Quote (balrog66 @ May 8 2018 01:09pm)
Regardless of Rouhani's puppetry status, Iran has made concessions in their dealings. It is only fair that we do the same. I know that doesn't rub the right way with the more Machiavellian Republicans, but you kinda have to if you want to avoid another pointless war in the ME.
It isn't like Iran is an actual threat to the USA. They might beef with Israel some, but Israel's had it coming for quite some time now. Israel does deserve one lesson in humility. There are very few who could even mount a threat to the US, and most of them are tooo dependent on the US or allied with them.
what are those concessions?
Iran was under threat of getting blown to smithereens if it pursued its nuclear development. Under the deal it could rapidly assemble a bomb after 2025 with a decade of preparation to set up the infrastructure to create the facilities and enrichment they weren't allowed. In exchange, we stopped pooping on their oil industry and as a result their elites and theocrats/oligarchs are turning into real counterparts to the saudi princes. Thats besides the cash we flew them.
From Iran's perspective, pursuing their nuclear agenda prior to 2015 was a treacherous path. They knew that Israel hung over them like a sword of damocles. Mossad was all too willing to assassinate scientists and America would bugger their infrastructure with stuxnet and everyone was on the edge of outright bombing Iran. They didn't have the protection of a neighboring China to enable their safety like the DPRK did. But with the Iran Deal, they've essentially been given a
safe path to a nuclear weapon, just after a decade of delay. Thats all Obama really bought, a few years. They weren't allowed to enrich weapons grade uranium or manufacture the components, but they were allowed to make the infrastructure that would let them rapidly enrich uranium, make the detonators, and as Trump pointed out- totally free to pursue missile tech. What would happen when 2025 rolls around? We'd have a nuclear Iran anyway, and a nuclear Saudi Arabia, and soon a nuclear Qatar and nuclear UAE.
For Iran it was really kind of a win-win. They got to hoard ridiculous amounts of money
and got to pursue their long term goals of nuclear development to ensure their existence and emergence as a world power. All by kicking the can down the road a few years.
Is a return to uncertainty better than a bad certainty?