I like fire best but I blow people with winds right now.

All charms average out to the same damage.

It’s all preference if you want consistent damage (ice) or if you want high highs and low lows (lightning)

Only benifit in my eyes to keep to 1 type is to build that prof and in time make more damage for it.

But honestly I would go for the highest ee/fg per tier and not worry about matching.

I've played with all best ingame sets, and imo earth is probably the one that I liked the most (wind secondly), Im using ice charms normally tho, but the reason im not the biggest fans of ice is because of the low crits at all times.
at least with earth and theother u will see some higher crits from time to time, so it's more eye-candy.

The least 2 favorized would be lights and fire (that lightset is amazing tho, but not much fun seeing 200hits with a 55 charm with 278ee...)

I would say fire is by far the worst of the sets, mostly because u have 3 monsters in total that are immune, so that makes it very annoying.

started off with Earth and moved onto Ice. both were good to me.

Fire has worst immunities yes but damage-wise it feels like it never hits low and always hits high.

Lights seem to outdamage ices. Put equally powerful charms together in a climb and lights will do more group damage.

Ices/ Earths are good for solo.

Fire > ice > earth > wind > light

Is how I see it

But that's just me

Based on popularity i think its like this:

Ice > Earth > Fire > Wind > Light

Some people want to see the world burn.

No pun intended ;D

Besides the immunes though, the gap on fire charms is the besttt! Imo

Btw wind just blows for me!

that is not the order to summon Captain Planet Silly.