why you have those teams in your sig?

Don't understand the correlation.


Im the football fan, the 4 teams i would be following and rooting for.
Member
Posts: 9,412
Joined: Apr 29 2009
Gold: Locked
Trader: Scammer
Warn: 30%
#97
Sep 22 2012 12:56pm
Quote (xnozx. @ Sep 22 2012 01:53pm)
Wondering why you have those teams in your sig?

Don't understand the correlation.


You say "Post your top 10-20" but whomever doesn't have Eli above players you don't like you claim a troll. Gtfo.
Member
Posts: 3,356
Joined: Feb 13 2009
Gold: 0.00
#98
Sep 22 2012 12:59pm
Since i have trouble making a list. i will do what homers do and say why matt ice should be ranked higher (as of right now) Highest qb rating in the league (average) this year and yes its only been 2 games.. 5 tds no picks.. atl hasnt had a rushing game so far... highest points per possesion in the league... great leader... home record.. 4th Q comebacks.. only knock on ryan.. No playoff wins... but hopefully changes this year.

This post was edited by hammerdanjbg on Sep 22 2012 01:00pm
Member
Posts: 59,137
Joined: Jan 19 2005
Gold: 26.51
Warn: 10%
#99
Sep 22 2012 01:06pm
Quote (Reckreation @ Sep 22 2012 02:53pm)
I can careless what a QB has accomplished.  That's my judgment on QB's and my list.  Post-season success is a team effort.


Post season success is a team effort but regular season success isn't?

So the fact that Eli's played great in the playoffs in his career means nothing? OK, lol.
Member
Posts: 45,936
Joined: Jun 4 2007
Gold: 0.00
#100
Sep 22 2012 01:10pm
Based on performance so far this year Stafford isn't even in the top 20, let alone top 10. Top 5 for interceptions and over/under thrown balls.
Go Back To Football & Rugby Topic List
Prev18910111214Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll

© 2003-2026 d2jsp  Contact