i don't see the point in this statement even if it's true. the event already occurred. i chose the green amp. there's no going back.. all you're saying is if i happened to videotape the event that every time i play the movie it will turn out the same.. i can't rewind life.

so far i've seen this thread 3 seprate times on 3 seprate days and on the 3rd time i "decided" through my own free will to post.

no, u were obviously meant to look at this thread on 3 different occassions, and not post until the third time because ur medical issue (I forget, but it makes u very tide) makes u do things in 3.

/e i justSWUNGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGG that one... but like u were obv meant to do those actions, than post about it being ur free will, so i could post this comment.

This post was edited by Magikarpet on Jul 22 2010 06:11pm

free will= anything you WANT to do...you can do anything you want but others may say its stupid/illegal.

Ironically came accross a NYT article about this exact topic.

"Here we are setting out on a regress that we cannot stop. Ultimate responsibility for how one is is impossible, because it requires the actual completion of an infinite series of choices of principles of choice."

But read the article for yourself, and if the philosophic arguments made are confusing, just get through them and the author will explain their meaning.

http://opinionator.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/07/22/your-move-the-maze-of-free-will/?hp

Hope you get something from it.

cant read now, but will

god is all knowing so it knows what you will do and how you do it before you; in the end you can call it whatever you want, but god already knows

Hmm if our lives are determiend by God how can probability exist?

I mean if i roll a die there is a 1/6 chance to hit a number, the more times i do this, the closer my results show there is a 1/6 chance.

If there were such thing as a God who pre-determined our lives, why do i not roll 27 x and get the same number? Or roll 1 - 6 in order every time since he planned it that way.

How do you figure?