No man I'm really not delusional or homering.


Maybe you have to watch Eli play every game to realize it since the numbers don't back up his brilliant play, I don't know. Sure he makes a few mistakes/bad throws, every QB does.
There's no QB better during the pre snap other than probably Peyton.


I don't know what else Eli has to do to prove that he's an equal amongst those guys.


Peyton after the first game everyone had him #1 again lol. You can't rank anyone right now after only 2 games. It's impossible to do.

Right now I'd rank them like this

1a. Peyton
1b. Rodgers
1c. Eli
1.d Brady
2. Brees


People always give credit to Peyton for being so brilliant and making no name receivers into stars. Look at what Eli did with Ramses Barden last game. That's an example of what I'm referring to.

This post was edited by xnozx. on Sep 22 2012 01:57pm

His accuracy and decision making were definitely an issue the 1st two games but I wouldn't worry too much. He's a good young QB, I just don't understand how everyone not named Calvin Johnson isn't wide open or beating their man. Calvin is literally being triple teamed regularly.

I just think Stafford is trying to rely on Calvin's greatness and forcing passes that he shouldn't simply because he's made those plays countless times regardless if he's not open. It's a maturation process.

If he looks for other receivers more often he'll see open targets. Just have to trust them.

This post was edited by xnozx. on Sep 22 2012 02:08pm

I do watch him...

You can't put Peyton at #1 right NOW. That's stupid, he looked good in his 1st game but he's not #1 yet. Especially after that performance.

Rodgers
Brady
Brees
Peyton
Romo
Eli

You can't judge him off one bad game though which is my point. He's been #1 forever and the only question coming into the season was his health. How his neck would hold up.


What listing is that?

This post was edited by xnozx. on Sep 22 2012 02:11pm

We're talking, right now, as far as talent, performance, potential and execution.

Hence why Peyton can't be #1.

This post was edited by ReckCc on Sep 22 2012 02:12pm

stafford is #1

I don't get it though.

So this is a listing for this season thus far?

Rodgers
Brady
Brees
Peyton
Romo
Eli


How could you possible have Brees ahead of Eli or Romo? really Rodgers can't even be 1st if we're ranking based off 2 games, nor Brady.

I just think we should stop trying to rank them right now because we're running into way too many arguments and factors. One off-game is going to offset everything, it's pretty silly lol


I was just making an observation about Eli

This post was edited by xnozx. on Sep 22 2012 02:20pm

Are you kidding me.... Theres 4 qbs id take over Eli and its not even close.

And that's exactly why he's still underrated. It ABSOLUTELY is close. very close.

What's so great about Brees that you would take him over Eli?

Rodgers
Peyton
Brady

Are all obvious debates.


Rodgers is the most talented QB in the league. He's young, has all the tools. Other than him there's no one I'd rather have and only because of age would I take him over Eli. If I needed one game, Eli all the way. He's proven everything. He's proven all his doubters wrong.

What does Brady do better than Eli at this point?


Like I said before:



This post was edited by xnozx. on Sep 22 2012 02:31pm

This thread gets worse every day.