d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Diablo II > Diablo 2: Resurrected > D2:R Discussion > Ww Raw Test
Prev1111213141519Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 19,309
Joined: Feb 24 2018
Gold: 9,765.50
Jul 2 2022 01:57pm
I am testing and already big find:

Set youtube playback speed to 0.25 and go to 3rd second. WW does double hitcheck for 2 weapons at frame 4 now! The setup is 2x BA socketed with a Ral rune for fire damage to track as visiual indicator. You see two monsters hit as soon as I start a WW.

For now:
3.5fpa attack rate for 0 ias
3fpa attack rate for 2 ias

This post was edited by babun1024 on Jul 2 2022 01:58pm
Member
Posts: 22,679
Joined: Sep 3 2006
Gold: 40,582.00
Jul 2 2022 02:38pm
Quote (babun1024 @ Jul 2 2022 12:20am)
I am taken hostage by my GF tonight but a good guy in blizzard forums (Ubeogesh) did extensive tests:
https://i.ibb.co/mGQDzhC/WW-table.png
https://us.forums.blizzard.com/en/d2r/t/update-whirlwind-breakpoints-for-all-single-wielding-1h-and-2h-weapons/136394

Have a look there.


Oki, so we ditch shield like we always did cause boring.
So we use grief ba + Beast ba

Level 9 fana = 29 eias
0 Wsm = 0 EIAS

120*40/(120+40) = 30
30 + 29 + 0 = 59 EIAS

With 30ias grief it will average out between the weps if i understood correct?
(30+40)/2 = 35

With 30 ias grief ba one should then have:
56 EIAS. Which means one would handle 10% slow without missing a breakpoint.

However to counter golem or decrificity or holy freeze at 50% one would need:
- Total of 56 ias to counter 50% slow and will then hit 5fpa (each wep ofc, so 2,5 fpa)
- Total of 129 ias to counter 50% slow and stay on 4 fpa attack (each wwep ofc, so 2fpa)

You should not become chilled, cause u should have cnbf on ur gear. (chilled = 50%)
You should not duel enemies using both holy freeze and decreap, or golem + any other slow.
You should not duel people using extended slow above 10% in combi with holy freeze.
You should not duel people using decreap in either way.

So we are left at needing this to counter arach slow and 50% skill slow:
- 80 ias, 0wsm, 29 skill ias from beast to remain on 5fpa.

Did i understand it correct?
Member
Posts: 7,500
Joined: May 9 2019
Gold: 1,300.00
Jul 2 2022 02:42pm
Anyone have a tldr on this?

All I want to know is does 34ias grief zerk and beast zerk give 4fpa ww?
Member
Posts: 19,309
Joined: Feb 24 2018
Gold: 9,765.50
Jul 2 2022 02:45pm
Quote (gel87 @ Jul 2 2022 10:38pm)
Oki, so we ditch shield like we always did cause boring.
So we use grief ba + Beast ba

Level 9 fana = 29 eias
0 Wsm = 0 EIAS

120*40/(120+40) = 30
30 + 29 + 0 = 59 EIAS |30 + 29 - (0) = 59 EIAS


With 30ias grief it will average out between the weps if i understood correct?
(30+40)/2 = 35

With 30 ias grief ba one should then have:
56 EIAS. Which means one would handle 10% slow without missing a breakpoint.

However to counter golem or decrificity or holy freeze at 50% one would need:
- Total of 56 ias to counter 50% slow and will then hit 5fpa (each wep ofc, so 2,5 fpa)
- Total of 129 ias to counter 50% slow and stay on 4 fpa attack (each wwep ofc, so 2fpa)

You should not become chilled, cause u should have cnbf on ur gear. (chilled = 50%)
You should not duel enemies using both holy freeze and decreap, or golem + any other slow.
You should not duel people using extended slow above 10% in combi with holy freeze.
You should not duel people using decreap in either way.

So we are left at needing this to counter arach slow and 50% skill slow:
- 80 ias, 0wsm, 29 skill ias from beast to remain on 5fpa.

Did i understand it correct?

Yes, correct. The only thing wrong in your equation is that you subtract WSM.

For WSM 0 weapons I got exactly the breakpoints in that table:

0ias for 7fpa or better said 3.5fpa
2ias for 6fpa / 3fpa on two targets
20ias for 5fpa / 2.5fpa on two targets
63ias for 4fpa/ 2fpa on two targets

This post was edited by babun1024 on Jul 2 2022 02:52pm
Member
Posts: 22,679
Joined: Sep 3 2006
Gold: 40,582.00
Jul 2 2022 02:51pm
Quote (babun1024 @ Jul 2 2022 09:57pm)
I am testing and already big find:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IZnOjKbgE3s
Set youtube playback speed to 0.25 and go to 3rd second. WW does double hitcheck for 2 weapons at frame 4 now! The setup is 2x BA socketed with a Ral rune for fire damage to track as visiual indicator. You see two monsters hit as soon as I start a WW.

For now:
3.5fpa attack rate for 0 ias
3fpa attack rate for 2 ias


Cant w8 for assa test :D BOS, fast frames per direction with claws, -30wsm claws ^^

U can use the items i made for you on barb as well for test.
GC lvl 15 fana
GC lvl 9 fana
5 x scs 1 ias
1 x sc 5 ias
4 x scs 10 ias
1 x sc 50ias
3 x sc 100ias
1 x lc 7 all skills
3 x lc 5 all skills
1 x lc 7 shadow skills
1 x cap/hat 2000 defense, -20 damage, lvl 23 enchant charges
1 x sc 107frw, 107fbr, 107fhr, 107fcr, 205@ res, 63mdr, 63dr, 150% dr, 127ml, 127 ll, 235plr (NN die...)
1 x sc 491% ar, 1023 ar, 3026 ar pr lvl, 1 wirl, 63 teleport, +2037 defense, 205@, 127 cold/fire/light abs, 63mdr, 63 dr (NN die)
4 x shael trune
4 x 15ias jools
1 x suaywaya: 491% ar, 1023 ar, 3026 ar pr lvl, -100% requirments, 10fire dmg, 3 free socs
1 x suaywaya: 491% ar, 1023 ar, 3026 ar pr lvl, -100% requirments, 10light dmg, 3 free socs
1 x runic: 491% ar, 1023 ar, 3026 ar pr lvl, -100% requirments, 10fire dmg, 3 free socs
1 x runic: 491% ar, 1023 ar, 3026 ar pr lvl, -100% requirments, 10light dmg, 3 free socs

Should be easy to test with those^^
Member
Posts: 22,679
Joined: Sep 3 2006
Gold: 40,582.00
Jul 2 2022 02:54pm
Quote (babun1024 @ Jul 2 2022 10:45pm)
Yes, correct. The only thing wrong in your equation is that you subtract WSM.

For WSM 0 weapons I got exactly the breakpoints in that table:
https://i.ibb.co/mGQDzhC/WW-table.png
0ias for


I get the same as table as well when not including slow.

blablabla - (-30wsm) = +30 EIAS
blablabla - (10wsm) = -10 EIAS

One must subtract wsm.
-- = +
-+ = -
Member
Posts: 56,582
Joined: Sep 26 2005
Gold: 14,050.05
Jul 2 2022 02:55pm
Quote (gel87 @ Jul 2 2022 04:51pm)
Cant w8 for assa test :D BOS, fast frames per direction with claws, -30wsm claws ^^

U can use the items i made for you on barb as well for test.
GC lvl 15 fana
GC lvl 9 fana
5 x scs 1 ias
1 x sc 5 ias
4 x scs 10 ias
1 x sc 50ias
3 x sc 100ias
1 x lc 7 all skills
3 x lc 5 all skills
1 x lc 7 shadow skills
1 x cap/hat 2000 defense, -20 damage, lvl 23 enchant charges
1 x sc 107frw, 107fbr, 107fhr, 107fcr, 205@ res, 63mdr, 63dr, 150% dr, 127ml, 127 ll, 235plr (NN die...)
1 x sc 491% ar, 1023 ar, 3026 ar pr lvl, 1 wirl, 63 teleport, +2037 defense, 205@, 127 cold/fire/light abs, 63mdr, 63 dr (NN die)
4 x shael trune
4 x 15ias jools
1 x suaywaya: 491% ar, 1023 ar, 3026 ar pr lvl, -100% requirments, 10fire dmg, 3 free socs
1 x suaywaya: 491% ar, 1023 ar, 3026 ar pr lvl, -100% requirments, 10light dmg, 3 free socs
1 x runic: 491% ar, 1023 ar, 3026 ar pr lvl, -100% requirments, 10fire dmg, 3 free socs
1 x runic: 491% ar, 1023 ar, 3026 ar pr lvl, -100% requirments, 10light dmg, 3 free socs

Should be easy to test with those^^


Did they fix the horrid animation? Wwsin was the only reason I played d2 and when they butchered it I stopped playing. I might try again. No mb will still suck but if ww is buffed it might be manageable
Member
Posts: 19,309
Joined: Feb 24 2018
Gold: 9,765.50
Jul 2 2022 03:00pm
Quote (gel87 @ Jul 2 2022 10:54pm)
I get the same as table as well when not including slow.

blablabla - (-30wsm) = +30 EIAS
blablabla - (10wsm) = -10 EIAS

One must subtract wsm.
-- = +
-+ = -

Ok, it gets even more interesting. Even when I attack with 0 ias the first double hitcheck happens at 4th frame! So to be precise to counter 50% slow you don't need 129ias in total, 56ias is more than enough if you do short two hit WWs. You get hitchecks at frame 4 and 9 instead of 4 and 8 but you gain tons of flexibility in the matchup.

Edit: I confirmed BPs for -10 WSM war spikes as well. This table is definitive for dual wield:

Credit to the original person who did the work Ubeogesh from Blizzard forums.

This post was edited by babun1024 on Jul 2 2022 03:09pm
Member
Posts: 19,309
Joined: Feb 24 2018
Gold: 9,765.50
Jul 2 2022 03:11pm
Quote (VickIsSick07 @ Jul 2 2022 10:55pm)
Did they fix the horrid animation? Wwsin was the only reason I played d2 and when they butchered it I stopped playing. I might try again. No mb will still suck but if ww is buffed it might be manageable


I am moving on to WWsin but will start with slow weapons first. I'll start with a chaos suwayyah + jah+zod suwayyah for the slowest claw pair.
Member
Posts: 22,679
Joined: Sep 3 2006
Gold: 40,582.00
Jul 2 2022 03:19pm
Quote (babun1024 @ Jul 2 2022 11:11pm)
I am moving on to WWsin but will start with slow weapons first. I'll start with a chaos suwayyah + jah+zod suwayyah for the slowest claw pair.


There is suawaya on the sin i sendt you, as well as wirl via charm :)

Dno how my testing went lol, i just played with like 52 skill ias from bos + 295 ias.


Well, my(actually not mine^^) pc is struggeling, and so is this network.
I ran it frame by frame on youtube. This means 60fps... Not 25fps like we count the hits in.
By pressing space to pause video, then forward with DOT and backwards with COMMA

I noticed theese hits on 60fps:
Frame 6 = 2 hits
Frame 9 = 1 hits (at least i could not find more, maby 1 monster got hit again, maby i missed, dno forgot to put on miss marker^^)
Frame 16 = 2 hits
Frame 32 = 2 hits
Frame 42 = 2 hits

So lets say its 2 hits pr actual frame hit.
So it looks to slow down.
25/60 = 41% slower fpa

6 x 0,41 = 2,46
9 x 0,41 = 3,69
16 x 0,41 = 6,56
32 x 0,41 = 13,12

This post was edited by gel87 on Jul 2 2022 03:46pm
Go Back To D2:R Discussion Topic List
Prev1111213141519Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll